Junior level Downey was a standout junior level
freestyle wrestler until 2014, year in which his eligibility to compete at this level expired. After failing to make the 2012 Senior US Olympic Team, he made the Junior World Team and went on to win a silver medal at the World Championships. He was also a
FILA and
USAW National Champion.
Senior level 2011–2016 He made his debut in 2011 (fresh out of high school) at the OTT qualifiers in an attempt to make the Olympic Team, but was unsuccessful after losing in the first round to eventual
UFC champion and then
NCAA DII champion Kamaru Usman. He competed just once between 2012 and 2013 and made his return in 2014. In this year, he won the Northern Plains tournament, placed sixth at the University Nationals and attended the World Team Trials. A year later, he competed at the ASICS US Nationals, the Northern Plains and the Bill Farrell Memorial but did not place, In 2016, he just wrestled one match.
2017–2018 In 2017, he made a return to freestyle in big fashion with a fifth-place finish at the US Open, which qualified him for the World Team Trials. At the WTT, he defeated two-time
All-American turned MMA fighter
Kyle Crutchmer but subsequently dropped his next two bouts. To close the year, he racked up a bronze medal from the Dave Schultz Memorial Invitational. In 2018, he once again placed at the US Open and (unlike the previous year) at the World Team Trials.
2019–2020 Downey completed his best year of competition as of now in 2019, as he racked up titles from the Dave Schultz Memorial International and the US Open and made the World Team after defeating Nick Heflin in the challenge finals and the
defending World Champion David Taylor could not make it to
Final X. After successfully making the team, Downey won a prestigious
Pan American Games medal and went 2–1 at the
World Championships. He then participated in a Super Fight against the accomplished submission grappler
Nick Rodriguez, whom he
tech'd after scoring 12 points to none. In 2020, he won a bronze medal at the Matteo Pellicone Ranking Series in Italy and had a brief appearance at the
Ivan Yarygin Golden Grand Prix. In February 2020, Downey competed at a special event where he faced the often referred as "Greatest Submission Grappler of All Time"
Gordon Ryan. This event consisted of a
freestyle wrestling match and a
submission grappling match. In the wrestling match, Downey tech'd Ryan in seconds. In the sub only portion of the match, Downey tapped out to Ryan via 3/4 nelson. Downey was scheduled to compete at the
2020 US Olympic Team Trials on April 4 at
State College, Pennsylvania. However, the event was postponed for 2021 along with the
Summer Olympics due to the
COVID-19 pandemic, leaving all the qualifiers unable to compete. After the Olympic Trials were postponed, Downey participated in the first wrestling event of the United States during the
COVID-19 pandemic on June 28, at Rumble on the Rooftop. He faced
Greco-Roman World Team Member
Joe Rau in a
mixed-rules match, this consisted in one period of Greco-Roman rules and other of
freestyle rules, with no
technical falls. After choosing Greco-Roman in the first period, Downey was down 9 points to none and could just pick up four points during the freestyle period, dropping the match 4–9.
Controversies After several tweets where he made comments towards
Greco-Roman and women's wrestling, Downey was dropped by the NJRTC, terminated by Paradigm Sport Management and Barbarian Appel and also lost his spot at the
FloWrestling: Dake vs. Chamizo card where he was supposed to wrestle
2018 World Champion David Taylor on July 25, in a 5–day period.
2021 After more than a year of inactivity, Downey wrestled at the
UWW Matteo Pellicone Ranking Series on March 7, at 92 kilograms, where he went 0–4. Downey then competed at the rescheduled
US Olympic Team Trials in April, finishing fourth after going 1–2. Downey was scheduled to face two-time US Open National champion at 97 kg
Kyven Gadson on August 13 in an adapted folkstyle match at the Stalemates Street League event. However, Downey did not show up to the event. He was then scheduled to trim down to 79 kilograms and compete at the
2021 US World Team Trials on September 11–12, but once again did not show up.
2025–2026 Downey began competing in
Real American Freestyle (RAF) in 2025. He faced
Yoel Romero for the interim
RAF Light Heavyweight Championship at
RAF 04 on December 20, 2025, losing via
technical fall. == Legal issues ==