On
Passover 2001, Wolpe told his congregation that "the way the Bible describes the Exodus is not the way it happened, if it happened at all." Casting doubt on the historicity of
the Exodus during the
holiday that commemorates it brought condemnation from congregants and several rabbis (especially
Orthodox Rabbis). The ensuing theological debate included whole issues of Jewish newspapers such as
The Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angeles and editorials in
The Jerusalem Post, as well as an article in the
Los Angeles Times. Critics asserted that Wolpe was attacking Jewish
oral history, the significance of Passover and even the
First Commandment. Orthodox Rabbi Ari Hier wrote that "Rabbi Wolpe has chosen
Aristotle over
Maimonides, theories and scientific method over facts". Wolpe, on the other hand, was defended by
Reform Rabbi Steven Leder from the
Wilshire Boulevard Temple, who argued that "defending a rabbi in the 21st century for saying the Exodus story isn't factual is like defending him for saying the earth isn't flat. It's neither new nor shocking to most of us that the earth is round or that the
Torah isn't a history book dictated to Moses by God on
Mount Sinai." Wolpe asserted that he was arguing that the historicity of the events should not matter, since he believes
faith is not determined by the same criteria as empirical
truth. Wolpe argues that no archeological digs have produced evidence of the Jews wandering the Sinai Desert for forty years, and that excavations in Israel consistently show settlement patterns at variance with the Biblical account of a sudden influx of Jews from Egypt. In March 2010, Wolpe expounded on his views saying that it was possible that a small group of people left Egypt, came to Canaan, and influenced the native Canaanites with their traditions. He added that the controversy of 2001 stemmed from the fact that
Conservative Jewish congregations have been slow to accept and embrace
biblical criticism. Conservative rabbis, on the other hand, are taught biblical criticism in rabbinical school. ==Gay marriage==