Descent to Undermountain was generally poorly received. The decision to use the
Descent graphics engine was cited as a design issue, as it required heavy rewrites to the code in order to support an RPG setting such as Undermountain. According to game designer Eric Bethke, bugs, poor AI, the unappealing and shoddy nature of the graphics, and several other issues have attributed to a general consensus of the game as an example of a title that was pushed to release before it was ready. Technical issues existed in the concept which delayed development, forcing redesigns and re-engineering. Ultimately the "quick change" to Descent's rendering engine proved to be extremely challenging which exceeded the technical understanding of the corporate leadership who were resolved to predetermined delivery dates. This lack of understanding led to a hurried development cycle, and the game was maligned by Bethke as "a classic example of a game that was shipped too early." Julian Schoffel, in the Australian
PCWorld, called the game "woeful", with the hope that the following release, ''
Baldur's Gate, might "redeem" Interplay as a company. GamePro'' blasted it as having outdated visuals, numerous bugs, and difficult setup and configuration. Though the praised the level designs, they concluded that "you can't escape the feeling that, despite this game's two-year delay,
Descent to Undermountain still isn't finished." They gave it 2.5 out of 5 for graphics, 4.0 for sound, 3.0 for control, and 3.0 for fun factor. On the other hand, Ahmed Kamal Nava of the
New Straits Times called it the best role-playing game of 1997.
Next Generation rated it one star out of five, citing outdated visuals and a poorly designed player interface, though they said the character creation system is the best recreation of the
Forgotten Realms universe in a video game to date. According to
GameSpy, "
Descent to Undermountain had only one virtue - it made everybody forget about ''
Gorgon's Alliance and the entire previous two years of atrocious Dungeons & Dragons'' games." Interplay acknowledged this poor reception with an easter egg in the
computer role-playing game Fallout 2, released a year after
Undermountain. The player may obtain a
Magic 8 Ball item which typically dispenses advice but also has a few gag lines. One of these is "Yes, we KNOW Descent to Undermountain was crap." ==References==