1951–1990: Early conflict Conflict over songwriting credits and
royalty payments has engulfed "Wimoweh" and "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" ever since their release. The earliest dispute dates to around 1951. Upon learning that Solomon Linda would not be granted songwriting royalties, Pete Seeger objected, insisting that Linda, as the "true" author of "Wimoweh", should receive his due. He directed his publisher to send Linda the royalties, at one point dispatching a
$1,000 check himself. Linda's daughters later denied that consistent payments for "Wimoweh" had been made ever since the 1950s. Nonetheless, Seeger stated that "I never got author's royalties on 'Wimoweh'. ... I assumed [the song's publishers] were keeping the publisher's fifty percent and sending the rest". In 1971, The Richmond Organization acknowledged that the song was based on "Mbube", and since then, Linda's family has received royalty payments totalling 12.5 percent of "Wimoweh"'s overall earnings. The next dispute concerned the Tokens' revision. Hugo Peretti, Luigi Creatore, and George David Weiss credited "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" solely to themselves, thinking the Weavers' tune was based on traditional African music and hence could not be copyrighted, which was untrue. The dispute made its way to court a year later. Here, litigants representing The Richmond Organization argued that the 1961 permission was "inaccurate", and tried to expose Weiss for adapting Linda's "Mbube" without making due payments to Linda's family. The court eventually ruled in favour of Weiss' team, with Judge John Keenan declaring their adaptation of "Wimoweh" a separate composition. While Weiss' team retained rights over "The Lion Sleeps Tonight", the court ordered they send ten percent of performance royalties—profits made whenever the composition was broadcast—to Linda's family. By 1992, Abilene Music had acquired the rights to "The Lion Sleeps Tonight".
Early 2000s: Linda rediscovered In spite of the song's immense fame, Linda's family had earned very little in royalties, and Linda himself had been all but forgotten. Due to this, in 2000, South African journalist Rian Malan penned an essay for
Rolling Stone which shed light on the origins of "The Lion Sleeps Tonight". He told the story of "Mbube", its eventual rise to success, and the struggles faced by Linda's daughters, and concluded that "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" had earned some $15 million in royalties. Two years later, fellow South African
François Verster composed a documentary about Linda and "Mbube", ''
A Lion's Trail''. In writers Håvard Ovesen and Adam Haupt's view, it "seeks to obtain justice for a man marginalised by his status as a black African musician in a racist and exploitative environment". Both Malan's essay and Verster's documentary publicised Linda's history. Five of his eight children had died. But with Malan's article sparking public interest in their condition, they decided to act. They started publicly calling for the royalties from "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" they, in their view, were due. The
South African government supported their cause, and the Gallo Record Company vowed to pay their legal fees. The family also demanded 6 million rand from three South African companies profiting from royalties. Owen Dean, a South African lawyer who steered their case, argued that they received some $15,000 in royalties from 1991 to 2000, roughly spanning the period of
The Lion Kings success, while the song earned an estimated total of $15 million. "There has ... been a misappropriation of South African culture—the song is thought to be American", he said. It also maintained that Abilene Music, which held the US copyright to "The Lion Sleeps Tonight", had given it the rights to use the song. Dean argued that Abilene Music was still liable for copyright infringement since under the
Copyright Act 1911, the rights had reverted to Linda's heirs 25 years after his death.
Billboard wrote in 2004 that depending on the outcome, the Lindas' effort could shift the fortunes of other South African artists who had unawaredly ceded their rights. The case garnered attention all over the world, and a trial was set for February 2006. But shortly before the opening date, it was settled. Abilene Music agreed to pay the family a lump sum representing royalties earned from 1987 onward and grant them a share of future income until 2017. While the amount was not made known, the family's lawyers claimed that the family "should be quite comfortable". Linda was recognized for his work and received a cowriting credit on "The Lion Sleeps Tonight". South Africa's
East Coast Radio suggests that the case stirred on other families of artists, such as
Bob Marley's, to consider legal action. In an act separate from the case in September 2004, The Richmond Organization admitted to not paying enough royalties to Linda's heirs for a version of "Mbube", promising to donate $3,000 annually and finance a memorial to Linda. Musicologist Carol A. Muller notes that Linda enjoyed no legal rights as a black South African in the pre-
apartheid years of segregation. However, by the time his family filed a lawsuit, apartheid had been abolished, and South Africa become a democracy. In 2012, "Mbube" fell into the public domain in South Africa. According to a grandson of Linda, the family made approximately between $20,000 and $65,000 per year from "Lion Sleeps Tonight" while the settlement terms were active, while another source indicates that each daughter earned around $250,000 in the decade following the settlement. As of 2020, "The Lion Sleeps Tonight" continued to cause legal conflict. The Linda family's settlement with Disney became void in 2017, keeping them from profiting from the 2019 film
The Lion King that sampled an alternate version the song. Linda's grandson stated, "There was no courtesy of informing the family about inclusion of a new version of the song in the movie. And we are not convinced the family is not supposed to derive revenue from the use of a new version of 'The Lion Sleeps Tonight' and are currently in the process of procuring legal advice." Nonetheless,
Rolling Stone estimates that Linda's heirs would have only received a few thousand dollars in royalties from the film. == Legacy ==