Effigy of the Forgotten has received critical acclaim and is considered by many to be one of the most influential death metal albums of all time. It is regarded as a pioneering record in the development of multiple subgenres of death metal, notably
brutal death metal,
slam death metal, and
technical death metal, becoming a benchmark of the latter genre along with
Death's fourth album
Human,
Pestilence's third album
Testimony of the Ancients, and
Atheist's second album
Unquestionable Presence.
Decibel Magazine would later say: "
Effigy of the Forgotten was a benchmark for extreme music, as it sacrificed neither virtuosity or brutality, becoming a signpost for thousands who were still contemplating how to incorporate
scalar runs, rapid-fire
palm-muting and hummingbird-wing-quick
picking into riffs, while opening up rhythmic dimensions and the scope of the
blast beat." In 2013, Graham Hartmann of
Loudwire wrote: "Baffling enough, when performed live, the tracks from
Effigy of the Forgotten consistently remain as Suffocation's most purely brutal offerings. The album is widely known for blueprinting low guttural vocals and integrating masterful technicality within brutal death metal, and the disc's tracks 'Infecting the Crypts,' 'Liege of Inveracity' and 'Jesus Wept' could compete with any modern death metal song in a competition of pure heaviness." In 2016,
Invisible Oranges commended the album's artwork and Burn's production, conferring the titles of "
bonafide death metal classic" and "one of the heaviest [...] ever recorded" on the album. Staff writer
Tom Campagna wrote: "The band would go on to record the ill-fated
Breeding The Spawn a year and a half later. For that album, Roadrunner refused to let the band join Scott Burns in the studio again, which led to a poor recording and eventually Smith’s first exit from the band (he returned when the band reformed in 2004 with
Souls to Deny). But for a shining moment in 1991 Suffocation were one of the most promising, new, brutally heavy, technically sound bands on the scene. 25 years later this is still one of the heaviest albums ever recorded.
Metal Hammer named
Effigy the 18th best death metal album of all time, calling it "effectively
ground zero" for the brutal death metal subgenre. == Track listing ==