March's novels are psychological character studies that intertwine his own personal torment—deriving presumably from childhood trauma as well as from his war experiences—with the conflicts spawned by class, family, sexual, and racial matters. March's characters, through no fault of their own, tend to be victims of chance. He writes that freedom can only be obtained by being true to one's nature and humanity. Commenting on March's complete body of work, British-American journalist and broadcaster
Alistair Cooke wrote that March was "the most underrated of all contemporary American writers of fiction", citing the author's unique style as "classic modern" and stating that March was "the unrecognized genius of our time." Cooke himself championed the anthology
A William March Omnibus, which was published two years after March died. In 2009, only
The Bad Seed and
Company K were still in print. In 2015, the University of Alabama Press returned to print the three novels in the Pearl County series:
Come in at the Door,
The Tallons, and
The Looking-Glass.
Novels Company K Company K, published in 1933, was hailed as a masterpiece by critics and writers alike and has often been compared to
Erich Maria Remarque's classic anti-war novel
All Quiet on the Western Front for its hopeless view of war.
University of Alabama professor of American literature and author
Philip Beidler wrote, in his introduction to a republication of the book in 1989, that March's "act of writing
Company K, in effect reliving his very painful memories, was itself an act of tremendous courage, equal to or greater than whatever it was that earned him the Distinguished Service Cross, Navy Cross and French Croix de Guerre." In 2004, Alabama filmmaker
Robert Clem made a feature adaptation of the novel; the movie attracted local interest. The novel has garnered attention as a World War I classic in other languages also: in 1967 it was translated into Italian for editor Longanesi as "
Fuoco!" ("
Fire!") and in 2008, it was translated into
Dutch and published in a series called "The Library of the First World War."
The Bad Seed The Bad Seed, published in April 1954, was a critical and commercial success, and introduced
Rhoda Penmark, an eight-year-old
sociopath and burgeoning
serial killer. The novel became an instant bestseller and was widely praised by critics for its use of suspense and horror. James Kelley writes, for
The New York Times Book Review, "
The Bad Seed scores a direct hit, either as exposition of a problem or as a work of art. Venturing a prediction and a glance over the shoulder: no more satisfactory novel will be written in 1954 or has turned up in recent memory." Although March lived long enough to see the critical praise bestowed upon the novel and hear of its commercial success, he died before the novel's full impact became apparent. Referring to the author's repressed homosexuality, cultural historian
Foster Hirsch opines that in this novel's "incendiary melodrama, March transferred his own hidden sexuality into the story of the bad seed...a child who kills and who has inherited her evil nature from her grandmother, a serial murderer." Hirsch goes on to observe that March's story raises the question--in the mid-1950s: "is homosexuality determined at birth, or is it caused by environmental conditions such as an overbearing mother and an absent father?" adapted into a successful and long-running Broadway
play by
Maxwell Anderson, He won four
O. Henry Awards for his short stories, tied for the most wins by any author up until that time.
Trial Balance: The Collected Short Stories of William March collects many of March's short stories from his entire career. The book was published in 1987 by the
University of Alabama Press, with an introduction by Rosemary Canfield-Reisman. None of March's story collections is currently in print. A little book with a March story, "The First Sunset", was printed in a limited edition of 150 copies by Cincinnati printer and writer
Robert Lowry's Little Man Press.
99 Fables Six years after March's death, his
99 Fables were published by the University of Alabama Press. March's
fables follow those of
Aesop: according to a review in
The New York Times Book Review, "Mr. March ... has picked up where Aesop and
Don Marquis left off." Allen King, however, reviewing the book for the
South Atlantic Bulletin, said the fables are "platitudinous" and offer no new insights into the nature of man. The cover won an award at the 1960 Southern Books Competition; the book is not currently in print. ==Biographical studies==