In 1865–1866, Dana conducted the newly established and unsuccessful Chicago
Republican, when the paper was owned by
Jacob Bunn, and published by A.W. (Alonzo) Mack (1822-1871). He became the editor and part-owner of
The Sun, a New York City newspaper, in 1868, and remained in control of it until his death. Upon taking control of the organization, he announced his credo: It will study condensation, clearness, point, and will endeavor to present its daily photograph of the whole world's doings in the most luminous and lively manner. Under Dana's control,
The Sun opposed the impeachment of
President Andrew Johnson; it supported Grant for the presidency in 1868; it was a sharp critic of Grant as president; and in 1872 took part in the Liberal Republican revolt and urged Greeley's nomination. In contrast with "the young Dana [who was] touched by the
Transcendental wand, a fiery youth, frank, open, trusting, a believer in the possibility of realizing an ideal society upon earth ... the Dana of the seventies and eighties and nineties [was] an aging cynic.... [H]e fought civil service reform tooth and nail.... He believed in expanding the American republic by wholesale land-grabbing.... He was opposed to the main aims of the labor movement.... Half the time he and the Sun were on the side of the worst politicians in Tammany, and against the reform movements in city government." Dana made the
Sun a
Democratic newspaper, independent and outspoken in the expression of its opinions respecting the affairs of either party. His criticisms of civil maladministration during General Grant's terms as president led to a notable attempt on the part of that administration, in July 1873, to take him from New York on a charge of libel, to be tried without a jury in a Washington police court. Application was made to the
United States District Court in New York for a warrant of removal, but in a memorable decision Judge
Samuel Blatchford, later a justice of the
Supreme Court of the United States, refused the warrant, holding the proposed form of trial to be unconstitutional. Perhaps to a greater extent than in the case of any other conspicuous journalist, Dana's personality was identified in the public mind with the newspaper that he edited. In 1876,
The Sun favored
Samuel J. Tilden, the Democratic candidate for the presidency, opposed the
Electoral Commission, and continually referred to
Rutherford B. Hayes as the "fraud president". In 1884 it supported
Benjamin Butler, the candidate of Greenback-Labor and Anti-Monopolist parties, for the presidency, and opposed
James G. Blaine (
Republican) and even more bitterly
Grover Cleveland (Democrat). Circulation peaked about 150,000, and the advent of
Joseph Pulitzer and the
New York World cut deeply into the ''Sun's'' circulation. Dana was a very old-fashioned publisher who distrusted the
Linotype and relied not on advertising but on the two-cent cover price for his funding. In 1888 it supported Cleveland and opposed
Benjamin Harrison, although it had bitterly criticized Cleveland's first administration, and was to criticize nearly every detail of his second, with the exception of Federal interference in the
Pullman strike of 1894; and in 1896, on the
free silver issue, it opposed
William Jennings Bryan, the Democratic candidate for the presidency. In a word, the
Sun had abandoned its original working-class clientele and was now a staunch supporter of the conservative business community. he died in New York on October 17, 1897 at 78. ==Writing==