Todd Rundgren states that Steinman was highly influenced by the "rural suburban teenage angst" of Springsteen. According to manager David Sonenberg, "Jim would always come up with these great titles and then he would write a song that would try to justify the greatness of the title." Steinman had been working on a magnum opus, which finally opened in 2017 in the form of
Bat Out Of Hell: The Musical. The first incarnation of his work was a musical called
The Dream Engine when he was in college at Amherst. The qualities of teenage rebellion and a girl joining a "tribe" led by a charismatic leader are present in all versions of Steinman's work. It is in
The Dream Engine that the spoken word piece "Hot Summer Night" originates, and is the earliest work that appears on the Meat Loaf album, where it is performed by Jim Steinman and actress Marcia McClain. The next incarnation of Steinman's magnum opus, during the 1970s, was a musical called
Neverland, which contained many of the same scenes and themes as
The Dream Engine but was now largely depoliticized and contained many
Peter Pan references. Some scenes in
Neverland, such as the parents feeding their imprisoned daughter "dream suppressant" drugs, are still present in
Bat Out Of Hell: The Musical, but overall
Neverland was of a much darker tone. This musical contained the songs "Heaven Can Wait", "
Bat Out of Hell", and "All Revved Up with No Place to Go". On the 25th anniversary version of
Bat Out of Hell, one of the bonus live tracks, "Great Boleros of Fire", is an instrumental version of another song from
Neverland titled "Gods". (Meat Loaf finally recorded and released this song under the title "Godz" on his 2016 album
Braver Than We Are.) When staged in 1977, the cast of
Neverland included
Ellen Foley as Wendy – who performs the lead female vocal on "
Paradise by the Dashboard Light" on the album. The music for
Neverland was performed by
Orchestra Luna, and one of their members at the time was
Karla DeVito. Foley was not available when it came time to go on tour for the album, so Karla DeVito took her place. In the various promotional music videos for the songs on the album
Bat Out of Hell Karla DeVito's lips are synced to Ellen Foley's album vocals. The opening track "Bat Out of Hell" is the result of Steinman's desire to write the "most extreme
crash song of all time". "You Took the Words Right Out of My Mouth" is musically inspired by the rock chords of
The Who's "
Baba O'Riley" with a Phil Spector-style melody on top. In Jim Steinman's
Neverland and
Bat Out of Hell: The Musical, the spoken word "Hot Summer Night" and this song are used as an exchange of wedding vows, and to celebrate a wedding. The song "
Two Out of Three Ain't Bad" was written in direct response to actress
Mimi Kennedy asking Jim Steinman whether he could write a simple song like
Elvis Presley's "
I Want You, I Need You, I Love You". Todd Rundgren identifies how the song was influenced by
the Eagles, who were successful at the time. The producer also highlights the "underlying humor in the lyrics", citing the line "There ain't no
Coupe de Ville hiding at the bottom of a
Cracker Jack box." He says you could "get away" with that lyric only "in a Meat Loaf song." so they had a history of performing over-the-top musical comedy sketches together. The baseball commentary make-out section performed by
New York Yankees announcer
Phil Rizzuto was written with the announcer in mind, using phrases he would actually say during commentary. "For Crying Out Loud" was originally written for the 1975
New York Shakespeare Festival musical Kid Champion, and a recording by an unknown artist is in the New York Public Library archives. Jim Steinman considers the line "And can't you see my faded Levi's bursting apart" his most daring lyric on the entire album. Comparing the album to Steinman's late-1960s musical
The Dream Engine,
Classic Rock magazine says that Steinman's imagery is "revved up and testosterone-fueled. Songs like 'Paradise by the Dashboard Light,' 'Two Out of Three Ain't Bad' and 'For Crying Out Loud' echoed the textbook teenage view of sex and life: irrepressible physical urges and unrealistic romantic longing." Steinman's songs for
Bat Out of Hell are personal but not autobiographical: I never thought of them as personal songs in terms of my own life but they were personality songs. They were all about my obsessions and images. None of them takes place in a normal world. They all take place in an extreme world. Very operatic...they were all heightened. They don't take place in normal reality. For example, citing the narrative of "Paradise", Rundgren jokes that he can't imagine Steinman being at a lakeside with the most beautiful girl in school, but he can imagine Steinman "imagining" it. ==Cover==