. On 14 September 2023, Urfan, Beinash, and Faisal were all charged with murder along with an additional charge of causing or allowing the death of a child. They were
remanded in custody ahead of a hearing on 15 September at Guildford
Magistrates' Court. They appeared before London's
Old Bailey on 19 September 2023 via
videolink. A plea hearing took place in December 2023, at which all three pleaded not guilty to each charge, and they were set to stand trial in September 2024. At a hearing on 1 March, it was confirmed the trial was tabled to begin on 1 October. On 8 October 2024, the jury was sworn in at the start of the trial of the three defendants at the Old Bailey. At the trial, Sara's more than 70 injuries were revealed: these included injuries to her ribs, shoulder blades, fingers and 11 fractures to her spine, a puncture wound to the head, a
traumatic brain injury, a burn on her buttock caused by a domestic iron, scalds by hot water, restraint injuries, bruises
caused by blunt objects and human bite marks. The cause of death was determined to be "complications arising from multiple injuries and neglect". A paediatric
radiologist provided evidence that Sara had sustained neck injuries that occur "extremely rare[ly]" and that said injuries were likely caused by "manual
strangulation with a degree of force above that which we would normally recognise in ligature force – meaning
hanging". He said that Sara's spinal fractures were "very rare", and compared them to those usually found in victims of
traffic collisions. An osteoarticular
pathologist testified that she had
hyoid bone and wrist fractures, both of which were determined to be caused deliberately. He also stated that those fractures were not what had killed her. A burns and plastic surgeon provided evidence, saying that Sara had been burnt on the
buttocks by a
clothes iron, causing "significant physical and psychological discomfort". He said that though he could not provide an exact date for the injury, he believed it between two and six weeks before her death. There was no evidence of leftover
adhesive near the wound, suggesting that the wound was neglected. Sara's feet were also
scalded by a liquid. Mark Chapman, a detective
chief superintendent in Surrey Police, said that he had never seen "such horrific suffering of a young person" in his 30-year career. In November 2024, Urfan accepted "full responsibility" for causing Sara's death in court during
cross-examination. He called himself the "worst parent on the planet" and admitted during cross-examination that he mistreated Sara, but said that Beinash was "the true villain of the piece" and accused her of assaulting him. On 11 December 2024, Urfan and Beinash were found guilty of murdering Sara.
Imprisonment On 1 January 2025, Urfan, while serving his sentence at
HM Prison Belmarsh, was ambushed in his cell by two inmates who attacked him by slitting his throat with a tuna can lid. Urfan sustained non-life threatening injuries to his face and neck. He was treated inside the prison and was not transported to a hospital. After the attack, Urfan was transferred to
HM Prison Frankland under heavy security. While incarcerated at
HM Prison Bronzefield, Beinash was reported to have become good friends with
Lucy Letby, a former neonatal nurse convicted of murdering seven infants. The two women played cards together and talked frequently. They were housed in the same secure unit to protect them from other inmates.
Related litigation The
High Court of Justice placed a
gag order on the media in December 2024 to prevent them from reporting the names of the judges that placed Sara in Urfan's custody, due to a "real risk of harm" from a "virtual
lynch mob".
Geoffrey Vos, the
Master of the Rolls, overturned the previous judgement after an appeal by media organisations, calling it "misguided". The judges overseeing the family court trial were named as Alison Raeside, Peter Nathan, and Sally Williams, In January 2025, the
Solicitor General's Office referred Urfan's sentence to the Court of Appeal under the
Unduly Lenient Sentence Scheme, asking the court to impose a
whole life order. At the same time, Urfan, Beinash and Malik petitioned the Court of Appeal to reduce their sentences. A hearing on the cases was held on 13 March 2025 and the court delivered its ruling the same day, upholding all three sentences and rejecting the Solicitor General's application. == Aftermath ==