Pilot episode In July 1993,
Briscos two-hour pilot was screened for television critics in Los Angeles.
USA Todays Matt Roush enjoyed the campy humor and the cast of the show, saying it worked on many levels and would "please all but the family curmudgeon". Calling
Brisco "one of the best shows of the fall season", Jennifer Stevenson of the
St. Petersburg Times praised the show's "intelligent, satirical asides". Kay Gardella wrote in the New York
Daily News that the pilot set itself "apart from others of genre" with its humorous script and sight gags. The
Los Angeles Times called
Brisco "gratifying nonsense", and praised Campbell and the supporting cast for supplying humor without "going over the top". Some critics, such as Walter Goodman of
The New York Times and David Hiltbrand of
People, found the supporting characters "weakly cast" and not as strong as Campbell in the lead. Other reviewers praised the overall look of the show, such as Todd Everett of
Variety, who approved of the "strong comic-book visual style" and the pilot's high production values. Writing in
The Washington Post, Tom Shales said that the pilot's production was "more movielike than serieslike". The pilot's science-fiction plot elements were appreciated by
New York magazine, which wrote favorably about the "
millenarianism" of the show, including Brisco's use of a rocket to travel on railroad tracks. While Rod Dreher of the
Washington Times liked the "nifty" Orb subplot, some critics responded negatively to the Orb. The
Washington Posts Shales called the Orb "hokey supernatural bunk". Diane Werts of
Newsday similarly said that
Brisco "just about hits the bulls eye" with its "sharp wit" and "thrill a minute" action, although she noted that the pilot was over-packed with characters and subplots. Writing in
The New York Times, Goodman said, "The writers try everything, including some business involving raiders of a lost orb, without much of a payoff." Writing in the
Toronto Star, Greg Quill said that the pilot introduced
Brisco as "a western in the loosest use of the term". Quill noted that the pilot includes "every cliche in the western movie arsenal", but that "everything, from characters to plot turns, is skewed away from the norm", and that the pilot episode rose above the level of western
spoof to become an "outrageously confident tribute to... the best of the genre". The magazine twice listed
Brisco as a family-friendly TV program: "Back when some of us grew up, Westerns were synonymous with great family entertainment, but – let's be honest – some of them were dull as dust. Not this one.
Brisco is a Western with a sense of humor, filled with impish action for kids and adults."
The Wall Street Journal reviewed a host of Westerns from 1992 and 1993 and said that
Brisco was "the most sheer fun of the bunch", calling it "a period piece with slick production values and a mix of drama and humor, fast pace and high camp". In an article on the 1993 television season, the
Toronto Stars Greg Quill wrote that
Brisco was a program that represented "American TV craft at the top of its form". In contrast, Elvis Mitchell of
Spin magazine gave
Brisco a scathing review, calling the show's premise a "tedious... rickety gimmick". Mitchell acknowledged the show's "quick reflexes", but said the humor was "uncomfortable" with a "cynical quickness". He added, "
Brisco County relieves us of the burden of laughing. It spends too much time looking at itself in the mirror, admiring its own adorable dimpled half-smile." Viewership figures for
Brisco fell as its season progressed and in 1994, it was listed in
TV Guides annual "Save Our Shows" article. Readers were requested to write in and vote to save one of the four listed shows – one from each television network – that were in danger of being cancelled.
The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr., won with 34.7 percent of the 72,000 votes cast. Cuse said the vote "reaffirms for me a feeling I've had – namely that the Nielsens aren't accurately reflecting people's interest in this show", adding that, given Fox's then relatively small share of the market, it was notable that the show got more votes than any of the programs from NBC, CBS, and ABC. Writing in
USA Today, Matt Roush encouraged readers to watch the low-rated show, saying that families should watch it rather than "that interchangeable
T.G.I.F. tripe". He said, "Brisco is mighty lavish but even more mightily loony, happily saddled with broad sight gags and tortured puns." Bruce Fretts of
Entertainment Weekly speculated that mainstream success eluded the show because of its mixing of genres. He said, "
Brisco refuses to behave like a normal Western, mixing in sci-fi, slapstick, and... kung fu."
Chicago Tribune's Scott Williams praised
Brisco for its "strong supporting cast" and "superb physical comedy and crisp dialogue". He said the show should have been a hit, but that the Friday night time slot hampered its ratings.
Level of violence Brisco was criticized early on for the violence it portrayed; meant to be comical, a scene in the pilot in which four villains accidentally kill each other in a crossfire troubled critics instead. Cuse insisted that the show was still appropriate for children, saying, "I think we're very conscious of violence and I think we've made an effort to avoid violence in the pilot and in the future episodes". Halfway through the season, U.S. Senator
Byron Dorgan singled out
Brisco as the most violent show on television based on a study at Minnesota's
Concordia University, in which students watched 132 hours of network and cable programming, during the week of September 28 to October 4, 1993. The students tallied each act of violence, and found that
Brisco had 117 violent acts per hour. The
Los Angeles Times printed a story about Senator Dorgan's efforts to elicit a response from the
Federal Communications Commission (FCC) with the title "Fox Tops Tally of Violence on Major TV Networks Media: Study of a week of prime-time shows also lists 'Brisco County' as bloodiest series. Senator wants FCC to issue report card, name sponsors". Cuse responded by writing a letter to the editor. In the letter, entitled "'Brisco County' Is a Family-Oriented Series", Cuse objected to the newspaper story title labeling
Brisco as the "bloodiest series". He said that Senator Dorgan's press release did not mention blood and that the show's violence should be viewed in context. Cuse added the show had been listed as family friendly in other publications, and that he read every viewer letter sent regarding the show. "The overwhelming majority praise "Brisco County" for being a show that the entire family can watch together. After 15 original airings, I have not received one single letter criticizing the show on the grounds of violence or violent content." When the
US Senate discussed forcing broadcast and cable networks to regulate violent programming, Cuse said that self-regulation within the industry was a positive move. As he operated on his "own internal moral principles", the measures would not affect his week-to-week work.
Post-cancellation Writing in
People magazine in 1995, Craig Tomashoff said the cancellation of
Brisco was "one of the tragedies going into [the 1994–1995] TV season". Tomashoff suggested that the show influenced
UPN's
Legend, another Western series with comedy and science fiction elements. Reflecting on the show in the
Orange County Register in 1996, critic Cary Darling lamented
Brisco's cancellation, saying that the show "stood way out from the rest of the broadcast pack". Darling reviewed the show, describing it as "a witty, multiracial Western that tempered its fisticuffs with fantasy, its innocence with irony, and its romantic vision of the Old West with an abiding New World faith in the future's infinite possibilities". When the series was released on DVD, critics remembered it fondly.
Video Librarian called
Brisco "criminally short-lived" and "wildly entertaining". Ken Tucker of
Entertainment Weekly gave the series an "A−", calling the show "smart-alecky and witty, suspenseful and absurd".
IGN DVD called the DVD set "impressive" and said that the series was "a satisfying show that hits its mark". In its 2006 gift guide, the
Christian Science Monitor gave
Brisco a positive review, saying, "Folks, there are so few comic sci-fi/Westerns, they should be celebrated, not canceled prematurely." In a 2018 interview with
Houston Chronicle, Bruce Campbell voiced an interest in reviving the series. "I would actually be willing to do a Brisco revisited". ==References==