There have been a number of Japanese court cases related to smoking, either directly or indirectly related to JT.
1980–1987 JNR Shinkansen lawsuit A group of nonsmokers sued at the
Tokyo District Court demanding that
Japanese National Railways shinkansen (bullet trains) provide more non-smoking cars. The case was filed in 1980 and while the court recognized tobacco's health risks the 27 March 1987 ruling rejected the lawsuit on the basis that the plaintiffs had failed to prove their harm to be "beyond the limits of toleration".
1998–2005 Tokyo lawsuit In 1998 seven plaintiffs represented by lawyer Yoshio Isayama sued JT at the Tokyo District Court for ¥70 million compensation (¥10 million per plaintiff) for health damage caused by smoking JT cigarettes. While similar cases had been filed in
Nagoya, this was the first such case in Tokyo. In addition to financial compensation, the plaintiffs also demanded: • That tobacco sales through vending machines be banned; • That advertising on television and radio be stopped; • That promotions at public and sports events be halted; • That a more stringent warning label be printed on cigarette boxes. The plaintiffs' case was dismissed by the district court on 21 October 2003. The court agreed with the 1980s ruling that tobacco had health risks, but said that there was no causal link between the smoking habits and the specific diseases of plaintiffs. In addition, Judge Kikuo Asaka denied that
nicotine was highly addictive. Isayama said that the group would appeal the decision to the
Tokyo High Court. On 22 June 2005 the Tokyo High Court dismissed the case; by that time brought by only six plaintiffs. Three of the plaintiffs had died during the course of the case. Judge Toshinobu Akiyama said he agreed with the District Court decision. Jun Araki, the son of one of the deceased plaintiffs, said: "This ruling placed priority on the annual 2.3 trillion yen in [tobacco] tax revenue over the precious lives and health of the Japanese people". He also said the plaintiffs would appeal to the
Supreme Court. ===2005–2010
Yokohama lawsuit=== In January 2005 plaintiffs Kenichi Morishita, Koreyoshi Takahashi, and Masanobu Mizuno filed a case in the
Yokohama District Court against JT seeking ¥30 million in damages for smoking related illness. Morishita died of pneumonia while the case was being fought, and JT used the same argument as in the 1998–2005 Tokyo case, that smokers were free to quit any time and that cancer and other illnesses had multiple causes. On 20 January 2010 the court clearly ruled that there was a link between smoking and
lung cancer and respiratory illnesses, and said that smoking may be addictive. However, the court rejected the demand for damages, and said that the plaintiffs had smoked of their own free will and that there was no proof that smoking had directly caused their sicknesses. ==Brands==