Cultural impact Aftermath is often considered one of the most important of the Rolling Stones' early albums. It was an inaugural release of the
album era, during which the LP replaced the single as the primary product and form of artistic expression in popular music. As with
Rubber Soul, the extent of
Aftermaths commercial success foiled the music industry's attempts to re-establish the LP market as the domain of wealthier, adult record-buyers – a plan that had been driven by the industry's disapproval of the uncouth image associated with Jagger and their belief that young record-buyers were more concerned with singles. In Malvinni's opinion,
Aftermath was "the crucial step for the Stones' conquering of the pop world and their much-needed answer" to
Rubber Soul, which had similarly embodied the emergence of
youth culture in popular music during the mid-1960s. With their continued commercial success, the Stones joined the Beatles and
the Who as one of the few rock acts who were able to follow their own artistic direction and align themselves with London's elite bohemian scene without alienating the wider youth audience or appearing to compromise their working-class values. Speaking on the cultural impact of
Aftermaths British release in 1966, Margotin and Guesdon say it was, "in a sense, the soundtrack of Swinging London, a gift to hip young people" and "one of the brightest stars of the new culture (or counterculture) that was to reach its zenith the following year in the
Summer of Love".
Aftermath is regarded as the most artistically formative of the Rolling Stones' early work. Their new sound on the album helped expand their following by the thousands, while its content solidified their dark image. As
Ritchie Unterberger observes, its contemptuous perspective about society and women contributed significantly to the group's reputation as "the bad boys" of rock music. According to John Mendelsohn from
PopMatters, the social commentary of "Mother's Little Helper" in particular "cemented their reputation as a subversive cultural force", as it exposed the hypocrisy of mainstream culture's exclusive association of
psychoactive drug use with addicts and rock stars. The
NMEs Jazz Monroe writes that
Aftermath simultaneously disowned and reimagined rock tradition and forever elevated the Stones as equals to the Beatles. Writing for
The A.V. Club, Hyden describes it as "a template for every classic Stones album that came afterward", crediting its "sarcastic, dark and casually shocking" songs with introducing themes Jagger would explore further in the future through a "complex, slippery persona" that allowed him to "be good and evil, man and woman, tough and tender, victim and victimiser". This deliberately "confounding, complicated image" helped make Jagger one of the most captivating lead musicians in rock, Hyden concludes.
Influence on rock music The album proved influential in the development of rock music. Its dark content pioneered the darker psychological and social themes of
glam rock and British
punk rock in the 1970s. The music historian
Nicholas Schaffner, in
The British Invasion: From the First Wave to the New Wave (1982), acknowledges the Stones on the album for being the first recording act to engage themes of sex, drugs and
rock culture "with both a measure of intelligence and a corresponding lack of sentimentality or even romanticism". The attitude of songs like "Paint It Black" in particular influenced punk's
nihilistic outlook.
Elvis Costello called his album ''
This Year's Model (1978) "a ghost version of Aftermath''" and called "
This Year's Girl" an
answer song to "Stupid Girl". Some of
Aftermaths blues-oriented rock elements foreshadowed the blues-rock music of the late 1960s. Schaffner suggests "Goin' Home" anticipated the trend of extended
musical improvisations by professional rock bands, while Rob Young of
Uncut says it heralded "the approaching psychedelic tide" in the manner of
Rubber Soul. Summarising
Aftermaths impact in 2017, the
pop culture writer Judy Berman describes "Paint It Black" as "rock's most nihilistic hit to date" and concludes that, "with Jones ditching his guitar for a closetful of exotic instruments and the band channelling their touring musicians' homesickness on the record's 11-minute culminating blues jam, 'Goin' Home,' they also pushed rock forward."
Reappraisal Aftermath is often considered the Rolling Stones' first classic album. According to Stephen Davis, its standing as the first wholly Jagger-Richards collection makes it, "for serious fans, the first real Rolling Stones album". Schaffner says it is "the most creative" and possibly the best of their albums "in the first five years", while Hyden cites it as their "first full-fledged masterpiece". Writing for
Uncut, Ian MacDonald recognises it as an "early peak" in the Stones' career, and
Jody Rosen, in a "Back Catalogue" feature for
Blender, includes it as the first of the group's "essential" albums.
The Guardians
Alexis Petridis names
Aftermath the Stones' fifth-best record, while Graeme Ross of
The Independent ranks it sixth and suggests it stands on a level with other benchmark LPs from 1966, including
Blonde on Blonde,
Revolver and
the Beach Boys'
Pet Sounds. In
The Rolling Stone Illustrated History of Rock & Roll (1976), Christgau names
Aftermath the first in a series of Stones LPs – including
Between the Buttons,
Beggars Banquet (1968) and
Let It Bleed (1969) – that stand "among the greatest rock albums". In
MusicHound Rock (1999),
Greg Kot highlights Jones' "canny" instrumental contributions while identifying
Aftermath as the album that transformed the Stones from
British blues "traditionalists" into canonical artists of the album-rock era, alongside the Beatles and Bob Dylan. In a retrospective review for
AllMusic, Unterberger applauds the band's use of influences from Dylan and psychedelia on "Paint It Black", and similarly praises "Under My Thumb", "Lady Jane" and "I Am Waiting" as masterpieces. In 2002, both versions of
Aftermath were digitally remastered as part of
ABKCO Records' reissue campaign of the Rolling Stones' 1960s albums. Reviewing the reissues for
Entertainment Weekly,
David Browne recommends the UK version over the US, while Tom Moon, in his appraisal in
The Rolling Stone Album Guide (2004), prefers the US edition for its replacement of "Mother's Little Helper" with "Paint It Black" and highlights the clever lyrics of Jagger.
