Early career and tryouts Gargano made his professional wrestling debut for CAPW in 2005. In his first match, he competed in the AIW Gauntlet For The Gold Battle Royal on December 11, 2005, which was won by
Michael Hutter. The following day he wrestled in another dark match, this time losing to
Eric Young. Gargano has also wrestled in a dark match for
Ring of Honor, defeating
Sami Callihan on August 15, 2008. After his ROH tryout it was discovered that Gargano had a hairline fracture in his back, caused by his
left leg being shorter than his right leg, which led to his doctor advising him to rethink his career choice. On February 24, 2008, Gargano defeated his trainer Josh Prohibition to become the number one contender to the AIW Intense Division Championship. After Gargano's first shot at the title, held by
Tyler Black, went to a fifteen-minute time limit draw on March 21, the two were booked in a
30-minute Iron Man match on May 25, where Gargano defeated Black to win the Intense Division Championship for the first time. Gargano held the title for 187 days before he was stripped of it due to an injury on November 28, 2008. On February 28, 2009, Gargano defeated Jimmy DeMarco, who had won the vacant Intense Division Championship in a tournament, to regain the title. As a result of winning the tournament, Gargano and Aeroform earned the right to represent AIW in
Chikara's
2010 King of Trios tournament. Later that same night, Gargano retained his brand new title by wrestling
Bryan Danielson to a 30-minute time limit draw. On March 3, 2012, Gargano won a 30-man
Gauntlet for the Gold, last eliminating
Tim Donst, to earn a shot at Xion and the AIW Absolute Championship.
Chikara (2008, 2010–2013, 2016) 's
King of Trios tournament in April 2010|203x203px Gargano made his debut for
Philadelphia–based Chikara on June 14, 2008, taking part in the sixth
Young Lions Cup tournament, but was eliminated in the first round against Marshe Rockett. Gargano returned to the company on April 23, 2010, taking part in the 2010 King of Trios tournament with Aeroform and suffering a loss in the opening round against
The Colony (Fire Ant, Green Ant and Soldier Ant). On the second night of the tournament, Gargano came out during a quarter-final match between F.I.S.T. (
Icarus,
Gran Akuma and
Chuck Taylor) and Team
Osaka Pro (
Atsushi Kotoge,
Daisuke Harada and
Tadasuke), wearing a F.I.S.T. shirt and witnessed how Icarus, Akuma and Taylor were eliminated from the tournament. Gargano wrote on his
Facebook page that he liked F.I.S.T., but thought that the team might have a weak link, which led to the
stable's members pointing fingers at each other. On June 27 at
Faded Scars and Lines, Gargano defeated
Player Uno to earn a spot in the eighth Young Lions Cup tournament. On July 26 at
Chikarasaurus Rex: King of Show, F.I.S.T. lost a six-man tag team match to
Cima,
Masaaki Mochizuki and Super Shenglong. After the match, Icarus and Taylor turned on Akuma, kicked him out of both F.I.S.T. and Chikara and gave his spot to Gargano. On August 27, Gargano entered his second Young Lions Cup tournament, defeating Andy Ridge in the first round but was eliminated from the tournament when he was disqualified in the six-way elimination semi final match. On August 29, Gargano defeated 29 other men to win
The Countdown Showdown match and earn a "Golden Opportunity". With Gargano as a member, the new F.I.S.T. ended their losing streak by defeating Da Soul Touchaz (Acid Jaz, Marshe Rockett and Willie Richardson) and
3.0 (Scott Parker and Shane Matthews) and Soldier Ant in six-man tag team matches on September 18 and 19. On October 23, Gargano cashed in his "Golden Opportunity" for a Young Lions Cup title match against
Frightmare, but lost. On April 15, 2011, F.I.S.T. entered the
2011 King of Trios, defeating Team Australia (Kabel, Percy T and Tama Williams) in the first round. The following day, F.I.S.T. defeated Team Osaka Pro (Atsushi Kotoge, Daisuke Harada and Ultimate Spider Jr.) to advance to the semifinals. On April 17, F.I.S.T. scored a major upset in the semifinals of the tournament by defeating Team
Michinoku Pro (
Dick Togo,
Great Sasuke and
Jinsei Shinzaki) but lost in the finals of the tournament to The Colony. In June and July, Gargano and Taylor gained three points and the right to challenge for the
