The expression "Seize Mai" does not refer only to the events of that day, 16 May 1877, but to the whole of a period "politically agitated and deeply troubled" that ended seven months later with the submission of the head of state. On 4 May 1877, from the rostrum of the Chamber, Gambetta reproached Jules Simon for having lacked firmness in the face of
ultramontane manoeuvres. He denounced "clerical evil [...] deeply infiltrated into what are called the ruling classes of the country" and ended his speech by repeating a phrase inspired by his journalist friend , "Clericalism? That is the enemy!". His motion was adopted without Simon opposing it. Thus the religious question revived the confrontation between the republican and conservative blocs and, in this state of heightened tension, President reproached Jules Simon for being under the influence of a majority radicalised in an anticlerical direction and accused him of being Gambetta's hostage, especially since on 15 May the President of the Council allowed the Chamber to vote for the repeal of a law punishing press offences against the government's opinion. File:La Lune RoussePremière Année - N°5Dimanche 7 Janvier 1877Peuh par Gill. Paris Musées 20231005193621.jpg|alt=Press caricature showing two wrestlers.|Depicted as a
fairground strongman, Jules Simon manages to lift the weight of opportunism in front of a jealous
Léon Gambetta. Caricature by
André Gill, '''', 7 January 1877. File:Édouard Pépin - À qui le tour ? - Le Grelot (18 février 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing a moustachioed man standing in a doorway, holding a tooth-extraction instrument, in front of several people burying their heads in their newspapers.|Jules Simon depicted as a tooth-puller of journalists.Satire by Pépin of press censorship,
Le Grelot, 18 February 1877. File:Édouard Pépin - À vos pièces - Le Grelot (6 mai 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing men in ecclesiastical dress bustling around a cannon.|In order to push France down the path of
ultramontanism,
Jesuits prepare to bombard public opinion and the public authorities with petitions,
pastoral letters and other depicted as
shells filled with
Lourdes water.
Anticlerical caricature by Pépin,
Le Grelot, 6 May 1877.
Mac Mahon's letter and Jules Simon's resignation , President of the Council.Caricature by
Karel Klíč, published in the satirical
Vienna magazine
Humoristische Blätter, 20 May 1877. On 16 May 1877, early in the morning, the president reacted sharply to reading the
Journal officiel de la République française which reported the previous day's debate in the Chamber. Considering that Jules Simon's speech departed from the positions agreed in the Council of Ministers, he sent him a letter asking "whether he still had over the Chamber the influence necessary to make his views prevail" and demanding "an explanation [...] that is indispensable", justifying his intervention by the sacred idea he had of his office: "if I am not responsible as you are to parliament, I have a responsibility to France, which today more than ever I must be concerned about" . A few moments later, the secretary-general of the President of the Republic, , read the text and, understanding the gravity of the situation, persuaded to send an usher to retrieve the letter, but in vain. Disavowed, Jules Simon immediately tendered his resignation to the head of state, even though he had not been put in the minority in the Chamber. The president accepted it, declaring among other things that he would "rather be overthrown than remain under the orders of Moscow". Jules Simon then attended the funerals of the former minister
Ernest Picard and then those of the former deputy , where he informed his various ministers and the numerous politicians present of the situation; they were outraged by the presidential move. A meeting of the
Republican Left, already scheduled for 3 PM on the
Boulevard des Capucines, was opened to the other political groups. It ultimately brought together 200 parliamentarians including a few senators. A plenary meeting was decided for that same evening at the
Grand Hôtel where about 300 deputies adopted the motion proposed by Léon Gambetta who, sticking strictly to the legality of the
Constitution, recalled that "the preponderance of parliamentary power exercised through ministerial responsibility is the first condition of government of the country by the country". In the letter that the deputy immediately sent to his mistress
Léonie Léon, he displayed his determination to lead the fight at the head of the republicans: My dear child, war has been declared, they are even offering us battle: I have accepted it, for my positions are impregnable; we occupy the heights of the law from which we can machine-gun at our leisure the miserable troops of reaction floundering in the plain.
