Circumcision is one of the oldest surgical procedures in human history, and remains a highly emotional and controversial issue. Many societies hold a wide ranging perspectives and different cultural, ethical, or social
views on circumcision. Islamic, The
mitzvah of circumcision on the eighth day of life is considered among the
most important commandments in Judaism. Barring extraordinary circumstances, failure to undergo the rite is seen by followers of
Judaism as leading to a state of
Kareth: the extinction of the
soul and denial of a share in the
world to come. The basis for its observance is found in the
Torah of the Hebrew Bible, in
Genesis chapter 17, in which a covenant of circumcision is made with Abraham household and his descendants. Jewish circumcision is part of the ritual, to be performed by a trained ritual circumciser, a , on the eighth day of a newborn son's life, with certain exceptions for poor health. Jewish law requires that circumcision leaves the glans bare when the penis is flaccid. Mainstream Judaism foresees serious negative spiritual consequences if it is neglected. Though there are certain exceptions for those with poor health. The Reform and Reconstructionist movements generally do not require a circumcision as part of the conversion process. However, most streams of non-Orthodox Judaism allow female , called (, the plural of , feminine of ), without restriction. In 1984 Deborah Cohen became the first certified Reform ; she was certified by the Berit Mila program of Reform Judaism. All major rabbinical organizations recommend that male infants should be circumcised. The issue of converts remains controversial in Reform and Reconstructionist Judaism.
Brit shalom (
Hebrew: ברית שלום; "Covenant of Peace"), also called
alternative brit to the practice of brit milah, is a naming ceremony for Jews that does not involve circumcision. The first known ceremony is said to have been celebrated around 1970 by Rabbi
Sherwin Wine, the founder of the
Society for Humanistic Judaism. Although increasingly many U.S. Jews have chosen not to circumcise their sons, a study by
The Jewish Journal in the Greater Los Angeles area found brit shalom to be extremely rare.
Islam (present-day Indonesia), colonial era. , 2013 Islamic scholars have diverse opinions on the obligatory nature of male circumcision, with some considering it mandatory (
wājib), while others view it as only being recommended (
sunnah). According to
historians of religion and scholars of
religious studies, the Islamic tradition of circumcision was derived from the
Pagan practices and rituals of
pre-Islamic Arabia. Although there is some debate within Islam over whether it is a religious requirement or mere recommendation, circumcision (called
khitan) is practiced nearly universally by Muslim males. Islam bases its practice of circumcision on the Genesis 17 narrative, the same Biblical chapter referred to by Jews. The procedure is not explicitly mentioned in the Quran, however, it is a tradition established by Islam's prophet
Muhammad directly (following Abraham), and so its practice is considered a
sunnah (prophet's tradition) and is very important in Islam. For Muslims, circumcision is also a matter of cleanliness, purification and control over one's baser self (
nafs).
Christianity Traditionally, circumcision has not been practiced by Christians for religious reasons. The practice was viewed as succeeded by
Baptism and the
New Testament chapter
Acts 15 recorded that Christianity did not require circumcision from new converts. Christian denominations generally hold a neutral position on circumcision for prophylactic, cultural, and social reasons, while strongly opposing it for religious reasons. This includes the
Catholic Church, which explicitly banned the practice of religious circumcision in the
Council of Florence, and maintains a neutral position on the practice of circumcision for other reasons. A majority of other
Christian denominations take a similar position on circumcision, prohibiting it for religious observance, but neither explicitly supporting or forbidding it for other reasons. and generally boys undergo circumcision shortly after birth as part of a
rite of passage. and they practice circumcision as a rite of passage. Some Christian churches in South Africa disapprove of the practice, while others require it of their members.
Christian communities in
Africa, some
Anglosphere countries, the Philippines, the Middle East, South Korea and
Oceania have high circumcision rates, while Christian communities in
Europe and
South America have low circumcision rates, although none of these are performed out of perceived religious obligation. Scholar Heather L. Armstrong writes that, about half of Christian males worldwide are circumcised, with most of them being located in Africa, Anglosphere countries, and the Philippines.
