Early writing by Payne included two novels,
The War in the Marshes and
The Mountain and the Stars. He also reported for newspapers on the
Spanish Civil War and from China on the
war with Japan. While in China he also wrote autobiographical works, historical novels, and worked on
The White Pony, a compilation of Chinese poetry. including novels, histories and biographies. He was best known for the biographies, which included studies of
Charlie Chaplin,
Greta Garbo,
Hitler,
Lenin,
Stalin,
Trotsky,
Gandhi,
Albert Schweitzer,
Dostoyevsky,
Ivan the Terrible,
Chiang Kai-shek,
Karl Marx,
Mao Zedong,
Sun Yat-sen,
André Malraux,
Shakespeare,
Alexander the Great, the
White Rajahs of Sarawak and General
George C. Marshall. Payne also dined and had long conversations with Mao Zedong in 1946. As a novelist, Payne used the pseudonyms Richard Cargoe, John Anthony Devon, Howard Horne, Valentin Tikhonov, and Robert Young. He also performed translations into English from many languages, including works by
Pasternak and
Kierkegaard.
Critical reaction Payne was described in 1947 as "a poet and a believer in the permanent power of beauty", and as a "young English author whose versatility and prolific output have astonished the literary world".
The New York Times in 1950 called him "the most versatile writer of the year".
Orville Prescott, book reviewer for the
New York Times, claimed that "No man alive can write more beautiful prose than Robert Payne." The American critic
Christopher Lehmann-Haupt wrote that the effect of this approach was "interesting and terrifying". The historian
Alan Bullock commented that Payne's focus on Hitler's personal life resulted in a good account of Hitler's earlier years, but proved less productive for his later life when he "becomes absorbed in politics".
The Biography Book recognised the "narrative and imaginative power" of Payne's account, while stating that "it incorporates speculation as fact". One example of this was the book's acceptance of claims by
Bridget Dowling (Hitler's sister-in-law) and others that Hitler had spent time in
Liverpool before 1914, a claim later - and, in view of Payne's personal meeting in Munich with Hitler in 1937, albeit speculatively - described as "conclusively disproved". Payne was said to be "a firm adherent to the conspiracy theory of politics" and among biographies of Lenin, Payne's book was described as "the easiest to read ... also the easiest to forget". The
Los Angeles Times commented on the Leonardo biography that "Payne makes a persuasive case ... The biography is ... a rendering of respect and admiration for the man." ==Bibliography==