Historian
David Roediger has outlined how works, beginning in the 1980s, from writers such as
James Baldwin and
Toni Morrison, began explicitly discussing "white identity's intricacies and costs". In 1999,
La Salle University's Charles A. Gallagher proposed that perceptions of a racial double standard were creating a "foundation for a white identity based on the belief that whites are now under siege". Two decades later, political activist
Leah Greenberg referred to a "white identity grievance movement". A 2016
New York Times piece, describing "a crisis of white identity", analyzed some of the complex political, economic and cultural interconnected factors involved with it: The struggle for white identity is not just a political problem; it is about the "deep story" of feeling stuck while others move forward. There will not likely be a return to the
whiteness of social dominance and exclusive national identity.
Immigration cannot be halted without damaging
Western nations' economies; immigrants who have already arrived cannot be expelled en masse without causing social and moral damage. And the other groups who seem to be "cutting in line" are in fact getting a chance at progress that was long denied them. In April 2019,
AP covered activist
Rashad Robinson's suggestion that 2020's
Democratic Party candidates needed to do more than address white identity, by transforming privilege into action that tackled inequality. Defensiveness, or
white fragility, have been described as a way of constructing a "blameless white identity". In 2020,
Julia Ebner, a terrorism and extremism researcher, outlined how the subsiding of alternative identities in individuals can cause white identity to become an "all-embracing" centralized medium for interaction in the world.
Study of the concept The study of white identity began in earnest as the field of modern
whiteness studies became established in universities, and within academic research during the mid-1990s. The work of
Ruth Frankenberg, among other significant concepts, considered the relationship between whiteness and white identity and attempted to intellectually "disengtangle each from the other". In 2001, sociologist
Howard Winant proposed how deconstructionist methodology, as opposed to abolitionist, could help re-examine white identity and its association to whiteness.
Trump presidency and Republican Party Since the mid-2010s, sections of media in the United States have increasingly associated white identity with the emergence of
Donald Trump's presidency.
The Guardian has reported on the 2016 appointment of
Steve Bannon in the Trump administration, in the context of his website being linked with an aim to preserve a white identity. In a party-specific analysis,
Jamil Smith, writing in
Rolling Stone, has suggested that under Trump's leadership, "
Republicanism is now inseparable from this corrosive notion of white identity." In 2019, historian
Nell Painter stated that the Republican Party had been committed to white identity for decades, and since its
Southern strategy. ==Extremism==