Critical response The film received critical acclaim and Castle-Hughes's performance won rave reviews. Based on 155 reviews collected by
Rotten Tomatoes, the film has an overall approval rating from critics of 91%, with an average score of 7.77 as of October 2020. The website's critical consensus states, "An empowering and uplifting movie, with a wonderful performance by Castle-Hughes". By comparison,
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 top reviews from mainstream critics, calculated an average score of 79, based on 31 reviews, indicating "generally favourable reviews".
Margaret Pomeranz and
David Stratton of
The Movie Show both gave the film four out of five stars. Pomeranz said "Niki Caro has directed this uplifting story with great sensitivity, eliciting affecting performances from a sterling cast, and a wonderful one from newcomer Keisha Castle-Hughes."
Roger Ebert gave the film four out of four stars and said, "The genius of the movie is the way it sidesteps all of the obvious cliches of the underlying story and makes itself fresh, observant, tough and genuinely moving." He said of Castle-Hughes: "This is a movie star." Ebert later went on to name it as one of the ten best films of 2003. The
Los Angeles Timess
Kenneth Turan praised Caro for her "willingness to let this story tell itself in its own time and the ability to create emotion that is intense without being cloying or dishonest." Claudia Puig of
USA Today gave the film three-and-a-half out of four stars and praised Castle-Hughes' acting, saying "so effectively does she convey her pained confusion through subtle vocal cues, tentative stance and expressive dark eyes." The film has also been discussed and praised widely within academia. Anthropologist A. Asbjørn Jøn discussed a range of Māori tribal traditions that resonate within the film, while noting links between the release of
Whale Rider and increases in both New Zealand's whale watching tourism industry and conservation efforts.
Box office Whale Rider grossed US$41 million worldwide. • the Canal Plus Award at the January 2003
Rotterdam Film Festival. At the age of 13,
Keisha Castle-Hughes was nominated for the
Academy Award for Best Actress for her performance, becoming the youngest actress ever nominated for the award at that time (breaking
Isabelle Adjani's record at the age of 20). She held the record until 2012 when
Quvenzhané Wallis (at the age of 9) was nominated for that category for the film
Beasts of the Southern Wild.
Academy Awards: • Best Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes, lost to
Charlize Theron for
Monster)
Chicago Film Critics Association: • Best Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes, lost to
Charlize Theron for
Monster) • Most Promising Filmmaker (Niki Caro, lost to
Shari Springer Berman and Robert Pulcini for
American Splendor) • Most Promising Performer (Keisha Castle-Hughes,
winner)
Image Awards: • Best Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes, lost to
Queen Latifah for
Bringing Down the House) • Best Film (lost to
The Fighting Temptations)
Independent Spirit Awards: • Best Foreign Film (
winner)
New Zealand Film Awards: • Best Film • Best Director (Niki Caro) • Best Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes) • Best Supporting Actor (Cliff Curtis) • Best Supporting Actress (Vicky Haughton) • Best Juvenile Performer (Mana Taumanu) • Best Screenplay (Niki Caro) • Best Original Score (Lisa Gerrard) • Best Costume Design (Kirsty Cameron)
Satellite Awards • Best Art Direction (lost to
The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King) • Best Director (Niki Caro, lost to
Jim Sheridan for
In America) • Best Film – Drama (lost to
In America) • Best Screenplay – Adapted (Niki Caro, lost to
Brian Helgeland for
Mystic River)
Screen Actors Guild: • Best Supporting Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes, lost to
Renée Zellweger for
Cold Mountain)
Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association: • Best Actress (Keisha Castle-Hughes, lost to
Naomi Watts for
21 Grams) ==Legacy==