Relationship with former national coach Jake White, 2002–07 In 2003 coach Jake White chose
Schalk Burger and omitted Watson for the South African under-21 team that won the world championship. White suggested that Watson switch to hooker instead where he could reach the highest echelons, as Watson did not have the requisite attributes to be a first-class flank. White's suggestions may have been prompted by his own experience, when as a youth player he had to switch from flank to hooker because he was too short. By 2004 White was said to be against picking Burger and Watson in the same team, Although he had shown "sensational form" in 2004, Watson was again ignored by White and selectors
Andre Markgraaff and
Pieter Jooste in favour of Solly Tyibilika, who had lost his position to Watson at the Sharks during the season. Some believe that White's preference for Burger motivated Watson's 2005 move to Cape Town, where he could prove himself against Burger in the Western Province team. According to statistics compiled by the
New Zealand company Verusco, Watson was the second best openside flanker in the 2006 Super 14 competition, preceded only by
Richie McCaw and followed by
Phil Waugh. White repeatedly emphasised the need for tall loose-forwards who could add extra line-out options. Similar sentiments regarding stature, while not aimed at Watson specifically, had been expressed by other rugby pundits. Italy coach and former Springbok coach Nick Mallett has been a supporter of Watson. When asked in 2008 why in his opinion the Springboks won the 2007 World Cup, Mallett told an audience that the reason the Springboks won was because Schalk Burger is the smallest player in the Springboks' forward pack. Schalk Burger is 1,93m tall, while Watson is 1,84m. And in March 2008
SA Rugby Magazine quoted newly appointed Springbok coach Peter de Villiers as saying: "A small talented guy will always be better than a big untalented guy, and a big talented guy is better than a small talented guy. I will select the best player for the job". After Jake White's preferred selections won the 2007 World Cup, England line-out specialist
Ben Kay was quoted as saying: "Their line-out was fantastic and was a major difference between the two teams. They have been the best line-out in the world for many years and gave us enormous problems." White's public stance against shorter loose forwards was contradicted in November 2006 when he included
Kabamba Floors for the Springbok squad against England in the place of an injured
Pierre Spies. At 1.75m Floors is 9 cm shorter than Watson. White admitted at the time that his view that Floors also was too short had been incorrect. SARU president
Oregan Hoskins, certain journalists and Watson himself at the time accused White of personal bias. For them, Watson's non-selection was due partly to the fact that his father Daniel "Cheeky" Watson was a former anti-apartheid activist, who alienated himself from the SA Rugby establishment by playing club rugby in the 'black' townships of
Eastern Province at a time when this was illegal in terms of racist
apartheid legislation. Watson claimed that Mike Howe, one of his coaches at Grey High School, had told him while he was still a student there that White had made derogatory comments about Watson. Cheeky Watson suggested that Howe had influenced White against Luke – a charge Howe denies. The elder Watson said that White, while the coach of the Under-21 national team, had told a South African Rugby Football Union before witnesses that he would not select Luke " 'because he would come with his father's baggage' ". White dismissed the charge of bias in 2006, claiming that his reasons were purely rugby-related and that he had "no personal issues with anybody".
SA Sports Illustrated interview, 2006 Apart from his objections to what he perceived as Watson's limited skills and lack of stature, White implied that Watson was not a team player, and would have been a divisive influence on the Springbok team if selected. White's accusation that Watson was divisive was no doubt supported by Watson's public criticism of Jake White in a 2006
SA Sports Illustrated article. Watson accused White of a "lack of integrity", as White had "attacked
Schalk Brits" for wanting to play professionally in England, yet he himself had "tried to hold SA Rugby to ransom with an overseas offer". Watson also questioned the credentials of captain
John Smit and he said there was no longer any pride and passion in the Springbok squad. Watson reportedly said: "Obviously I would love to play for the Springboks, but I do not want to find myself in a position where I'm compromising my beliefs in equality, integrity and honour to achieve that goal." Watson's comments in the 2006
SA Sports Illustrated interview revealed his own negative feeling at the time towards White, captain John Smit and the squad. When Watson was finally selected as a Springbok in 2007 and was asked in media interviews to comment on his earlier public criticisms, he maintained that he stood by what he had said a year earlier. White himself had been threatened with sanctions for breaching this regulation. No action was apparently taken by SARU against Watson for bringing the game into disrepute, nor any explanation provided why it had not done so. Springboks or officials are not always charged for making negative public comments about teammates. Smit was not sanctioned for his "cancerous effect" comments about Watson, for example. "Bringing the game into disrepute" is so broadly defined that it has been used to remove players or officials that have fallen into disfavour.
The Independent's correspondent suggested that such an internal settling of scores had happened to Mallet. By reaffirming his 2006 position after his 2007 selection, Watson may have breached the Springbok code of conduct according to which a player undertakes not to discredit or insult a Springbok teammate. But a player makes this commitment to the code when senior teammates initiate new Springboks after their debut game, and Watson's teammates had refused to initiate him.
Resolution In October 2008 White was said to have reconciled with Watson by shaking hands with him at a service of the
Hillsong Church in Cape Town that both then attended. White was quoted as saying " 'I feel sorry for Luke...and it is not for me to judge him". White's actions were ascribed to his conversion to Christianity.
