At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream critics,
When I Get Home received an
average score of 89, based on 25 reviews, indicating "universal acclaim". In the review for
Consequence of Sound, David Sackllah concluded, "Solange's latest mystifies and stuns, leaving you awestruck as she cements her legacy as a true generational voice." Israel Daramola at
Spin wrote that the album "is expertly crafted, curated, and aesthetically dazzling; choreographed, extremely self-serious and self-absorbed; intellectualized, sonically adventurous, but often feels too rehearsed and neat." Kuba Shand-Baptiste at
The Independent stated that it "give[s] voice to the endless frustration of being black in the world, to be punished on that basis, and to support the urge we all often feel to push back against it all". She added that "there are melodies slow enough to sink you into a state of tranquility, and beats hard and strong enough to push you to sway and dance while that happens".
Jon Pareles at
The New York Times observed, "The black solidarity that was Solange's strongest message on
A Seat at the Table is still there in 'Stay Flo' and in '
Almeda', where she praises 'Black skin, black braids, black waves, black days' and insists, 'These are black-owned things' over
rattlesnake drum-machine accents. But most of the album has her musing on more private, domestic matters and looking inward".
The Observers Kate Mossman wrote that "Solange has made a record that sounds at times like a collection of
demos – fleeting impressions of fluid,
contemporary soul songs that fizzle out the moment they're laid down, like a
Snapchat album. It's in keeping with the increasingly
avant-garde nature of R&B production today, which can be heard in everyone from
Frank Ocean to
Ariana Grande: songs feel like sketches;
hooks and
choruses matter less; and music is conceived, perhaps, with visuals in mind – in the manner of
Beyoncé's
Lemonade. This kind of music demands a lot of the listener – short songs are harder on the attention span than long ones. It's as though Solange is saying: here is a mood, and here is another… but perhaps, with our increasingly insular listening habits, a 'mood' is exactly what we want our music to be." In a year-end essay for
Slate,
Ann Powers cited
When I Get Home as proof that
the format is not dead but rather undergoing a "metamorphosis", with artists such as Solange utilizing the
concept album through the culturally-relevant autobiographical narratives. The album was placed in many year-end lists, and it was ranked 81st on
Pitchfork's 2010s decade-end list. ==Film==