Lori and Chad's trials in Idaho A jury trial for the Madison County charges against Lori was initially set for January 25–29, 2021. In December 2021, Lori's attorney Mark Means was disqualified from the case because his representation of both Lori and Chad created a conflict. On April 11, 2022, Lori was deemed competent to stand trial after mental health treatment. On October 6, 2022, after Lori's new defense team filed several
motions, Judge Steven W. Boyce issued an order indicating the case was suspended until her competency to stand trial could be determined. On November 16, she was once again found competent. Lori and Chad both pleaded not guilty to all charges in Idaho. Their cases were split in March 2023, at Chad's request. The reasons were that Chad had
waived his right to a
speedy trial and his attorneys said they needed more time to review
DNA evidence. Lori's trial began on April 3, 2023, On April 15, pictures of the children's corpses were shown to jurors and audience. Lori asked to be excused from court that day; this was denied, as the defendant in a felony case must be present at all significant proceedings. Melanie Gibb, Audrey Barattiero (another former friend of Lori's who had also participated in her religious group) and Ian Pawlowski (the husband of Lori's niece Melani) testified about Lori's beliefs and her claims that she could cast out Satan and other evil spirits. Barattiero said that when she grew uncomfortable about Lori's beliefs and decided to dissolve their friendship, Lori threatened to murder her and dispose of her body in trash bags. In the light of the evidence that pointed to Alex Cox's direct involvement in the murders, prosecutors stated that Lori Vallow Daybell had "groomed" and "manipulated" her brother to participate in her crimes. Zulema Pastenes said that Alex was entirely under the influence of Chad and Lori, who had convinced him that he was a reincarnated warrior of God and that "the only reason he had come to Earth was to protect Lori." Prosecutor Rob Wood summed up the evidence that showed Lori had participated in the conspiracy to commit all three murders and reminded the jury how Lori had never reported that her children were missing and had lied to multiple people about their whereabouts. On May 12, 2023, Lori was found guilty of all criminal charges. On July 31, 2023, she received three
consecutive life sentences without the possibility of
parole for, respectively, the murder of Tylee, the murder of J.J., and the conspiracy to murder Tammy, in addition to fines and restitution for the grand theft charges. Before her sentencing, Lori made her first public statement since her arrest. She said that she had been speaking to Jesus, as well as to her children and to Tammy, and that Tylee, J.J. and Tammy were "happy and extremely busy" in heaven. She also stated, "Jesus Christ knows that no one was murdered in this case. Accidental deaths happen, suicides happen, fatal side effects from medications happen." On May 30, 2025, Lori's attorney filed a notice of appeal for her 2023 conviction, demanding a new trial. The motions were denied in December. Chad Daybell's trial opened on April 10, 2024. In his opening statement, prosecutor Wood depicted him as a man motivated by "sex, money and power" and craving for significance, who saw his spouse and Lori's children as obstacles to his rightful destiny. Chad's attorney John Prior painted him as a religious man who had been "lured" into
adultery by Lori Vallow. Prior's statement also focused on Alex Cox's history of violence and his role as "Lori's protector." On the contrary, three former colleagues of Tammy Daybell said that she seemed healthy and energetic up until the day before her death. During the closing arguments, prosecutor Lindsey Blake summarized the evidence that pointed to Chad's crucial role in coordinating and giving a religious justification to the murders. Prior painted Lori and Alex Cox as the true culprits, stating that Lori had been motivated by greed, that she had manipulated Chad all along and that Chad would likely have been her next victim. It was confirmed that the prosecution would seek the death penalty for Chad. At his
sentencing hearing, Chad chose not to present any
mitigating evidence. On June 1, 2024, he was sentenced to
death. For the insurance fraud charges, he was sentenced to 15 years in prison, to run concurrent to death, and to the restitution of $130,000 plus $300,000. Since Chad had been deemed indigent, no fines were added to the insurance fraud sentence. Chad was put on
death row at
Idaho Maximum Security Institution. On June 5, 2024, Chad's attorneys filed notice of appeal to
Idaho Supreme Court asking them to review verdict and death penalty sentence.
Lori's trials in Arizona (2025) , where Lori Vallow Daybell stood trial. In November 2023, Lori was extradited to Arizona to face her two conspiracy charges there. She pleaded not guilty to both. In February 2024, her trial was scheduled to begin on August 1 of the same year, though the judge mentioned that it might be moved at a later date due to the amount of evidence to process. In June, Lori's defense team in Arizona filed a motion requesting a delay for the trial. Lori objected and continued to assert her right to a speedy trial. On July 2, the lawyers' request was granted and the trial date was moved to February 24, 2025. In October 2024, Colby Ryan posted on his YouTube channel the recording of a telephone conversation he had had with his mother from her prison. During their exchange, Lori claimed that she received "higher knowledge" directly from Jesus and was on a "divine mission," said that Tylee and J.J. had visited her in spirit, and suggested that Tylee had accidentally killed J.J. and then taken her own life in remorse. Colby commented that his mother was "beyond deceived." Also in October 2024, Lori's attorneys made a request for a
competency hearing. One week later, she requested to waive her
right to counsel and
act as her own attorney. At a December 5, 2024, hearing, Lori was deemed by a doctor to be mentally fit and competent to stand trial. Judge Justin Beresky also granted Lori's request to represent herself. Lori said at the hearing that she had "real trial experience" and had been studying
case law since her incarceration. The court decided that the Charles Vallow case and the Brandon Boudreaux case would be tried separately. The judge moved again the trial date for the Charles Vallow conspiracy case, this time to March 31, 2025. Her trial over the murder attempt on Brandon Boudreaux was eventually scheduled to begin in late May. In both Arizona trials, members of the jury had to be unaware of Lori and her previous convictions.
