19871991: Early years with Columbia Records Jennings had originally planned to sign Carpenter to an independent label, but the owner of a Washington, D.C. nightclub submitted some of Carpenter's demos to a representative of
Columbia Records' Nashville division. This led to her signing with that label in 1987, only two days before she was slated to sign the contract with the other independent label. Columbia released her debut album
Hometown Girl in 1987. Of the ten songs on
Hometown Girl, Carpenter wrote or co-wrote eight. The two exceptions were "Come On Home" and a cover of
Tom Waits' "
Downtown Train". Jennings played guitar, synthesizer, piano, bass guitar, and
mandolin on the album, while
Mark O'Connor contributed on fiddle and
Tony Rice on acoustic guitar. Musician Jon Carroll played piano and also provided percussion by shaking a
Cream of Wheat can. While the album did not produce any charting singles, it received
word of mouth attention in folk music circles, which led to her being booked to perform at the
Philadelphia Folk Festival in addition to serving as an opening act for
Emmylou Harris. The song served as the lead single to her second Columbia album,
State of the Heart. The album charted three more singles between 1989 and 1990. First was "
Never Had It So Good", a song which Carpenter wrote with Jennings. By the end of 1989, this became her first top-ten hit on
Billboard. She won Top New Female Vocalist from the
Academy of Country Music in 1989. At the
33rd Annual Grammy Awards in 1991, "Quittin' Time" was nominated for a
Grammy Award for
Best Female Country Vocal Performance. accompanied Carpenter on her 1991 hit "
Down at the Twist and Shout".|alt=Cajun band BeauSoleil performing on a stage. Her third Columbia album was 1990's
Shooting Straight in the Dark. Its first single release was her own composition "
You Win Again". Both of these cuts achieved top-20 peaks on Hot Country Songs upon release. Jim Bohen of the
Morristown, New Jersey,
Daily Record thought that the album was more upbeat than its predecessors, citing "You Win Again" and "Down at the Twist and Shout" as examples.
19921995: Come On Come On and Stones in the Road ' "
Passionate Kisses".|alt=Singer Lucinda Williams strumming a guitar.
Come On Come On, Carpenter's fourth Columbia album, was also her most commercially successful. It also charted a total of seven singles between 1992 and 1994. First among these was "
I Feel Lucky". Upon its release to country radio, it achieved a peak of number four on Hot Country Songs. The next release from the album was "
Not Too Much to Ask", a duet with
Joe Diffie. The next single off
Come On Come On was "
The Hard Way", followed by a cover of
Dire Straits' "
The Bug". After it came the top-ten hits "
He Thinks He'll Keep Her" and "
I Take My Chances".
David Browne of
Entertainment Weekly thought the album had more "edge and directness" than its predecessors, and thought that the lyrics had a theme of "women caught between tradition and contemporary roles who realize that the solution lies with their own inner resolve". Later in 1994, Carpenter released
Stones in the Road. Upon its release, it became her only one to reach number one on the
Billboard Top Country Albums charts. Likewise, the lead single "
Shut Up and Kiss Me" became her only number one on Hot Country Songs. Follow-up "
Tender When I Want to Be" peaked at number six, but the next two singles were less successful. "
House of Cards" peaked at 21, while "Why Walk When You Can Fly?" became her first to miss top 40 entirely. The title track was inspired by her memories of seeing
Robert F. Kennedy's funeral procession when she was young. Reviewing the album for AllMusic, Thom Jurek stated that "Carpenter cut back on the number of hooks in her melodies, creating a palette that required closer listening to appreciate". He compared "Tender When I Want to Be" to the work of
Bruce Springsteen, and considered "John Doe No. 24" and "The End of My Pirate Days" "moodier" than her previous works.
Stones in the Road won Carpenter her first
Grammy Award for Best Country Album at the
37th Annual Grammy Awards. At the same ceremony, "Shut Up and Kiss Me" won Best Female Country Vocal Performance and was nominated for Best Country Song, thus meaning that Carpenter won the former award in four consecutive years. She also received her first nomination outside the association's country music categories that year, when "He Thinks He'll Keep Her" was nominated for
Record of the Year. Her last studio album to be released in the 1990s was 1997's
A Place in the World. Carpenter told Russ DeVault of
The Atlanta Constitution (now
The Atlanta Journal-Constitution) before the album's release that she wished she had more time to record the album because she "likes to tweak things". She also stated that the title track represented a "sense of identity" and "search for fulfillment". Lead single "
Let Me into Your Heart" made number eleven on the country music charts. After this album, Carpenter stated that she began to feel "malaise" toward the pace of her career. As a result, she deliberately scheduled fewer touring dates to allow herself more time spent with family and friends. She also expressed disdain toward
A Place in the World, as she felt her management had pressured her into making a "commercially viable" album instead of letting her choose songs she wanted to record. As a result, she hired a new manager, Ron Fierstein, who at the time was also serving in this capacity for Colvin. Fierstein was supportive of Carpenter's decision to slow the pace of her career, and encouraged her to focus on touring and selecting songs until she felt she was ready to make another album. The title track was a cover of
Mick Jagger's "Party Doll", from his 1987 album
Primitive Cool. Two of the new recordings, "
Almost Home" and "Wherever You Are", were issued as singles, with the former becoming her last top-40 country hit.
