1951–1962 For its first three telecasts, the program had been presented in black-and-white (there were two presentations of it in 1952, one on Easter and one during the Christmas season), but beginning in 1953, it was telecast in color. Because it was an opera, and commercial network television executives had increasingly little confidence in presenting opera on television, it later began to be scheduled, with rare exceptions, as an afternoon television program, rather than shown in
prime time as had been done in its first few telecasts. According to ''The New Kobbe's Complete Opera Book'', the first stage performance was presented at
Indiana University Bloomington, on February 21, 1952, with conductor Ernest Hoffman. The opera's second performance was in Boston on December 18 and 19, 1952. It was presented by the Opera Club at the Agassiz Theatre of Radcliffe College, under the direction of Thomas H. Phillips for the
Longy School of Music. James Hercules Sutton, 9, soloist for Alfred Nash Patterson at the Church of the Advent, played Amahl; Claire Smith played the mother; Walter Lambert, Paul Johnson and Hermann Gantt played the three kings.
1963–1966 For years, Amahl and the Night Visitors was presented live, but in 1963 it was videotaped by NBC with conductor
Herbert Grossman and an all-new cast featuring
Kurt Yaghjian as Amahl, Martha King as the Mother, and
John McCollum,
Willis Patterson, and
Richard Cross as the
Three Kings. This was the first television production of "Amahl" in which the role of King Balthazar was sung by a real African-American. Earlier productions, including the 1951 original version, had had a white man in blackface singing the role. When Menotti found out that NBC had scheduled the taping on a date when he was out of the country, he tried to get the date changed. The network refused and recorded the 1963 performance without the composer's presence or participation, telecasting it in December 1963, and twice more after that — in 1964 and 1965. Menotti never approved of the 1963 production, and in May 1966 when the rights to future broadcasts reverted to him, the composer refused to allow it to be shown again. Because of this,
Amahl was not shown on television at all between 1966 and 1978.
1978 In 1978, a new production starring
Teresa Stratas as Amahl's mother, Robert Sapolsky as Amahl, and
Willard White,
Giorgio Tozzi and
Nico Castel as the Three Kings was filmed by NBC, partly on location in the
Holy Land. As was the norm for filmed opera, the music was pre-recorded and the singers mimed their performances to the playback. This performance was so successful that it was repeated on Christmas Eve 1954 with substantially the same cast apart from the Page sung by John Carvalho and the dancer, Betty Ferrier. Both performances were broadcast live. A
telerecording of the 1954 performance was broadcast on Christmas Eve 1956 but this recording seems to have been discarded. An audio recording of the 1954 performance exists in private hands. Further performances followed. The 1955 performance was also produced by Christian Simpson, starring Malcolm Day as Amahl, with Gladys Whitred as Amahl's mother. Music was provided by the Sinfonia of London. It appears that this performance was also broadcast live. It was either not recorded or the recording was discarded. It does not exist in the BBC Archives. The second production was broadcast on December 24, 1959. This version exists as a 35 mm telerecording in the BBC Archives. This version was again produced by Christian Simpson and starred Christopher Nicholls as Amahl and
Elsie Morison as Amahl's mother. This time music was provided by the
Royal Philharmonic Orchestra.
1957 Australian TV version A version was broadcast on
ABC on
Australian television in 1957. It was aired live in Melbourne on 18 December 1957, and was kinescoped to be shown in Sydney on Christmas Day. It is not known if the
kinescope recording still exists. == Roles ==