Charles Vallow case Lori's trial over Charles' death began on March 31 with
jury selection. Lori told jurors that their role was to "protect" her from the state. On April 7, during her opening statement, Lori maintained that Alex Cox had shot Charles in self-defense and announced that she would provide proof of this. She used the phrase "The evidence will show..." over 70 times during her statement. The prosecution said that Lori had conspired to murder Charles so she could access his life insurance policy and marry Chad, that Cox had staged the home to make it look like Charles had attacked him and Lori, and that there was no evidence Cox had been hit with a baseball bat like he claimed. At one point, Lori "aggressively" cross-examined a witness who had gone on a date with Charles the day before he was killed: Lori asked the woman if she went on dates with married men. Adam Cox, Lori's surviving brother, testified for the prosecution, saying that he had "no doubt" Lori had conspired with Alex to murder Charles. When Charles was killed, he and Adam had been planning to confront Lori together about her beliefs. Charles had been hit by two bullets: evidence showed that he was lying on the floor when he was shot the second time. Lori ultimately did not call any witnesses or present evidence, nor did she testify in her own defense. She made a verbal motion for a
Rule 20 judgment of acquittal, arguing that no evidence had been presented that would allow a jury to find her guilty. The judge denied her motion. On April 22, 2025, Lori was found guilty of conspiring to murder Charles. After the verdict, she agreed to several
aggravating factors. One of the jurors told reporters that Lori hadn't done herself any favors by choosing to represent herself in court: "Many days she was just smiling and laughing and didn’t seem to take anything very seriously." When asked by reporters if she had a message for Lori, Kay Woodcock said, "We gotcha, and you're not the smartest person in the room. Everybody's going to forget about you." On May 1, Lori filed a motion demanding a new trial for the Charles Vallow murder case, claiming that a juror had been aware of her prior murder convictions. She also claimed there had been
discovery violations,
prosecutorial misconduct, and a lack of impartiality by the court, and that her rights had been violated under the
Religious Freedom Restoration Act. Her motion was denied on May 23.
Brandon Boudreaux case After Lori was found guilty of conspiring to murder Charles Vallow, Maricopa County attorney
Rachel Mitchell confirmed that despite Lori's multiple convictions, she fully intended to prosecute her for the murder attempt on Brandon Boudreaux, as it was important for Boudreaux "to be able to have his story vindicated." Lori filed a motion to cancel her trial in the Brandon Boudreaux case, claiming that her constitutional right to a speedy trial had been violated. The judge rejected that motion on May 9. During the hearing, Lori argued with Judge Beresky over jury selection and witnesses. After her motion was denied, she demanded that the judge
recuse himself, claiming that he demonstrated bias against her by rejecting all her motions. The judge answered that he would grant a motion by Lori if she filed one that had legal merit. On May 28, Lori filed a motion for the judge to recuse himself, alleging "personal bias or prejudice" and religious discrimination against her. Her motion was denied the next day. She filed three motions for recusal against Judge Beresky during the proceedings. Lori's second Arizona trial began on May 29 with jury selection. The next day, jury selection had to be halted On June 2, Lori appeared in court in a wheelchair, saying she was suffering from nausea, chills and headache, and crying loudly. The trial was postponed for two days. On June 4, Lori appeared again in court, not using a wheelchair but insisting that she was still sick. The judge said that based on an examination that showed Lori had no medical condition preventing her from appearing, the trial would proceed. During her opening statement, on June 5, Lori claimed her innocence, disputing that the event was not a crime at all or that a shooting had actually occurred. She discussed the meaning of the word 'conspiracy' by comparing her own case to
Judas conspiring against Jesus and
Cain against
Abel, and stated that she had no malice towards anyone and was "all about spreading love." Brandon Boudreaux took the stand, telling the court that Lori had contributed to the breakup of his marriage and recounting the moment he was shot. Prosecutor Treena Kay showed the evidence, including cellphone location data, that pointed to Lori's involvement in the preparations for the murder. On June 6, Lori cross-examined Boudreaux and the private investigator he had hired after being shot. She cast suspicion on her niece Melani by asking if she had a financial gain at Boudreaux's death. The prosecutor mentioned that Melani was under investigation. Also on June 6, Lori was briefly removed from the courtroom after failing to comply with the court's instructions and disregarding sustained
objections. The judge threatened to revoke her self-representation. On June 9, Lori filed a motion to recuse Chief Judge Jennifer Green, who had denied her multiple motions to recuse Judge Beresky. She also filed a motion to "dismiss abuse of discretion." Both were denied. Once again, Lori did not testify in her defense or call witnesses. She instead tried to cast doubt on nearly every piece of evidence, also suggesting that data could have been tampered with. On June 12, Lori was found guilty of conspiring to murder Brandon Boudreaux, after the jury had deliberated for less than 30 minutes. Brandon Boudreaux, standing with Kay Woodcock and Colby Ryan, stated that though facing Lori at the trial had been difficult for him, he had owed it to Charles, Tylee, J.J. and Tammy to speak, "because [he] could." On June 25, Lori filed a motion requesting a new trial, citing her own health condition during the trial and lack of impartiality by the court. On June 26, she granted an interview to East Idaho News, in which she said that she still loved Chad, reaffirmed her innocence, and predicted that she and Chad would be exonerated. Her motion asking for a new trial was denied on July 22.
Sentencing Prosecutors requested a life sentence without parole for each case, to run concurrently with the convictions in Idaho. Sentencing for both cases took place on July 25. During her final testimony, Lori claimed that she had been denied a fair trial and said God would set prisoners free. Judge Beresky said Lori had "shown blatant disregard for humanity" and should never be released from prison. Lori was given two consecutive life sentences without the possibility of parole before 25 years. ==Media depictions==