Chikara Campeonatos de Parejas with victories over The Colony, Incoherence (Frightmare and
Hallowicked) and
Atlantis and
Rey Bucanero. On September 18, Gargano and Taylor defeated
Jigsaw and
Mike Quackenbush to win the Chikara Campeonatos de Parejas for the first time. Gargano and Taylor made their first title defense on October 7, defeating Momo no Seishun Tag (Atsushi Kotoge and Daisuke Harada) with help from Icarus. On August 2, Chikara's
Director of Fun, Wink Vavasseur, named Sugar Dunkerton, who had stated his wish to join a stable, the fourth member of F.I.S.T. The other members, however, refused to accept Dunkerton as a full-fledged member, instead referring to him as their "water boy". On September 14, F.I.S.T., represented by Gargano, Icarus and Taylor, entered the
2012 King of Trios tournament, defeating Team Osaka Pro (Ebessan,
Kikutaro and Takoyakida) in the first round. The following day, F.I.S.T. defeated the all-female Team
JWP (
Command Bolshoi,
Kaori Yoneyama and
Tsubasa Kuragaki) to advance to the semifinals. On the third and final day of the tournament, F.I.S.T. was eliminated in the semifinals by the Spectral Envoy (Frightmare, Hallowicked and UltraMantis Black). In early 2013, the members of F.I.S.T. began having problems with each other, leading to Icarus turning on Gargano on May 3 over his treatment of Sugar Dunkerton. Following the turn, Gargano quit F.I.S.T., which was followed by Chikara removing his profile from the promotion's official roster page. He returned on September 2, 2016, entering the
2016 King of Trios tournament as part of Team #CWC, alongside
Cedric Alexander and
Drew Gulak. They were eliminated from the tournament in the first round by The Warriors Three (Oleg the Usurper,
Princess KimberLee and ThunderFrog).
Dragon Gate USA and Evolve (2009–2016) While wrestling for
Chicago-based All American Wrestling (AAW), Gargano ran into
Colt Cabana, who suggested he get in touch with former Ring of Honor
booker Gabe Sapolsky, who was looking for talents for
Dragon Gate USA and
Evolve Wrestling, and tell him that Cabana sent him. On November 28 at
Freedom Fight, Gargano made his pay-per-view debut by entering the tournament to crown the first
Open the Freedom Gate Champion, but was eliminated in the first round. In May, Gargano signed a contract with Dragon Gate USA. On September 26, Gargano offered himself to Cima's Warriors International stable. On October 29 at Dragon Gate USA's first live pay-per-view, Bushido: Code of the Warrior, Gargano wrestled in a four-way match won by Chuck Taylor. After Taylor turned down an offer from Cima to join his Warriors International stable, Gargano offered himself to Cima but was turned down. Gargano confronted Cima again, offering himself to Warriors International, before attacking him and
Ricochet, along with Chuck Taylor and
Rich Swann, forming the stable Ronin. On January 29, 2011, Gargano and Taylor entered a three-day-long tournament to determine the first ever
Open the United Gate Champions. Gargano and Taylor defeated
Naruki Doi and Ricochet and followed it up by defeating Cima and
Dragon Kid, before losing in the finals to
Masato Yoshino and
PAC. On April 1 at
Open the Southern Gate, Gargano lost to Cima, with Ronin now working as a
babyface group against Cima's Blood Warriors. The following day at Mercury Rising, Ronin lost a six-man tag team match to Cima, Doi and Ricochet. On April 3 at Open the Ultimate Gate,
Austin Aries, who lost a match with his Dragon Gate USA career on the line, feigned passing the torch to his former Ronin rivals, but turned on them and joined Blood Warriors. Gargano defeated
Jon Davis on April 19 at Evolve's first live internet pay-per-view. On June 3 at Fearless, Gargano lost to Aries, but came back two days later at
Enter The Dragon to force Cima and Aries to submit in a six-man elimination tag team match, where he teamed with Rich Swann and Masato Yoshino with
Brodie Lee being the third member of Blood Warriors. belt in January 2013 On November 13 at Freedom Fight, Gargano defeated
Yamato to win the Open the Freedom Gate Championship. On January 14, 2012, Gargano retained the title against Ricochet in the final professional wrestling match in the
