,
Sericulus aureus, illustrated by
John Gould (1804–1881) Though bowerbirds have traditionally been regarded as closely related to the
birds of paradise, recent
molecular studies suggest that while both families are part of the great corvid radiation that took place in or near
Sahul (Australia-New Guinea), the bowerbirds are more distant from the birds of paradise than was once thought.
DNA–DNA hybridization studies placed them close to the
lyrebirds; however, anatomical evidence appears to contradict this placement, and the true relationship remained unresolved for long.
Cladistic analyses in the mid-2010s usually allied bowerbirds with the
Australasian treecreepers (Climacteridae), another Sahul
endemic family which is highly adapted to a
woodpecker-like lifestyle (woodpeckers being absent from Sahul). This putative
superfamily forms part of a large
basal radiation of ancient songbirds, with the lyrebirds being part of a more ancestral branch than the bowerbirds and their DNA-DNA hybridization similarities being due to the
phenetic methodology which (unlike cladistic analysis) merely assesses overall similarity without accounting for
convergent evolution. Many bowerbirds (in particular New Guinean species) are little known and even less studied. But the hypothesized relationships of 3 roughly equally distinct groups and one peculiar species inferred from courtship behaviour and external appearance are by and large confirmed by
molecular phylogenetics, . Some insights from the more recent studies, however, were less expected: The
Tooth-billed catbird, with its unique "stagemaker" courtship, was long suspected not to be a true catbird (genus
Ailuroedus). As it turned out, this is not only correct, but in fact the Tooth-billed catbird is robustly resolved by the
mtDNA data as more closely related to the "
maypole"-type bower builders than to
Ailuroedus, and certainly warrants separation in genus
Scenopoeetes. Also, the enigmatic "maypole-builder" genus
Archboldia seems to be merely a
Amblyornis with unusually heavy
melanin pigmentation as is often found in
tropical rainforest birds. On the other hand, the "avenue-builders" also have a hypermelanic lineage, the satin bowerbird, but this seems well separable as a
monotypic genus
Ptilonorhynchus, as is the "maypole-building" golden bowerbird (as
Prionodura). Interestingly, the widely divergent "avenue-builders" may represent the oldest living lineage, with the monogamous true catbirds, which do not build a bower and were traditionally held to be "primitive", as the most derived group among living bowerbirds – the
last common ancestor of the living bowerbirds is hypothesized to have been
polygynous, with
sexually dimorphic plumage –
cryptic greenish in the females, and probably dark with a yellow belly in the males. But overall relationships between the true catbirds, the "maypole-builders" and the "avenue-builders" were not definitely resolvable, with only a small
outgroup being used and outgroup effects on intra-family relationships not being tested. Even so, it is precisely this uncertainty about inter-group relationships that strongly suggests that the "maypole"/"avenue" bowers are not one ancestral and one derived type, but evolved independent of one another, perhaps from a "clean stage"-type courtship arena which is commonly established by all bower-building species at the start of bower construction, and persists in little-altered form (just adding some remarkable leaves strewn about as decoration) in
Scenopoeetes which almost certainly is the most ancient living lineage of the "maypole-builders". Among the catbirds, the white-cheeked group (
A.buccoides/geislerorum/stonii) is very likely the most ancient one, which is also in line with the hypothesis that bowerbirds have become more and more drab and inconspicuous as their evolution progressed. }}
Genera and species True catbirds Genus
Ailuroedus •
Ochre-breasted catbird,
Ailuroedus stonii •
White-eared catbird,
Ailuroedus buccoides •
Tan-capped catbird,
Ailuroedus geislerorum •
Green catbird,
Ailuroedus crassirostris •
Spotted catbird,
Ailuroedus maculosus •
Black-eared catbird,
Ailuroedus melanotis Maypole-builders (including Tooth-billed bowerbird) Genus
Scenopoeetes •
Tooth-billed bowerbird,
Scenopoeetes dentirostris Genus
Archboldia •
Archbold's bowerbird,
Archboldia papuensis Genus
Amblyornis •
Vogelkop bowerbird,
Amblyornis inornata •
MacGregor's bowerbird,
Amblyornis macgregoriae •
Streaked bowerbird,
Amblyornis subalaris •
Golden-fronted bowerbird,
Amblyornis flavifrons Genus
Prionodura •
Golden bowerbird,
Prionodura newtoniana Avenue-builders Genus
Sericulus •
Flame bowerbird,
Sericulus ardens •
Masked bowerbird,
Sericulus aureus •
Fire-maned bowerbird,
Sericulus bakeri •
Regent bowerbird,
Sericulus chrysocephalus Genus
Ptilonorhynchus •
Satin bowerbird,
Ptilonorhynchus violaceus Genus
Chlamydera •
Western bowerbird,
Chlamydera guttata •
Spotted bowerbird,
Chlamydera maculata •
Great bowerbird,
Chlamydera nuchalis • Eastern great bowerbird,
Chlamydera (nuchalis) orientalis (possibly a distinct species) •
Yellow-breasted bowerbird,
Chlamydera lauterbachi •
Fawn-breasted bowerbird,
Chlamydera cerviniventris Fossil record Bowerbirds have a scant
fossil record that nonetheless extends to the
Chattian (latest
Oligocene), with the fossil species
Sericuloides marynguyenae dated to 26 to 23 million years ago. It was found in Faunal Zone A deposits of the White Hunter Site at D-site Plateau of the
Riversleigh World Heritage Area.
S. marynguyenae was a tiny member of its family, about the same size as the golden bowerbird. It is known from the proximal end of a right
carpometacarpus and the proximal end of a left
tarsometatarsus. The material, though fragmentary, preserves much detail, and is overall more similar to the "avenue-builders" – in particular
Chlamydera – than to the other two main groups. However, the splits between the three main groups of living bowerbirds are presumed to have occurred only in the
Miocene, some time after
Sericuloides lived. Thus, the fossil species may have belonged to a more
basal and now entirely extinct lineage, and/or it may be considered to support the hypothesis that the "avenue-builders" are the most ancient group of bowerbirds and retain many "primitive" features in their anatomy. Other than
S. marynguyenae, as of 2025 only one other certain prehistoric bowerbird species is known. This has not been named, as it is only known from the distal left
ulna piece
QM F57970 (AR19857), also found on the D-site Plateau of Riversleigh WHA, but in interval 3 of Faunal Zone B at the Ross Scott-Orr site, in late early Miocene (
Burdigalian) sediments dated to 16.55 mya. Even though this piece of fossil bone is merely some 16 mm long, it is excellently preserved, and its features are characteristic of a smallish bowerbird the size of a
black-eared catbird. Bowerbird ulnae – to the extent they have been studied – differ little between genera and species, but the Miocene fossil is unlike all living members of the family in one detail or another. If anything, it resembles the presumably more advanced groups ("maypole-builders" and true catbirds) more than the "avenue-builders" and given its age it may well have been one of the earliest members of either of the former two groups. == References ==