Ratings The season received high
Nielsen ratings; the season premiere, "North by North Quahog", was broadcast as part of an animated television night on Fox, alongside two episodes of
The Simpsons and
the pilot episode of
American Dad!. The episode was watched by 11.85 million viewers, the show's highest ratings since the airing of the
first season episode "
Brian: Portrait of a Dog". Its ratings also surpassed the ratings of both episodes of
The Simpsons and
American Dad!. bringing the season average to 7.9 million viewers per episode.
Awards and nominations The season was nominated for a number of awards. In 2005, the
Academy of Television Arts & Sciences nominated "North by North Quahog" for a
Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Animated Program (for Programming Less Than One Hour). It nominated "
PTV" in the same category one year later. Neither of the episodes won the award, as
South Park received the award in 2005 and
The Simpsons was the eventual recipient of the award in 2006.
Peter Shin and
Dan Povenmire were both nominated for an
Annie Award in the Best Directing in an Animated Television Production category, for directing "North by North Quahog" and "PTV" respectively; Shin eventually won the award. MacFarlane won the Annie Award for Best Voice-over Performance for providing the voice of Stewie in "
Brian the Bachelor". The editors of the episode "
Blind Ambition" won the
Motion Picture Sound Editors Golden Reel Award for Best Sound Editing in Television Animated.
Critical reception Season 4 received positive reviews from critics. Reviewing the season premiere, Mark McGuire of
The Times Union wrote: "... the first minute or so of the resurrected
Family Guy ranks among the funniest 60 seconds I've seen so far this season."
The Pitt News reviewer John Nigro felt that the show had not lost its steam while it was on hiatus, and was surprised that the show had been canceled because of its "wildly extravagant shock factor". In 2007,
BBC Three named the episode "PTV" "The Best Episode...So Far". The episode has also been praised by Maureen Ryan of the
Chicago Tribune, who called it "
Family Guys most rebellious outing yet".
The Boston Globe critic Matthew Gilbert felt
Family Guys fourth season was as "crankily irreverent as ever". Critics of both
PopMatters and
IGN criticized the first few episodes but felt the show regained its humor after "
Don't Make Me Over"; IGN's Mike Drucker commented "At that point, we get some amazingly creative humor. It's almost like MacFarlane and gang decided they had thanked their fans enough and could return to what made the show successful in the first place." "
The Father, the Son, and the Holy Fonz", "
Brian Sings and Swings", "
Patriot Games", and "
The Courtship of Stewie's Father" as "worst show of the week". ==Notes==