Asylum Arena. Following the match, Gargano was helped backstage and rushed to a hospital with a back injury, but was released the following day. On March 30, Gargano returned to Dragon Gate USA, where he and Chuck Taylor unsuccessfully fought Masato Yoshino and Ricochet for the vacant Open the United Gate Championship; Taylor then turned on Gargano and broke away from Ronin. Following the merger of Dragon Gate USA and Evolve, Gargano successfully defended the Open the Freedom Gate Championship against Taylor on June 29 at Evolve 15. On July 28 at Untouchable, Gargano retained the title against
Akira Tozawa. Prior to the event it had been reported that Gargano had been offered a
developmental contract with WWE, however, following his win, Gargano revealed that he had signed a two-year contract extension with Dragon Gate USA/Evolve. The following day at Enter the Dragon, Gargano defeated Chuck Taylor in a non-title
"I Quit" match, ending their rivalry. Gargano made another successful defense of the Open the Freedom Gate Championship on September 8, defeating Jon Davis at Evolve 17. On November 4 at Freedom Fight, despite a pre-match assault by Jon Davis, Gargano defeated Tozawa,
A. R. Fox and Ricochet in a four-way elimination match to retain the Open the Freedom Gate Championship and, as a result, made it to a full year as the champion. On December 8 at Evolve 18, Gargano retained the title against
Sami Callihan. On April 6, 2013, Gargano retained the Open the Freedom Gate Championship against
Shingo after hitting him with a
low blow and a chain, turning
villainous in the process. Gargano's streak of successful title defenses continued against the likes of
Samuray del Sol, Akira Tozawa, and Rich Swann. Having now held the Open the Freedom Gate Championship for two years, Gargano retained the title on November 17 against
Chris Hero. Gargano's successful title defenses continued in early 2014, when he defeated Uhaa Nation,
Trent Baretta, and
Roderick Strong. On March 27, it was reported that Gargano had signed a contract extension with Dragon Gate USA. On April 4, Gargano lost the Open the Freedom Gate Championship to Ricochet in a match one year in the making, The rivalry between Gargano and Rich Swann culminated in an "Evolution's End" match on August 10, where Swann was victorious. Post-match, Gargano saved Swann from an attack by the Premier Athlete Brand of
Anthony Nese, Caleb Konley and Su Yung. On November 16, 2014, during Dragon Gate USA's parent company
WWNLive's tour of
China, Gargano defeated Ricochet to regain the Open the Freedom Gate Championship, becoming the first two-time holder of the title. On March 26, 2015, Gargano retained the Open the Freedom Gate Championship against A. R. Fox to set up a double title match with
Evolve World Champion Drew Galloway two days later, where Galloway defeated Gargano to retain the Evolve World Championship and win the Open the Freedom Gate Championship. Following the match,
Ethan Page turned on Gargano, On April 18, Gargano and Swann defeated Anthony Nese and Caleb Konley to win the Open the United Gate Championship. On May 30, Ronin successfully defended the title against Drew Gulak and
Tracy Williams. After the match, Gargano retired the Open the United Gate Championship since Dragon Gate was the past and demanded the creation of the
Evolve Tag Team Championship. Gargano's partnership with Swann ended on August 15, when Swann turned on Gargano and joined forces with Ethan Page. The feud between Gargano and Page culminated on October 17 at Evolve 49, where Gargano defeated Page in an "I Quit" match, where his Evolve career was on the line. On January 24, 2016, at Evolve 55, Gargano and Drew Galloway defeated Chris Hero and
Tommy End in the finals of a tournament to become the inaugural Evolve Tag Team Champions. They lost the title to Drew Gulak and Tracy Williams on April 2. After the match, Galloway turned on Gargano. The feud between Gargano and Galloway concluded on July 17 at Evolve 65, where Gargano lost to Galloway. On July 21, Evolve revealed Gargano's impending departure from the promotion with his final match taking place on September 11. On September 10 at Evolve 68, Gargano was defeated by
Zack Sabre Jr. in his final singles match in Evolve. The following day at Evolve 69, Gargano and
Cody Rhodes defeated Chris Hero and
Drew Galloway in Gargano's Evolve farewell match.
