Minor leagues (1949–51) Mizell's first team was the
Albany Cardinals of the
Class D Georgia–Florida League. His first pitch for the team sailed 20 feet over the
backstop. Overcoming homesickness, he went on to help Albany win the
pennant. He had a 12–3
record and a 1.95
earned run average (ERA) for Albany, recording 175 strikeouts in 141
innings pitched. He struck out 227 batters in 207 innings, leading Winston-Salem to a championship. With a record of 99–61, Houston won the pennant by 13.5 games over the
San Antonio Missions.
St. Louis Cardinals (1952–53, 1956–60) 1952–53 When he joined the Cardinals, broadcaster
Harry Caray started calling him "Vinegar Bend," and the nickname stuck. He gave up two runs in the first inning, then held the Reds scoreless for the rest of the game, though he took the loss in a 2–1 defeat. Two
starts later, on May 2, he limited the
Philadelphia Phillies to four hits and two runs in a
complete game, winning in the ninth when
Peanuts Lowrey broke a 2–2 tie with an
RBI-
single. After that win, he lost three games in a row, then received four consecutive
no decisions. That started a streak of six decisions won in a row, during which time Mizell posted a 3.05 ERA. He would not lose again until August 27. Mizell finished his rookie season with a 10–8 record and a 3.65 ERA in 30 starts. Mizell won his first start of 1953, coming within an out of throwing a complete game on April 22 against Cincinnati in an 8–3 victory. On April 28, he held the Phillies to one run for five innings in a tie, as rain forced the game to be called and it was never resumed. His most notable game of the season came on May 4, when he gave up just two hits in a shutout of the Pirates. On August 7, he held the
New York Giants to one run in a complete game, 2–1 triumph. Exactly one week later, he held Cincinnati to one run over nine innings, but the Cardinals only scored one for him. After throwing a scoreless 10th, Mizell took the loss in the 11th when
Roy McMillan had an RBI single against him. His 11 strikeouts in that contest were a season-high, and he also had five games in which he had nine, including each of his last two starts. In 33 starts, he had a 13–11 record.
Military service (1954–55) With the
Korean War occurring, Mizell had been drafted to serve in the
United States Army as early as 1952, but he managed to get his service deferred twice because he was the support for his mother and grandmother. Finally, shortly after the 1953 season ended, he reported to
Fort McPherson,
Georgia, where he would be stationed for the next two years. He set records for most strikeouts in a game (15) and in a season (206). With a 12–9 record and a 2.16 ERA, he finished second in
most valuable player (MVP) voting. In February, his wife gave birth to their first son. Mizell found out during one of the games and, according to one story, was so excited that he absentmindedly went to hit holding his glove instead of a baseball bat. His first outing back on April 17 was triumphant, as he allowed 12 hits but just two runs and came within one out of a complete game in a 4–2 victory over the
Cincinnati Redlegs. From May 21 through June 9, he won five straight games, though he followed that up with three straight losses from June 15 through June 26. During the winning streak, in the second game of a May 27
doubleheader, he struck out 10 hitters in a 12–2 victory over the
Chicago Cubs. In the first game of a doubleheader against Pittsburgh on August 23, he threw a four-hit shutout in a 3–0 victory. On September 7, 1956, facing the Redlegs, who were second to the Braves in a close pennant race, Mizell threw a two-hit shutout in a 1–0 victory. Six days later, he threw his second consecutive shutout, beating the Giants 5–0 and allowing just four hits. He had a 3.62 ERA for the Cardinals in 1956, and his 14–14 mark was reflective of St. Louis's .500 record. Assessing the Cardinals' pennant chances during 1957 spring training, manager
Fred Hutchinson said, "We've got at least three pitchers capable of winning 20-Herm Wehmeier, Sam Jones, and Vinegar Bend Mizell. If a couple of them can do it, we'll make plenty of trouble." Mizell's fastball had slowed a bit in 1956, and it was even slower in 1957. He was giving up more home runs than he had before he joined the Army, and the Cardinals were worried about his weight and his
windup motion. Mizell spent much of the early part of the season in the
bullpen, and the Cardinals even attempted to send him to Houston, but they were unable to get him through
waivers. They had him watch films of his pitching, not common practice at the time, to help him correct his mistakes. "That thing with Mizell in Brooklyn, I just wanted to get him over a hump," Hutchinson later explained. Called on for a start on July 29, he held the Pirates to two hits in a 4–0 shutout victory. Thereafter, most of his appearances would be starts. His ERA after July 27 was 2.54. Then, on July 12, he threw a shutout in a 2–0 win over the Pirates. He had a pitching duel against
Joe Nuxhall of Cincinnati in the first game of a doubleheader on September 1; Mizell prevailed 1–0, setting an NL record for most walks in a shutout with nine. In 30 games (29 starts), he had a 10–14 record, 80 strikeouts, and 91 walks in innings pitched.
Sports Illustrated reported, "Mizell and Larry Jackson (baseball)|[Larry] Jackson had impressive ERAs between them but lost more than they won." After working out at the
YMCA across from
Busch Stadium during the 1958–59 offseason, Mizell showed a stronger fastball in 1959. He had eight strikeouts in the second game of a doubleheader against Philadelphia on June 7, limiting the Phillies to five hits in a 2–0 shutout victory. In the first half of the season, he enjoyed a 9–3 record and a 3.05 ERA. However, he did not appear in either game. He won just twice more all season, as he dealt with back problems. On August 1, he again struck out eight Phillies but received a no decision, as he was removed with one out in the ninth and the game tied 1–1. The Cardinals won on a
Stan Musial home run in the bottom of the inning. In 31 games (30 starts), he had a 13–10 record, a 4.20 ERA, 108 strikeouts, and 89 walks in innings pitched.
Pittsburgh Pirates (1960–62) Mizell's trade to the Pirates was one of the catalysts of Pittsburgh's championship run that season. On the strength of two shutouts, he pitched 30 consecutive scoreless innings from July 22 to August 9, the longest such streak of his career. The first shutout may have been his best game of the season; he held the Cubs to two hits in a 4–0 victory on July 29. On September 18, he won another 1–0 game, limiting Cincinnati to three hits in nine innings. His only other appearance came in Game 6, when he pitched a scoreless fourth and fifth inning's in Pittsburgh's 12–0 defeat. Despite posting a 15.43 ERA, Mizell became a World Series champion for the only time in his career, as the Pirates clinched the series in Game 7 on
Bill Mazeroski's game-ending home run. Indeed, he got off to a 4–1 start, posting a 3.57 ERA through May 24. He lost seven straight decisions through the end of July, getting moved to the bullpen and only making two starts between June 15 and July 27. Mizell started two more games that month but lost both and was used only twice in September, as a relief pitcher. His second appearance with the team (on May 15) was a start, though, in which he allowed four runs (three earned) in six innings against the Cubs. Though he got a no decision, the Mets won 6–5. Against the expansion
Houston Colt .45's on June 14, he pitched "rather well" according to sportswriter
Louis Effrat, throwing six scoreless innings after starter
Jay Hook was unable to record an out in a 10–2 defeat. He failed to win a game with the Mets, however, posting a 7.34 ERA in 17 games (two starts) before getting released on August 4. Pittsburgh did not recall him after the season. Mizell participated in the Arizona Instructional League following the 1962 season, but when no teams signed him in 1963, he retired.
Pitching style Mizell stood . A hard thrower, he had a loose and easy throwing motion. The fastball moved closer to left-handed hitters, and the curveball went low and farther away on them. Mizell also threw a
slider. Control problems plagued him throughout his career, though these were not as bad in 1960. ==Political career==