Druze faith child Circumcision is widely practiced by the
Druze, who practice Druzism, an
Abrahamic,
monotheistic,
syncretic, and
ethnic religion. The procedure is a cultural tradition and has no religious significance in Druzism. There is no special date for it; male infants are usually circumcised shortly after birth,
Samaritanism Like Judaism, the religion of
Samaritanism requires ritual circumcision on the eighth day of life.
Mandaeism Circumcision is forbidden in
Mandaeism, and Mandaeans consider it abhorrent. According to Mandaean doctrine, a circumcised man cannot serve as a
Mandaean priest.
Yazidism Circumcision is not required in
Yazidism, but is practised by some
Yazidis due to regional customs. The ritual is usually performed soon after birth; it takes place on the knees of the kerîf (approximately "godfather"), with whom the child will have a lifelong formal relationship.
Indian religions Hinduism , male sex organ-placed on
yoni, female sex organ. In Hinduism, lingam and yoni represent the
masculine and the
feminine creative principles respectively. In
Hinduism, the
Upanishads say that the nature of the higher self (
Brahman), in essence, is
bliss (
ānanda), which the self in each being (
Atman) experiences during dreamless deep sleep but remains unconscious of, consciously experiencing it during
sensual activity. The
Brihadaranyaka Upanishad says that in humans, genitals are the "single locus of pleasure (
ānanda)". In
Sanskrit literature, the penis is called
Upastha ("that which stands up") and is traditionally considered a "source of great power or vitality (
ojas)." In Yoga physiology, the penis corresponds with
svadhishthana chakra, and channels the flow of
nadis, which enable higher sensations and consciousness. Consequently, circumcision, or even an interference with a tight foreskin, is strictly forbidden in
Hindu traditions.
Sikhism Sikhism does not require circumcision of its followers and strongly criticizes the practice. The
Guru Granth Sahib criticizes circumcision in a hymn. The holy book of Sikhs, dating to 1708, bans circumcision as an Islamic custom, saying: "If God wished me to be a Muslim, it would be cut off by itself."
Buddhism Buddhism neither requires nor prohibits circumcision, and it contains no canonical injunction regarding circumcision; the Pali Vinaya, which governs monastic conduct in detail, makes no mention of the practice. The 10th of the 32 attributes of an
enlightened person is possibly a reference to circumcision: "His sexual organs are concealed in a sheath and exude a pleasant odor similar to vanilla."The ceremony, known as
sünnet düğünü (circumcision celebration) in Turkey, is typically one of the most important events in a boy's life, often rivaling weddings in scale and expense. Boys are usually circumcised between the ages of 2 and 14, with the timing varying by region and family preference. The celebration commonly includes the boy wearing special ceremonial attire, often resembling a prince's costume or military uniform, and parading through the community on horseback or in a decorated vehicle. Among the
Uyghurs, the tradition is called
xetne toyi and remains an important rite of passage. In traditional practice, the ceremony was accompanied by feasting, music, and gift-giving, serving as an important occasion for community bonding and the affirmation of cultural identity.|250x250px
Filipino culture In the Philippines, circumcision is known as "tuli" and is generally viewed as a rite of passage. Often this occurs in April and May, when Filipino boys are taken by their parents. The practice dates back to the arrival of
Islam in 1450. Pressure to be circumcised is even in the language: one
Tagalog profanity for "uncircumcised" is
supot, meaning "coward". A circumcised eight- or ten-year-old is no longer considered a boy and is given more adult roles in the family and society.
Ethics Regulations Worldwide, most polities have no laws about circumcision of males, Randi Gressgård, Researcher at the Centre for Women's and Gender Research (SKOK) at the University of Bergen, argued that politicians that supported Norway's proposed circumcision ban debated circumcision in a manner which constituted "
ethnocentrism".
Economic considerations The cost-effectiveness of circumcision has been studied to determine whether a policy of circumcising all newborns or a policy of promoting and providing inexpensive or free access to circumcision for all adult men who choose it would result in lower overall societal healthcare costs. As
HIV/AIDS is an incurable disease that is expensive to manage, significant effort has been spent studying the cost-effectiveness of circumcision to reduce its spread in parts of Africa that have a relatively high infection rate and low circumcision prevalence. In Rwanda, circumcision has been found to be cost-effective across a wide range of age groups from newborn to adult, A 2014 literature review found significant gaps in the literature on male and female sexual health that must be addressed for the literature to be applicable to North American populations. == References ==