Dragon Gate (2011, 2012) On March 1, 2011, Gargano made his
Japanese debut, when his Dragon Gate USA stable Ronin started their first three-week-long tour of Dragon Gate. In their first match of the tour, Gargano, Chuck Taylor and Rich Swann defeated Blood Warriors representatives Cima, Naruki Doi and
Naoki Tanizaki in a six-man tag team match. Gargano returned to Dragon Gate in October 2012, now aligned with the World-1 International stable. In his first match of the tour on October 6, Gargano teamed with Masato Yoshino and Naruki Doi to defeat Kaettekita Veteran-gun representatives
Don Fujii,
Gamma and Masaaki Mochizuki in a six-man tag team main event. The following day, Gargano defeated
Ryo "Jimmy" Saito to retain the Open the Freedom Gate Championship.
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla (2013–2015) On March 22, 2013, Gargano made his debut for
Southern California-based
Pro Wrestling Guerrilla (PWG) during the promotion's All Star Weekend 9, teaming with Chuck Taylor in a non-title tag team match, where they were defeated by the reigning
PWG World Tag Team Champions, The Young Bucks. Gargano returned to PWG on June 15, when he and Taylor lost to the Dojo Bros. (
Eddie Edwards and Roderick Strong). On August 30, Gargano entered the
2013 Battle of Los Angeles, defeating
Willie Mack in the first round. The following day, Gargano defeated
Kevin Steen in the second round, before being eliminated from the tournament in the semifinals by
Michael Elgin. On October 20, Gargano defeated Roderick Strong and, at the end of the event, challenged
Adam Cole to a future match for the
PWG World Championship. Gargano received his title shot during the second day of
All Star Weekend X on December 21, but was defeated by Cole. Gargano failed to earn another title shot on January 31, 2014, when he was defeated by Drake Younger in a four-way number one contender's match, which also included Chris Hero and Kyle O'Reilly. In August, Gargano made it to the finals of the
2014 Battle of Los Angeles, before losing to Ricochet in a three-way match, also involving Roderick Strong. On December 11, 2015, Gargano and
Tommaso Ciampa unsuccessfully challenged The Young Bucks for the PWG World Tag Team Championship.
WWE (2015–present) Early appearances (2007–2011) On March 23, 2007, Gargano appeared as the "Champion of
Liechtenstein", Cedrick Von Haussen, on an episode of
World Wrestling Entertainment's television program
SmackDown!, losing to
Montel Vontavious Porter. He made another appearance for WWE on the May 25, 2010, edition of
NXT, portraying a security guard.
