Reviewing
New York for
Rolling Stone,
Anthony DeCurtis described the album's songs as "fierce, poetic journalism" and found that Reed shows a newfound "political outlook that grounds his work and lessens his characteristic detachment", concluding that "whenever anyone wants to hear the sound of the Eighties collapsing into the Nineties in the city of dreams,
New York is where they'll have to go."
New Musical Express also voted
New York the third best album of 1989 on
their critics' list for that year. "Whether or not you buy Reed's line about
New York being a single integrated experience 'like a book or a movie'," remarked
Q in its end-of-year round-up, "this is indisputably one of the landmark albums of an inconsistently brilliant career." In a 1995 reappraisal,
Qs Bill Prince noted that
New York "signalled the beginning of the defrosting of Reed's
Velvet Underground past that has so far marked out his '90s." Mark Deming wrote in his review for
AllMusic that "
New York is a masterpiece of literate, adult rock & roll, and the finest album of Reed's solo career." In 2006,
Q listed it as the decade's 26th best album. In 2012,
Slant Magazine placed the record at No. 70 on its list of the 100 best albums of the 1980s. ==Other releases==