This scripture was cited at the end of
Puritan John Winthrop's lecture or treatise, "
A Model of Christian Charity" delivered on March 21, 1630, at
Holyrood Church in
Southampton, before his first group of
Massachusetts Bay colonists embarked on the ship
Arbella to settle Boston. In quoting Matthew's Gospel (5:14) in which Jesus warns, "a city on a hill cannot be hid," Winthrop warned his fellow Puritans that their new community would be "as a city upon a hill, the eyes of all people are upon us", meaning, if the Puritans failed to uphold their covenant with God, then their sins and errors would be exposed for all the world to see: "So that if we shall deal falsely with our God in this work we have undertaken and so cause him to withdraw his present help from us, we shall be made a story and a byword through the world". Winthrop's lecture was forgotten for nearly two hundred years until the
Massachusetts Historical Society published it in 1839. It remained an obscure reference for more than another century until Cold War era historians and political leaders reinterpreted the event, crediting Winthrop's text, erroneously, as the foundational document of the idea of
American exceptionalism. Winthrop's warning that "we will become a story" has been fulfilled several times in the four centuries since, as described in
Wayward Puritans: A Study in the Sociology of Deviance by
Kai T. Erikson in 1966. More recently,
Princeton historian Dan T. Rogers, in his 2018 book ''As a City on a Hill: The Story of America's Most Famous Lay Sermon'', made an effort to correct the record, arguing that there was no grand sense of destiny among the first Puritans to settle Boston. They carried no ambitions to build a New Jerusalem, they did not name their new home Zion, or
Canaan, the promised land of milk and honey; rather, they sought only a place to uphold their covenant with God, free from the interference they experienced in England. By the second generation of settlement, New England was considered a backwater in the Protestant Reformation, an inconsequential afterthought to the Puritan Commonwealth in England and the wealthier Dutch Republic, and in truth,
America's sense of destiny came generations later. ==Use in American politics==