Conflict between the Chamber and the president Prorogation of the Assembly and manifesto of the 363 (17–18 May) Marshal Mac Mahon recalled the duke Albert de Broglie to the presidency of the Council and the latter formed a right-wing government that marked the return to the
moral order. By appointing a ministry in line with his views, against the opinion of the deputies, the president offered a dualist reading of the constitution: for him the government was as much his emanation as that of the Chamber of Deputies. File:Union de tous les groupes républicains - 1877.jpg|alt=Commemorative handkerchief of the "union of all republican groups", 26 June 1877, reproducing the portraits of Thiers and Gambetta in medallions.|Commemorative handkerchief of the republican union, reproducing the portraits of
Thiers and
Gambetta as well as "the
coat of arms of Paris, surmounted by a battlemented crown and accompanied by the
motto Fluctuat nec mergitur". most often replacing them with former senior
Bonapartist officials whose mission was to relentlessly prosecute press, publishing or peddling offences. Local elected officials were affected by these measures: 1,743, or 4% of mayors, and 1,334 adjuncts were dismissed, and 613 city councils were dissolved. 133 secretaries-general and 170 prefectural councillors were also transferred or dismissed. File:La Lune RoussePremière Année - N°36Dimanche 12 Août 1877M. Menier, par Gill. Paris Musées 20231005190255.jpg|alt=Press drawing depicting a man depositing a purse in front of a bust of Marianne.|The
chocolate manufacturer industrialist
Émile-Justin Menier financing the republican electoral campaign to the tune of 100,000 francs. Illustration by André Gill,
La Lune rousse. File:Revue comique, par Cham - Une épouse convaincue - Le Monde illustré (22 septembre 1877).jpg|alt=Press caricature showing a woman pouring the contents of a kettle into a cup placed in front of a man with a disgusted look.|A "convinced wife" forces her husband to swallow chocolate as compensation for the generous donation made by the
Menier company in favour of republican candidates. Caricature by
Cham,
Le Monde illustré, 22 September 1877. To finance their campaign, the republicans relied on numerous personalities, notably the owner of the department store
Le Bon Marché,
Aristide Boucicaut, the
chocolate-making patronal dynasty of the Menier, the banker
Henri Cernuschi or the financier , who placed his private mansion at Gambetta's disposal. The latter delivered a speech in
Lille on 15 August 1877 whose
peroration has remained famous. Acclaimed by the audience, he declared to the president and his supporters: "When France has made her sovereign voice heard, believe it well, gentlemen, it will be necessary to submit or resign". This formula was immediately reprinted in
La République française and the Council of Ministers decided to prosecute the speaker, who was no longer protected by parliamentary immunity, and his newspaper, for insulting the head of state. This decision was criticised even in the conservative camp, which feared that the trial would give too much publicity to the republican candidate. Gambetta, tried in absentia on 11 September by the correctional tribunal of the
Seine, was sentenced to three months in prison and a fine of 2,000 francs. Confident of his re-election, he immediately appealed, the second judgment being able to take place only after the ballot. The death of Adolphe Thiers on 3 September was exploited by the republicans, the "363" gathering around the family of the deceased during the funeral which no official attended on 8 September. This sudden disappearance, however, tempered the optimism of the republicans who had envisaged the return of Thiers to the presidency of the Republic in the event of electoral victory and resignation of the marshal. It was the name of
Jules Grévy that replaced it, despite the disagreements that persisted between the latter and Gambetta. At the end of September,
François-Auguste Mignet published a posthumous
manifesto by Thiers in which the former president recalled the absolute necessity of the Republic to avoid civil war. File:Léon Gambetta aux funérailles d'Adolphe Thiers.jpg|alt=Press drawing showing men accompanying a hearse.|Léon Gambetta at the funeral of Adolphe Thiers, 8 September 1877. Illustration published in
The Graphic. File:Punch - Two Manifestoes (October 6, 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing a ghost holding out a written document to a moustachioed man in military attire.|The shade of Thiers brandishes his manifesto from beyond the grave to exhort Mac Mahon to maintain the republican regime but the marshal sticks to his own presidential manifesto. "Two Manifestoes", caricature published in
Punch, 6 October 1877.