DIY (2015–2017) In June 2015, Gargano took part in a WWE tryout camp, and also wrestled at the June 18
NXT tapings, losing to
Uhaa Nation in a dark match. Though he did not sign with WWE, Gargano continued making appearances for NXT over the next few months. In Gargano's first televised NXT match he teamed with Tommaso Ciampa in the
Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic tournament, defeating the team of
Bull Dempsey and
Tyler Breeze in their first round match on the September 9 episode. They were eliminated from the tournament by
Baron Corbin and
Rhyno on the September 16 episode. Gargano continued working for NXT in early 2016. On April 2, it was confirmed that Gargano had signed with WWE earlier in the week. Gargano's NXT contract was a so-called "Tier 2" contract, which allowed him to continue working independent dates alongside his now regular NXT bookings. On June 23, Gargano entered the
Cruiserweight Classic tournament, defeating his tag team partner Tommaso Ciampa the first round. On July 14, Gargano was eliminated from the tournament by
T.J. Perkins. On July 21, it was reported that Gargano was signing a new full-time NXT deal, which would prevent him from taking further independent bookings. Gargano and Ciampa, now billed collectively as "
DIY" (often stylized as #DIY), challenged The Revival for another title shot in a
two-out-of-three falls match on November 19 at
NXT TakeOver: Toronto, where they went on to become the new NXT Tag Team Champions. DIY went on to successfully defend their championships against the teams of
Tajiri and
Akira Tozawa, and
TM61 (
Nick Miller and
Shane Thorne) in their respective home countries of Japan and Australia, and against The Revival in a rubber match on the January 11, 2017 episode of
NXT, ending their trilogy feud with the latter team, after which they would be attacked by The Authors of Pain. At
NXT TakeOver: San Antonio on January 28, 2017, they lost the titles to
The Authors of Pain causing their championship reign to end at just 70 days. which DIY lost after being the first team eliminated. On May 20 at
NXT TakeOver: Chicago, DIY once again faced The Authors of Pain in the first-ever
ladder match for the NXT Tag Team Championship, which they lost. After the match, Ciampa turned on Gargano to end the partnership between the two. Their feud continued when Gargano faced
Andrade "Cien" Almas at
NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn III, but he lost after Almas' valet,
Zelina Vega, threw a #DIY shirt at Gargano to distract him. On the December 6 episode of
NXT, Gargano defeated
Kassius Ohno to qualify for a number one contender's fatal four-way match for the
NXT Championship involving
Aleister Black,
Killian Dain and
Lars Sullivan, which Gargano won after pinning Black (becoming the first man to do so).
Feud with Tommaso Ciampa (2018–2019) in April 2018 at
NXT TakeOver: New Orleans in April 2018 At
NXT TakeOver: Philadelphia on January 27, 2018, Gargano challenged Andrade "Cien" Almas for the
NXT Championship, which he lost again, even after his wife,
Candice LeRae, helped fend off a distraction from Zelina Vega. Afterwards, Tommaso Ciampa returned to attack Gargano from behind with a crutch. Gargano faced Almas for the title again on the February 21 episode of
NXT, where Gargano failed to win the title after interference from Ciampa, thus forcing him to (kayfabe) leave NXT. At
NXT TakeOver: New Orleans on April 7, he defeated Ciampa in an
unsanctioned match to be reinstated to NXT. On the April 25 episode of
NXT, Gargano was once again attacked by Ciampa while he was making his entrance for his NXT Championship match against Aleister Black, leading to a
Chicago Street Fight between them at
NXT TakeOver: Chicago II on June 16, which Ciampa won. At the July 18
NXT tapings of the July 25 episode, Gargano interfered in Ciampa's NXT Championship match against Black and accidentally hit Black with the title belt, causing Ciampa to win the championship. The following week, all three men were scheduled in a triple threat match for the NXT Championship at
NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn IV on August 18, though Black was removed from the match due to being unable to compete after being found unconscious in the parking lot after the show. The title match was later changed to a Last Man Standing match between Gargano and Ciampa at the event, which Ciampa won. On the October 24 episode of
NXT, Gargano was revealed as the one who attacked Aleister Black, turning
heel in the process. Black and Gargano continued their rivalry, culminating in a match at
NXT TakeOver: WarGames II on November 17, which Black won. On the December 19 episode of
NXT, Gargano defeated Black in a steel cage match after interference from Ciampa, ending their feud. At
NXT TakeOver: Phoenix on January 26, 2019, Gargano defeated
Ricochet to capture the
NXT North American Championship. Later in the night, after Ciampa successfully defended his NXT Championship against Black, Gargano reunited with his former tag-team partner as they raised their belts in unison on stage as the show went off air. The following night, he would make his first main roster appearance at the
Royal Rumble event, entering at number 6 in the
Royal Rumble match, in which he lasted over 13 minutes and eliminated
Jinder Mahal before getting eliminated by
Dean Ambrose. On the February 20 episode of
NXT, Gargano lost the NXT North American Championship to
Velveteen Dream.