20002004: Departure from Columbia Her next Columbia album was 2000's
Time* Sex* Love*. Carpenter recorded the album at
AIR Studios, a studio in
London owned by
George Martin. During this album's corresponding tour, Carpenter underwent
arthroscopic surgery for a knee injury and thus had to perform most of the concerts while seated. She also told Dave Scheiber of the
Tampa Bay Times that while the album's songs were positively received in concert, she was disappointed by the lack of radio play and questioned whether she still considered herself a country artist. In 2002, Carpenter joined Emmylou Harris,
Bruce Cockburn, and
Patty Griffin in a benefit concert for Campaigning for a Landmine Free World, an organization dedicated to raising awareness of
landmines left behind in former war zones. This concert was held at the Thomas Wolfe Auditorium in
Asheville, North Carolina. She was also named by
Habitat for Humanity as the head of their Build Project, which employed women to build houses for the homeless across the United States. Her contract with Columbia ended with her eighth studio album, 2004's
Between Here and Gone. Other songs on the album were inspired by the emotions Carpenter felt after the
September 11 attacks. Other musicians included
Mac McAnally,
Stuart Duncan, and
Viktor Krauss. Jurek thought the album was "a sophisticated but very accessible recording, pleasant in its tempos and in its lush presentation."
20072014: Zoë Records After leaving Columbia Records, Carpenter signed with the independent
Zoë Records (a division of
Rounder Records) in 2006. Her first release for the label was 2007's
The Calling. While it accounted for no charting singles, the release reached number ten on the
Billboard country albums charts. Shortly after the album's release Carpenter was hospitalized for a
pulmonary embolism, which forced her to cancel all concert dates that year. After being released from the hospital on April 27, 2007, she issued a statement on her website saying she was recovering and planned to tour again in 2008. Once she had recovered she began work on
Come Darkness, Come Light: Twelve Songs of Christmas, her first album of
Christmas music. This was released in 2008. She continued to record for Zoë Records throughout the 2010s, with her next project being
The Age of Miracles in 2010. In particular, she stated that the track "Iceland" represented the "feelings of loss and darkness and disconnection" she felt while hospitalized, and closing track "The Way I Feel" was about the "resilience" she felt after successfully recovering. Mark Deming of AllMusic wrote that the album was "a literate and thoughtful set of songs that speak to the concerns of the heart and soul with equal portions of compassion and intelligence", although he thought it might not appeal to fans of Carpenter's more up-tempo work such as "Shut Up and Kiss Me". Jonathan Keefe of
Slant Magazine was less favorable toward the album, praising the lyrics of the title track and "I Put My Ring Back On" but overall criticizing the album's sound as "a pedestrian, coffeehouse blend of hushed acoustic strumming." In July 2010, Carpenter performed "I Feel Lucky" at the
Grand Ole Opry before doing a concert at the
Tennessee Performing Arts Center to promote
The Age of Miracles. Throughout mid-2011, she toured across the United States in support of this album. '' included a duet with
James Taylor.|alt=A head shot of singer James Taylor.
Ashes and Roses followed on Zoë in 2012. Two personal life events influenced this album's songs: the death of her father, and her divorce from her husband.
James Taylor provided duet vocals on the track "Soul Companion". Jurek called this project "the most confessional record of her career" and praised the use of Hammond organ and mandolin in the production. Allison Stewart of
The Washington Post wrote that it had "woeful and beautiful coffeehouse folk songs, decorated with sparing, almost offhanded instrumentation that’s often limited to guitars and pianos." Keefe was less favorable toward the project, criticizing Carpenter's "hushed" vocal tone and the lack of
hooks. Her next project was 2013's
Songs from the Movie, a collaboration with composer and conductor
Vince Mendoza. This consisted of orchestral re-recordings of existing songs in her catalog. After this album's 2014 release, she performed selections from it with the
BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra at the
Celtic Connections festival in
Glasgow, Scotland. In 2014, Carpenter's touring schedule included a mix of orchestral performances comprising selections from
Songs from the Movie, as well as acoustic sets featuring Jon Carroll, multi-instrumentalist John Doyle, and opening act
Tift Merritt.
2015present: Albums on Lambent Light After leaving the Zoë label, she began recording her next album in 2015 with production work from
Dave Cobb. This album,
The Things That We Are Made Of, was released in 2016 via Carpenter's own Lambent Light Records label, Carpenter said that she intentionally intended for her vocal tracks to be "imperfect", and that she had difficulty "relinquishing control" of production duties. She also said that some of the songs were inspired by her walking her dog through the
Blue Ridge Mountains. Also in 2015, longtime collaborator John Jennings died of
kidney cancer. Next on Lambent Light was 2018's
Sometimes Just the Sky. This album consisted of re-recordings of tracks from each of her previous albums, as well as the title track, the only original composition. English record producer
Ethan Johns produced the project, in addition to selecting all of the musicians except for Carpenter's touring guitarist Duke Levine. The musicians recorded the project at
Real World Studios, owned by
Peter Gabriel. After its release, she embarked on a tour throughout mid-2018 in support. Following this project, she and Johns began work on another album. However, production was put on hiatus in early 2020 due to the
COVID-19 pandemic. In response, Carpenter began streaming live acoustic performances online. Also in 2020, she returned to Wolf Trap where, without an audience present, she performed a 26-song solo acoustic set. This set was recorded as an album and DVD release titled
One Night Lonely, Carpenter's next album was released in January 2025. Titled
Looking for the Thread, it is a collaboration with Scottish folk singers
Julie Fowlis and
Karine Polwart. She had met the two at the Celtic Connections music festival in
Glasgow, and Fowlis and Polwart agreed to collaborate because they were fans of Carpenter's music. Carpenter released a new album on June 6, 2025, titled
Personal History, via Lambent Light/Thirty Tigers. ==Collaborations and other works==