Colin Larkin, who rates the British version higher in his
Encyclopedia of Popular Music (2011), describes
Aftermath as "a breakthrough work in a crucial year" and an album that demonstrates a flexibility in the group's writing and musical styles as well as "signs of the band's inveterate misogyny". In their book ''The Beatles vs. The Rolling Stones: Sound Opinions on the Great Rock 'n' Roll Rivalry
(2010), Jim DeRogatis and Greg Kot agree that Aftermath'' is "the first really great Stones album beginning to end", with DeRogatis especially impressed by the British edition's first half of songs. The pop culture author
Shawn Levy, in his 2002 book
Ready, Steady, Go!: Swinging London and the Invention of Cool, says that, unlike the three previous Stones albums,
Aftermath displayed "purpose" in its sequencing and "a real sense that a coherent vision was at work" in the manner of the Beatles'
Rubber Soul. However, he adds that with the August 1966 release of
Revolver,
Aftermath appeared "limp, tame, dated". Young believes its reputation as a work on-par with
Rubber Soul is undeserved since the quality of its songs is inconsistent, the production is "relatively straight" and the assorted stylistic approach ensures it lacks the unifying aspect of the period's other major LPs. Discussing the album's critical legacy for
PopMatters, Mendelsohn and Eric Klinger echo this sentiment while agreeing that it is more of a transitional work for the Stones and not up to the level of the albums from their subsequent "golden years" –
Beggars Banquet,
Let It Bleed,
Sticky Fingers (1971) and
Exile on Main St. (1972). In an article for
Clash celebrating
Aftermaths 40th anniversary, Simon Harper concedes that its artistic standing alongside the Beatles' contemporaneous works may be debatable but, "as the rebirth of the world's greatest rock and roll band, its importance is undisputed." Some retrospective appraisals are critical towards the harsh treatment of female characters on the album. As Schaffner remarks, "the brutal thrust of such ditties as 'Stupid Girl,' 'Under My Thumb' and 'Out of Time' has since, of course, induced paroxysms of rage among feminists." Young infers that the album's principal lyrical theme now evokes a "rather old-fashioned sensation of brattish, spiky misogyny", presenting female characters as "pill-popping housewives... the idiotic hussy... the
obsolete fashion dummy... or the subjugated arm candy". Berman also singles out this aspect in her otherwise positive estimation of
Aftermath, saying it "indulged the Stones' misogyny on the bitchy diss track 'Stupid Girl' and tamed a shrew on 'Under My Thumb,' a nasty piece of work". Unterberger expresses similar reservations about the substance behind songs like "Goin' Home" and "Stupid Girl", finding the latter particularly callow.
Rankings Aftermath frequently appears on professional rankings of the best albums. In 1987, it was voted 68th in
Paul Gambaccini's book ''
Critics' Choice: The Top 100 Rock 'n' Roll Albums of All Time, based on submissions from an international panel of 81 critics, writers and broadcasters. In contemporaneous rankings of the greatest albums, the Dutch OOR, the British Sounds and the Irish Hot Press'' placed it as 17th, 61st and 85th, respectively. In 2000, it was voted number 387 in Colin Larkin's
All Time Top 1000 Albums. In 2003,
Rolling Stone ranked the American edition at number 108 on the magazine's "
500 Greatest Albums of All Time" list. In 2017,
Pitchfork listed
Aftermath at number 98 on the website's "200 Best Albums of the 1960s". The album is also highlighted in popular record guides. It is named in Greil Marcus' 1979 anthology
Stranded as one of his "Treasure Island" albums, comprising a personal discography of rock music's first 25 years. The American edition of the album is included in "A Basic Record Library" of 1950s and 1960s recordings published in ''
Christgau's Record Guide: Rock Albums of the Seventies'' (1981). The same version appears in James Perone's book ''The Album: A Guide to Pop Music's Most Provocative, Influential and Important Creations'' (2012) and in Chris Smith's
101 Albums That Changed Popular Music (2009), albeit in the latter's appendix "Ten Albums That Almost Made It". In addition,
Aftermath features in
Bill Shapiro's 1991
Rock & Roll Review: A Guide to Good Rock on CD (listed in its section on "The Top 100 Rock Compact Discs"),
Chuck Eddy's ''The Accidental Evolution of Rock'n'roll
(1997), the 2006 Greenwood Encyclopedia of Rock History''s "Most Significant Rock Albums", and Robert Dimery's
1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die (2010). ==Track listing==