NXT Champion (2019–2020) Gargano made his main roster debut on the February 18, 2019, episode of
Raw, where he and Ciampa defeated former rivals
Raw Tag Team Champions The Revival in a non-title match. The next night on their
SmackDown debut, Gargano and Ciampa defeated
The Bar (
Cesaro and
Sheamus). On the March 13 episode of
NXT, after Gargano and Ciampa were eliminated from the Dusty Rhodes Classic, Ciampa attempted to attack Gargano, similar to his original betrayal at TakeOver: Chicago two years prior, before Gargano reversed it and attacked him, thus turning face. On the March 20 episode of
NXT, it was revealed by
Triple H that Gargano and Ciampa were to compete at
NXT TakeOver: New York for the NXT Championship, but due to Ciampa needing real-life neck surgery, he was removed from the match and forced to vacate the title; therefore, it was announced that Gargano would still be in the match for the now vacant title, and his opponent would be
Adam Cole, who won a
fatal five-way match later that night to earn the right to replace Ciampa. At the event on April 5, Gargano defeated Cole in a critically acclaimed
two-out-of-three falls match to win the NXT Championship for the first time in his career, which also made him the first ever
NXT Triple Crown Champion. At the end of the show, Ciampa came out to celebrate Gargano's successful title win with
Candice LeRae as well. A rematch was scheduled between Gargano and Cole to take place at
NXT TakeOver XXV on June 1, where Gargano lost the title, ending his reign at 57 days. Gargano's rematch on August 10 at
NXT TakeOver: Toronto was then scheduled by
William Regal to be another two-out-of-three falls match, with each wrestler allowed to pick a stipulation, with Regal deciding the final fall's stipulation. At the event, Gargano won the second fall, but was ultimately unsuccessful in regaining the title after losing the final fall, which was in a steel cage match, after both men fell from the top of the cage through a table. On the October 23 episode of
NXT, Gargano reunited with Ciampa once again, only to be attacked by The Undisputed Era and surprise NXT returnee
Finn Bálor. He suffered a legitimate neck injury when Bálor performed his signature move
1916 on Gargano on the entrance ramp, sidelining him indefinitely. He returned on the December 18 episode of
NXT, distracting Bálor during his NXT Championship match against Adam Cole, causing him to lose; he then attacked Bálor with a steel chair post-match.
The Way (2020–2021) On the January 8, 2020, episode of
NXT, Bálor challenged Gargano to a match at
NXT TakeOver: Portland, which Gargano accepted. At
Worlds Collide on January 25, Gargano and Ciampa defeated NXT UK's
Moustache Mountain. At TakeOver on February 16, Gargano lost to Bálor, and later that same night, Gargano interfered in the main-event between Cole and Ciampa for the NXT Championship and attacked Ciampa with the title while the referee was unconscious, subsequently allowing Cole to pin Ciampa, breaking up DIY for the second time and turning heel for the second time in his WWE career. On the April 8, 2020, episode of
NXT, Gargano defeated Ciampa in an Empty Arena No Holds Barred match after Candice LeRae gave Ciampa a lowblow and Gargano hit Ciampa with the Fairytale Ending. Gargano and LeRae then began appearing together more frequently as a power couple. At
TakeOver: In Your House on June 7, Gargano unsuccessfully challenged
Keith Lee for the
NXT North American Championship. On July 8 at
The Great American Bash, Gargano defeated
Isaiah "Swerve" Scott. On the July 22 episode of
NXT, Gargano faced Bronson Reed and Roderick Strong in a triple threat qualifying match for a spot in the North American Championship ladder match at
NXT TakeOver XXX, but lost. After
Dexter Lumis dropped out of the match due to an ankle injury, Gargano replaced him by defeating