SA Rugby Players' Association's 2006 player of the year award Due to his good form in 2006, Watson was nominated for awards as the Players' Player of the Year, Super 14 Player of the Year, and Currie Cup Player of the Year. Rugby journalist
Mark Keohane reported that on the morning of Monday 30 October 2006 Watson had been confirmed as the winner. But the decision was overturned later the same day and awarded to Free State loose forward Kabamba Floors. Players' Association chair
Piet Heymans said that Floors had won by 8 votes when voting closed at 5pm on Monday. Heymans' assertion was placed in doubt when SARU revealed that the vote had actually been tied, and that SARU president Oregan Hoskins had cast the deciding vote in favour of Floors to break the deadlock. Keohane questioned why SARU's leadership became involved in what was the voting prerogative of players. He alleged that White and Hoskins had intervened when it appeared that Watson would win, and that in this context the Players' Association had demanded a recount. Keohane suggested that a joint award would have had precedent in that the Currie Cup had been shared among teams who were tied at the end of the season.
Politicised Springbok selection, 2007 In May 2007 White and selectors Pieter Jooste and
Ian Macintosh, the former national coach, submitted a list of 45 players to the South African Rugby Union for the Springbok training squad. After White's list was submitted, Watson was added to the list without Jake White's knowledge by SARU President Hoskins, fellow SARU executive council member
Koos Basson, and Springbok team manager Zola Yeye – a long-time friend of the Watson family. Hoskins later said in an interview with Talk Radio 702 host
John Robbie that he had added Watson Jake White considered legal action if the SARU executive interfered further with his final team selection. However, White eventually accepted SARU's decision to include Watson in the Springboks. The senior players then refused to include him in the traditional initiation ceremony for newly capped players, due to the nepotistic manner of his selection. passed a nine-point proposal to White. These included the selection of Watson in the World Cup squad; in return, White's contract with SA Rugby would be extended beyond the 2007 World Cup. Failure to select Luke Watson would result in him losing his job before the World Cup. White claims that the Watsons subsequently backed down. Luke's father, Cheeky Watson, has denied these claims. Watson's father has since told South African newspapers that Luke never wanted to play for the Springboks under White. Watson Snr also boycotted his son's capping ceremony, apparently in protest against White's attitude towards his son. An unknown media source criticized Watson for being "hypocritical in taking up his forced selection" against Samoa, given his public opinions about White and Smit. After the non-selection controversy of 2006 and the politicised-selection controversy of 2007, Watson was firmly established in the media spotlight, and aspects of his behaviour now became subject to more media scrutiny than for other players.
Stormers captaincy, 2007 The coach of the Stormers team in 2007,
Kobus van der Merwe, appointed Watson as captain for their Super Rugby campaign. but Watson denied that he and Van der Merwe had problems. In December 2007 new Stormers coach
Rassie Erasmus replaced Watson with Springbok backline veteran Jean de Villiers as captain of the Stormers. Watson retained his place in the Stormers' team. Earlier rumors in the press had suggested that Burger would replace Watson as captain for the 2008 Super 14 tournament. Reportedly the original decision was revisited after Erasmus met with Luke's father, Dan Watson, to discuss "the role that he [Luke Watson] should play in the Stormers' side". Dan Watson allegedly said "that he had no problem with Luke not captaining the side, provided Schalk Burger did not have a higher profile" than Luke. Erasmus was said to be concerned that Burger, despite his star status, should not be treated differently from his teammates. Previously Erasmus had opined that a good leader does not polarize opinion, and does not make waves or headlines. Just hours after being officially relieved of the Stormers captaincy Watson breached the terms of the team's
Adidas sponsorship contract by wearing rival
Nike logos at an official training session. The matter was dealt with internally. Despite his sacking as captain, Watson scored most tries (5) for the Stormers in the 2007 Super rugby season, only the second forward after Bobby Skinstad to achieve this accomplishment between 1998 and 2011.
Speech at Ubumbo rugby festival, 2008 On 3 October 2008 Watson delivered a speech at the Ubumbo rugby festival at the University of Cape Town. He spoke about his family's political record, and described wearing the Springbok jersey as "a burden" and said he had to struggle "to keep myself from vomiting on it." Watson said that his Springbok teammates refused to associate with him after his forced inclusion in the team in 2007. Watson's words completely contradicted sentiments that he had expressed in his 2006 interview with
SA Sports Illustrated magazine, when he had said: "It (the Springbok emblem) has the potential and it has the ability to become one of the most powerful emblems this world has seen. … It stands for equality. It stands for unity. It stands for a once divided nation that now stands together. It stands for everything this world doesn't have, and everything this world wants". Watson added that "Playing for the Boks would be a great honour" and that "Obviously I would love to play for the Springboks". The ANC's parliamentary sports committee chair, Butana Khompela, on 9 October seized on the event to demand the replacement of the Springbok. Soon after the contents of the speech was made public the
Pro-Afrikaans Action Group condemned Watson's comments as hate-speech, while the civil rights group AfriForum considered pressing charges against him on the same grounds. A number of senior players reportedly threatened to boycott the 2008 end of year tour to England, Wales and Scotland if Watson was included in the squad. But Andy Marinos, then acting managing director of SARU, dismissed the reports as "speculation" and said that they were "utterly groundless". When Watson made his first playing appearance after the incident, in a friendly warm-up match against English club
Saracens at
Newlands in January 2009, he was repeatedly booed by his home crowd. This treatment continued for at least three games into the Super 14 tournament and reached a climax in the Stormers fixture against the Blue Bulls at Loftus Versfeld in
Pretoria. Watson's detractors branded him "Luke the Puke" on various social media sites on the internet. The head of SARU's legal affairs department, Christo Ferreira, commented in public media that Watson could be charged of breach of SARU's code of conduct and fined, suspended or warned if found guilty. SARU appointed lawyer Dekker Govender to conduct a preliminary investigation into the incident. On 14 October 2008 the Ubombo Rugby wrote in a letter to Govender that Watson had not said anything that was racist or defamatory. ==Later senior career==