Contemporary Battletoads was greeted with mostly enthusiastic reviews upon release, with critics calling it one of the best all-time video games, presentation was frequently praised, particularly when it came to the cutscenes, humour, some backgrounds being a "bit bland on occasions,"
Battletoads started at number 26 on
Nintendo Powers July 1991 Top 30 list of NES games for Players' Picks only with 464 points, rising to number 13 the following issue with 858 points. In September 1991, it premiered on the actual Top 30 list at number 11 with 3,219 points, landing in the top ten of both respective lists for Players' Pick (number seven) and Pros' Picks (number six). In the October 1991 issue, the game skyrocketed to the number-three spot on the overall list with 6,008 points, remaining in that position in the November issue with 6,397 points. By January 1992, the issue
Nintendo Power turned the Top 30 list into a Top 20 list (as they added Top 20 rankings for games of other consoles),
Battletoads budged to number two with 6,140 points that month, staying in that ranking for three more consecutive issues but remaining out of the top spot due to having significantly less points than the long-lasting
Super Mario Bros. 3 (1990). Afterwards, the game remained in the top ten for 17 more consecutive months, and eleven times in the top five. The game still charted when the Top 20 NES list ended in November 1994, and most of the game's final eleven months on the chart were in the bottom half, with only one of those months in February 1994 being in a top ten spot.
Battletoads was nominated for the 1991
Nintendo Power Awards in nine categories, winning the first place in the categories: Graphics and Sound (NES), Theme and Fun (NES), Best Play Control (NES) and Best Multi-Player or Simultaneous (NES), it was also given the title of the Overall Best Game for NES of 1991.
Retrospective AllGame acclaimed
Battletoads as a mixture of a "great sense of humor (especially in the two-player mode) with a surprisingly good storyline and near-perfect gameplay," also praising its "smooth and responsive" controls "fluid" character animation, and the stages being "huge, gorgeously rendered and full of surprises." In 1997,
Nintendo Power ranked the NES version as the 89th best game on any Nintendo platform. In 2010,
UGO included it on their "Top 25 games that need sequels" also featuring the Arctic Cavern level on the list of "coolest ice levels".
Topless Robot ranked
Battletoads as the number one "least terrible
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles rip-off" in 2008, also naming it as one of ten best beat-'em-ups of all time in 2010 and as one of ten video games that should have gotten toys in 2011. In 2012, it was also listed among ten "classic videos games that deserve an HD
remake" by
Yahoo! News.
GamesRadar ranked it the 18th best NES game ever made, stating that "it was a fun game but its most notable element was its difficulty". Jeremy Dunham of
IGN listed
Battletoads as the 40th best NES game of all time. ==Legacy==