Involvement of business circles on the
Paris Stock Exchange. Caricature by Cham,
Le Monde illustré, 3 November 1877. In the early years of the
Third Republic, the influence of business circles in the political game was considerable: on the one hand, the country's economic recovery required close collaboration between political power, high finance and credit institutions; on the other hand, business circles were largely over-represented among political personnel, precisely among the centre right and centre left groups that made up most of the ministerial cabinets of this period. Just as several ministers of the Broglie cabinet were closely associated with the economic world, numerous members of the centre left held seats as directors in the largest companies in the key sectors of the French economy, particularly banks, railways, mining and metallurgy. Unable to form a new government, the president asked on 6 November the ministers of the cabinet to withdraw their resignations, to which the republican deputies responded by demanding the invalidation of all deputies elected with the presidential white poster and the indictment of the ministers. On 10 November, they declared the Chamber constituted and two days later re-elected
Jules Grévy to its presidency, while his brother
Albert Grévy proposed the creation of an inquiry commission on illegal acts committed since 16 May. Composed of 35 deputies, it was accepted by 312 votes to 205 and appointed on 14 October. The sought the Senate's support to reject the commission, but Audiffret-Pasquier informed him that, since a decision to create an inquiry commission was not a law, the upper chamber could not oppose it. The cabinet finally submitted its resignation on the evening of 17 November. , President of the Council and
Minister of War in his short-lived government.|alt=Engraving depicting a middle-aged man with moustache and goatee, in civilian clothes. At an impasse, appointed one of his close associates to the presidency of the Council,
General de Rochebouët. At the beginning of December, Léon Gambetta met with
General de Galliffet to ensure his support for the republic, and several generals spontaneously placed themselves at his disposal, such as
Justin Clinchant,
Jean-Baptiste Campenon or
Jean-Joseph Farre. Faced with the impossibility of forming a cabinet to his liking, considered resigning but his close associates dissuaded him again, both to protect themselves and to avoid a total victory for the republicans. File:Punch - Stuck in the Mud (November 3, 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing a man in military uniform with both boots deeply sunk in mud.|Mac Mahon bogged down in the mud of
Legitimism,
Bonapartism and
clericalism (
Punch, 3 November 1877). File:Punch - Mistress and Man (November 17, 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing a man in military uniform, looking submissive and holding his bicorne, standing before a seated woman wearing a toga and Phrygian cap.|
Marianne scolds : "I intend to be the mistress in my own house. You will execute my orders or you will leave!" (
Punch, 17 November 1877). File:Punch - The Tug of War (December 8, 1877).jpg|alt=Press drawing showing a man and a woman playing tug of war. In the background, three crowned birds of prey are perched on a rock.|Who will step over the Constitution?
Tug of war between Marianne and under the eye of crowned raptors, allegory of the trial of strength between the republicans and the President of the Republic (
Punch, 8 December 1877).
Mac Mahon submits (13 December) (
Punch, 29 December 1877). On 13 December 1877, President finally submitted to the election results and recalled
Jules Dufaure to form a government dominated by moderate republicans of the
centre left but which also included some close to Gambetta such as
Charles de Freycinet at Public Works. Gambetta also imposed the presence of
William Waddington at Foreign Affairs, despite the reservations of the head of state who was consulted only for the War portfolio, awarded to his former aide-de-camp
Jean-Louis Borel, the only apolitical and conservative member of the new cabinet. Other close associates of the president were removed from their responsibilities: the
prefect of police was dismissed as was 's chief of staff, Emmanuel d'Harcourt, who, at the request of the republicans, had no replacement. Finally,
General Ducrot, whom the deputies accused of having too openly conspired in favour of a coup d'État, was relieved of his command of the . The next day, the President of the Republic addressed a message to
parliament that sounded like a political capitulation. first acknowledged that dissolution could not be a normal way of governing a country and concluded by saying: "The
Constitution of 1875 founded a parliamentary Republic by establishing my irresponsibility, while instituting the joint and individual responsibility of the ministers. Thus are determined our respective duties and rights. The independence of the ministers is the condition of their responsibility. [...] These principles, drawn from the Constitution, are those of my government". For the historian Jean-Marc Guislin, "The hesitations and divisions of the conservatives, the hostility of business circles and the reluctance of the army led the Marshal to submit. He also encountered the firmness and resolution of the country won over to the Republic". File:Édouard Pépin - La grande retraite de 1877 - Le Grelot (30 décembre 1877).jpg|alt=Colour drawing depicting a column of officers in full dress, Jesuits and financiers fleeing across the countryside.|"La Grande Retraite de 1877": Pépin caricatures the political failure of the
monarchists as a military debacle
reminiscent of Napoleon (
Le Grelot, 30 December 1877). File:Jules Armand Dufaure.jpg|alt=Sepia photograph of Jules Dufaure, facing forward, seated. His arm is resting on a table, and his head is resting in his hand.|Portrait of Jules Dufaure, recalled to the presidency of the Council. == Consequences of 16 May ==