1965: Rookie season Sayers was the fourth overall selection in the
1965 NFL draft, taken by the
Chicago Bears, and was also picked fifth overall by the
Kansas City Chiefs of the
American Football League in the
AFL draft. After consulting his wife, he decided he would rather play in Chicago, signing with
George Halas's Bears. In his rookie year, Sayers scored an NFL-record 22 touchdowns: 14 rushing, six receiving, and one each on punt and kickoff returns. He gained 2,272
all-purpose yards, a record for an NFL rookie, with 1,371 of them coming
from scrimmage. Sayers averaged 5.2 yards per rush and 17.5 yards per reception. His return averages were 14.9 yards per punt return and a league-high 31.4 yards per kickoff return. Against the
Minnesota Vikings on October 17, Sayers carried 13 times for 64 yards and a touchdown; caught four passes for 63 yards and two touchdowns, and had a 98-yard kickoff return touchdown in the 45–37 Bears victory. He was the last NFL player to score a rushing, receiving, and kickoff return touchdown in the same game until
Tyreek Hill accomplished the feat over 50 years later in 2016. Bears coach Halas lauded Sayers after the game, saying, "I don't ever remember seeing a rookie back who was as good," and deemed his talents equal to former Bears greats
Red Grange and
George McAfee. "And remember," said Halas, "we used to call George 'One-Play McAfee'." On December 12, Sayers tied
Ernie Nevers' and
Dub Jones' record for touchdowns in a single game, scoring six in a 61–20 victory over the
San Francisco 49ers that was played in muddy conditions at the
Chicago Cubs'
Wrigley Field. He accounted for 326 yards in the game: 113 rushing, 89 receiving, and 134 on punt returns. Sayers was the consensus choice for
NFL Rookie of the Year honors from the AP, UPI, and NEA. He was quoted as saying at the time:
1966: First rushing title In his second season, Sayers led the league in rushing with 1,231 yards, averaging 5.4 yards per carry with eight touchdowns, and becoming the first Chicago Bears halfback to win the
rushing title since 1949. He also led the Bears in receiving with 34 catches, 447 yards, and two more touchdowns. He surpassed his rookie season's kick return numbers, averaging 31.2 yards per return with two touchdowns. He also supplanted his all-purpose yards total from the previous season, gaining 2,440 to set the NFL record. The first of his kickoff return touchdowns that season came against the
Los Angeles Rams, as he followed a wedge of blockers en route to a 93-yard score. Against the
Minnesota Vikings in the Bears' final game of the season, and the first of Sayers' pro career with his parents in attendance, he carried 17 times for a franchise-record 197 yards after returning the opening kickoff 90 yards for a touchdown. Sayers was named to All-Pro first-teams by the AP, UPI, the NEA,
The Sporting News, and the
Pro Football Writers Association, among others. The Bears finished the season with a 5–7–2 record, and the
Chicago Tribune tabbed Sayers as "the one bright spot in Chicago's pro football year."
1967: Shared workload In Halas's final season as an NFL coach, Sayers again starred. Sharing more of the rushing duties with other backs, such as
Brian Piccolo, Sayers gained 880 yards with a 4.7-yard average per carry. His receptions were down as well. He had three kickoff returns for touchdowns on 16 returns, averaging 37.7 yards per return. Only rarely returning punts—he returned three all season—Sayers still managed to return one for a score against the
San Francisco 49ers, a game in which he also returned the opening kickoff 97 yards for a touchdown and scored a rushing touchdown on a rain-soaked field in San Francisco's
Kezar Stadium. "It was a bad field, but it didn't stop some people," said 49ers coach
Jack Christiansen of Sayers' performance. Christiansen said that after Sayers' kickoff return, he ordered that all punts go out of bounds. But Sayers received the punt and ran 58 yards through the middle of the field for the score. In a November game against the
Detroit Lions, a
cutback by Sayers caused future hall of fame cornerback
Lem Barney to fall over, after which Sayers sprinted for a 63-yard gain. Later in the game he returned a kickoff 97 yards for a touchdown. After the season, Sayers was chosen for his third straight Pro Bowl, in which he returned a kickoff 75 yards and scored a three-yard rushing touchdown and again earned player of the game honors. Chicago finished in second place in the newly organized
Central Division with a 7–6–1 record.
1968–1969: Right knee injury and comeback season Sayers had the most productive rushing yardage game of his career on November 3, 1968, against the
Green Bay Packers, during which he carried 24 times for 205 yards. His season ended prematurely the following week against the 49ers'
Kermit Alexander, when he tore several
ligaments in his right knee including his
anterior cruciate ligament, his
medial collateral ligament, and his
meniscus cartilage.
Garry Lyle, the teammate nearest Sayers at the time, said, "I saw his eyes sort of glass over. I heard him holler. I knew he was hurt." Sayers had again been leading the league in rushing yards through the first nine games, and finished the year with 856 yards. After surgery, Sayers went through a physical rehabilitation program with the help of Piccolo, who had replaced him in the starting lineup. Despite missing the Bears' final five games, he earned first-team All-Pro recognition from several media outlets, including the AP, UPI, and NEA. In the 1969 season, after a slow start and despite diminished speed and acceleration, Sayers led the league in rushing once again with 1,032 yards. He averaged 4.4 yards per carry and was the only player to gain over 1,000 rushing yards that year. He moved into second place on the Bears' all-time rushing yards list, passing
Bronko Nagurski. Sayers was recognized as the NFL's
Comeback Player of the Year by
United Press International. The Bears, long past the Halas glory years, finished in last place with a franchise-worst 1–13 record. In his fourth and final Pro Bowl appearance, Sayers was the West's leading rusher and its leading receiver. For the third time in as many Pro Bowl performances, he was named the "Back of the Game".
1970–1971: Left knee injury and retirement In the
1970 preseason, Sayers suffered a second knee injury, this time bone bruises to his left knee. Attempting to play through the injury in the opening game against the
Giants, his production was severely limited. He sat out the next two games and returned in week 4 against the
Vikings, but he was still visibly hampered, most evidently when he was unable to chase down Vikings defensive lineman
Alan Page during a 65-yard fumble return. Sayers carried only six times for nine yards before further injuring his knee. He underwent surgery the following week and was deemed out for the remainder of the season. He had carried 23 times for 52 yards to that point. During his off time, Sayers took classes to become a
stockbroker and became the first black stockbroker in his company's history. He also entered a
Paine Webber program for 45 nationwide stockbroker trainees and placed second highest in sales. After another knee operation and rehabilitation period, Sayers attempted a comeback in
1971. He was kept out of the first three games after carrying the ball only twice in the preseason, as Bears head coach
Jim Dooley planned to slowly work him back into the rotation. His first game back was against the
New Orleans Saints on October 10, in which he carried eight times for 30 yards. After the game, he told reporters he was satisfied with his performance and that his knee felt fine. The following week, against the
49ers, he carried five times before injuring his ankle in the first quarter, an injury that ultimately caused him to miss the remainder of the season. He was encouraged to retire but decided to give football one last try. Sayers' final game was in the
1972 preseason in which he fumbled twice in three carries; he retired from professional football days later at age 29.
Career statistics ==Playing style==