Media response to
A Weekend in the City was mixed, but generally positive; aggregating website
Metacritic reports a
normalised rating of 65/100 based on 30 critical reviews. Louis Pattison of
NME described the album as "tender and reflective, edgy and embittered; a difficult and emotional beast that jolts with nervous electricity" and pointed out that its notable achievement is that it finds moments of genuine contentment amidst "a maelstrom of anger and confusion".
Allmusic's Heather Phares did not find the album as immediate as Bloc Party's earlier work, but noted that "its gradual move from
alienation to connection and hope is just as bold as
Silent Alarm, and possibly even more resonant".
Drowned in Sound's Mike Diver called it "dirty, dishevelled, unsure and paranoid; fearful, easily distracted, boisterous and ashamed; reckless, wild, nervous and terrified; graceful, thought-provoking, clumsy and contradictory ... and very nearly perfect." Jeff Miller of the
Chicago Tribune concluded, "For Bloc Party,
Silent Alarm was a baby step and this is a giant leap." Michael Endelman of
Entertainment Weekly was less receptive and stated, "Too often, the music on
A Weekend in the City is less memorable than the ambitious subject matter."
Robert Christgau, reviewing for
Rolling Stone, suggested that the album fails because it lacks "killer choruses", while Sia Michel of
The New York Times wrote that the multitracked vocals and baroque effects do not have "the wiry catchiness" of Bloc Party's previous work. Mike Schiller of
PopMatters commented that the sonic direction the band had moved to was unsuited to the members' musical strengths, while Dorian Lynskey of
The Guardian stated "grand statements are not earnest frontman Kele Okereke's forte...there's barely a song that isn't kneecapped by one of Okereke's lyrical clangers". The album was named by
Los Angeles Times in its unnumbered shortlist of the best releases of 2007. It figured in several other end-of-year best album lists, notably, at number eight by
Gigwise, at number nine by
Hot Press, and at number ten by
The A.V. Club.
The Guardian included
A Weekend in the City in its "1000 Albums To Hear Before You Die" list compiled in November 2007 and praised the band's "ambitious indie soundscapes packing a sizeable political punch". == Commercial performance==