Teitel was arrested in
Jerusalem's
Har Nof neighborhood on October 7, 2009, while posting
flyers praising the
2009 Tel Aviv gay centre shooting. He attempted to throw away a bag he was carrying, but it was retrieved, and was found to contain two
handguns. Teitel was then turned over to
Shin Bet for interrogation, while special police units raided his home and the homes of his brother-in-law, parents, and mother-in-law. The search of his property revealed a cache of guns, parts used in
explosive devices, pellets used to maximize the impact of explosives,
binoculars, and flyers containing
anti-gay incitement. The explosives were all detonated safely by the police, and a search of his home two days later found a
bomb buried in the backyard. In addition to Teitel's confession, his
DNA was found to match DNA retrieved from Sternhell's home after the bombing attack. Teitel was also suspected of murdering two police officers in the
Jordan Valley, and confessed to the
gay centre shooting in Tel Aviv in 2009, though police stated that they were certain he was not involved in either. Following the discoveries, Teitel was held by Shin Bet in special custody for 48 hours, without being allowed to see an
attorney or brought before a judge. The
Petah Tikva District Court denied appeals from his attorney to meet with him, and subsequently extended both his remand and the special ordnance banning him from meeting his lawyer. All of Teitel's
arraignments were held behind closed doors, and a
gag order was imposed on the case. Teitel's legal defense was provided by
Honenu, an organization which provides legal defense for Israelis accused of crimes against Arabs or the Israeli security forces. Honenu founder Shmuel Meidad suggested that Teitel may be
mentally unstable, stating that, "It's my impression that this man is sick, but he's not nearly as sick as the state." On 4 May 2010, Jerusalem's district
psychiatrist ruled Teitel unfit to stand trial. The evaluation was criticized by
Israeli-Arab Knesset members, with
Ahmad Tibi stating, "An Arab who shoots a Jew in Israel is a terrorist, but a Jew who shoots Arabs is insane." Following a new psychiatric evaluation, the district court overturned the previous ruling, and declared Teitel fit for trial, on 30 August. == Conviction ==