Scholars have deduced that the work was written in the fifth century AD, after the reign of Trajan it fictionally portrays. Due to similar composition and history, scholars associate the
Martyrdom of Barsamya with the
Acts of Sharbel. Both of these texts were found to be less authentic by scholars in terms of historicity than other Syriac Christian works such as the
Acts of Shmona and of Gurya and the
Martyrdom of Habib the Deacon. In his
Carmina Nisibena,
Ephrem the Syrian mentions Gurya, Shmona, and Habbib but not of Barsamya or Sharbel. The same reoccurs in the Syriac
Martyrology of 411, which lists martyrs from Edessa.
Sebastian Brock states that
Sharbel,
Barsamya, and the
Doctrine of Addai originated from the same group of authors. Unique to the
Doctrine of Addai, the exact list of
Petrine apostolic succession reoccurs at the end of the Martyrdom of Barsamya. Also unique to the
Doctrine of Addai, the names of
Addai's first Christian converts who are of nobility are mentioned in both the
Acts of Sharbel and the
Martyrdom of Barsamya. Inscriptions of these names can be found in once pagan regions of Edessa dating back to the fourth and third century AD and are rarely mentioned in Syriac sources from the fifth century AD and after. Sebastian Brock states that the names were probably genuine ancestral names of those who authored all three texts, however, he doubts their conversion to Christianity. He also states Addai's first Christian converts mentioned in the
Martyrdom of Barsamya and the
Acts of Sharbel were incorporated in a literary writing style similar to that of the
Acts of Shmona and Gurya and the
Martyrdom of Habbib. With such similarities, he deduced that the authors of the
Acts of Sharbel and the
Martyrdom of Barsamya were either inserting the ideal that they already had a
martyr before Shmona, Gurya and Habbib, or were integrating the ideal that their pagan ancestors were converted to Christianity at an early period. == Notes ==