Nomination process A frequent criticism of the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame has been that the nomination process is controlled by a small group of individuals, most of them not musicians; this includes founders Jann Wenner and Suzan Evans, as well as writer
Dave Marsh. There has also been criticism of the opacity of the selection process. Janet Morrissey of
The New York Times wrote: With fame and money at stake, it's no surprise that a lot of backstage lobbying goes on. Why any particular act is chosen in any particular year is a mystery to performers as well as outsiders, and committee members say they want to keep it that way. The chairman of the nominating committee,
Jon Landau, confirmed: "We've done a good job of keeping the proceedings nontransparent. It all dies in the room." The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Foundation responded: "There is a format and rules and procedure. There is a specific time when the votes have to be in, and then they are counted. The bands with the top five votes got in." The Dave Clark Five were subsequently nominated again and then inducted the following year.
Allegations of sexism and bias In
BBC Radio 6 Music's Annual
John Peel Lecture in 2013, singer
Charlotte Church accused the museum of
gender bias, stating, "Out of 295 acts and artists in the Rock n' Roll Hall of Fame, 259 are entirely male, meaning that
Tina Weymouth's part in
Talking Heads makes them one of the 36 female acts." In 2014, the percentage of female inductees was 8.5%.
Courtney Love made similar criticisms of the hall in 2023, highlighting the length of time it had taken to induct artists such as
Kate Bush,
Nina Simone,
Carole King,
Linda Ronstadt, and "most egregiously",
Tina Turner as a solo artist, as well as the failure to induct
Chaka Khan despite seven nominations. Following
Donna Summer's death in 2012,
Elton John had criticized the hall for failing to induct her during her lifetime, calling it "a total disgrace, especially when I see the second-rate talent that has been inducted."
Sister Rosetta Tharpe is often regarded as
the godmother of rock and roll, but was not chosen for induction until 2017. According to author
Brett Milano in 2007, "entire genres get passed over, particularly
progressive rock, '60s
Top 40, New Orleans
funk and a whole lot of
black music". At the time of Milano's comment,
Pink Floyd were the only progressive rock band in the hall, although bands such as
Genesis,
Rush,
Yes, and
the Moody Blues have since been inducted. In 2022,
Steven Hyden, a music critic for
Uproxx and a Hall voter, wrote that he believed the Hall had been ignoring
alternative rock and
indie rock artists. Some critics have pointed out a bias in favor of American and British acts, while
Canadian rock bands, such as
the Guess Who, are often ignored, with
Neil Young,
Joni Mitchell,
Leonard Cohen, Rush, and
the Band being the only Canadian acts in the hall. Mexican journalist Miguel Gálvez noted that no artist that performed exclusively in Spanish had ever been inducted into the hall, and advocated for the induction of artists from Latin America, including the Argentine rock band
Soda Stereo.
Criticism from inductees Members of the British
punk rock band the
Sex Pistols, inducted in 2006, refused to attend the ceremony, calling the museum "a piss stain" and "urine in wine". In 2018, when British rock band
Dire Straits were inducted, bandleader
Mark Knopfler did not attend the ceremony and offered no official explanation, leaving bassist
John Illsley to say: "He just didn't feel like coming, it's as simple as that. It just didn't appeal to him, and I appealed to him on several occasions." In response to
Oasis' nomination for the Class of 2024,
Liam Gallagher disparaged the hall on
X, declaring that "there's something very fishy about those awards", "it's all a load of bollox ", and referring to its members as "bumbaclarts".
Steve Miller, a 2016 inductee, directed a litany of complaints at the hall, both during his induction speech and especially in interviews after it. His criticisms included that there is a general lack of female inductees, there is not enough support by the hall for music education, and inductees are treated poorly at the award ceremony. At the same ceremony,
Cheap Trick guitarist
Rick Nielsen commented on the hall's ticket policy for inductees and their families as unnecessarily expensive, a sentiment echoed by Miller.
Velvet Underground drummer
Maureen Tucker has dismissed the museum as the "Hall of Lame", despite the band being inducted a few years prior to the remark. In 2018,
Bruce Dickinson of
Iron Maiden called the hall "an utter and complete load of bollocks ... run by a bunch of sanctimonious bloody Americans who wouldn't know rock 'n' roll if it hit them in the face". Dickinson has also expressed an overall distaste for the hall's entity, arguing that "if you put [music] in a museum, then it's dead". Iron Maiden had been eligible for induction since 2004 and are due to be inducted in 2026. Hard rock and heavy metal website
Blabbermouth.net observed how it had taken 15 years for
Kiss to be inducted (eligible since 1999; inducted in 2014) and 23 years for
Deep Purple (eligible since 1993; inducted in 2016). Regarding his band's non-induction into the hall,
Judas Priest bassist
Ian Hill stated in a 2019 interview, "I don't think they like heavy metal music in general." ==See also==