Ridge Holland in a last chance match. At TakeOver XXX on August 22, Gargano failed to win the title. He challenged new champion
Damian Priest for the title at
NXT TakeOver 31 on October 4, which he failed to win. On October 28 at
Halloween Havoc, Gargano defeated Priest in a Devil's Playground match to become the first-ever two-time NXT North American Champion. He lost the title to
Leon Ruff on the November 11 episode of
NXT, ending his second reign at 14 days, but regained it on December 6 at
NXT TakeOver: WarGames in a triple threat match involving Priest to become the first-ever three-time North American Champion. On the December 9 episode of
NXT, he announced that he formed a villainous faction with LeRae,
Indi Hartwell and
Austin Theory called
The Way. On the December 30 episode of
NXT, Gargano retained his title against Ruff, finally breaking his championship "curse". Gargano's streak of successful title defenses followed, including against Kushida at
Vengeance Day on February 14, 2021, and
Bronson Reed on April 8 at the second night of
NXT TakeOver: Stand & Deliver. On the May 18 episode of
NXT, he lost the championship to Reed in a steel cage match, ending his third reign at 163 days. At
In Your House on June 13, Gargano failed to win the
NXT Championship in a fatal five-way match involving Adam Cole,
Karrion Kross,
Kyle O'Reilly, and
Pete Dunne. On the October 19 episode of
NXT, Gargano turned face when he confronted NXT North American Champion
Carmelo Hayes and
Trick Williams. On the November 23 episode of
NXT, Gargano faced Hayes and Pete Dunne in a triple threat match for the title, where Hayes retained due to interference from
Tony D'Angelo. After the match, Gargano, Dunne, Ciampa, and
LA Knight brawled with Hayes, D'Angelo,
Bron Breakker and
Grayson Waller, leading to a
WarGames match at
WarGames on December 5, where Team Black & Gold lost to Team 2.0. On the following episode of
NXT, Gargano cut a farewell promo where he thanked his fans, friends, and family before being brutally attacked by Grayson Waller.
DIY reunion (2022–2025) On the August 22, 2022, episode of
Raw, Gargano returned to WWE after nine months to give a speech, but was interrupted and mocked by his former The Way stablemate
Austin Theory, whom he superkicked afterwards. Two weeks later, on the September 12 episode of
Raw, he defeated
Chad Gable in his return match, but was attacked by Theory. On the October 3 episode of
Raw, Gargano suffered his first main roster loss to
Otis after Theory hit him with his Money in the Bank briefcase. He retaliated by defeating Theory on the following episode of
Raw, ending their feud. At
Royal Rumble on January 28, Gargano competed in his second rumble match where he lasted nearly 30 minutes before being eliminated by
Dominik Mysterio and
Finn Bálor. On the following episode of
Raw, Gargano defeated
Baron Corbin to qualify for the
Elimination Chamber for the
United States Championship. At
Elimination Chamber on February 18, Gargano failed to win the title in the Elimination Chamber match. Gargano would return to NXT after over a year on the March 7, 2023, special episode of
NXT: Roadblock after being introduced by Shawn Michaels as Grayson Waller's opponent for
NXT Stand & Deliver, in which Gargano won. After a five-month hiatus due to a shoulder injury, Gargano returned on the October 2 episode of
Raw saving Tommaso Ciampa from an attack from
Imperium, reforming
DIY in the process. On the January 29, 2024 episode of
Raw, DIY received a match for the
Undisputed WWE Tag Team Championship against
The Judgment Day's
Damian Priest and
Finn Bálor, but were defeated. On the March 18 episode of
Raw, DIY defeated the
Creed Brothers to qualify for the
Six Pack Ladder Match for the Tag Team Championship at
WrestleMania XL, which they were unsuccessful. On the April 15 episode of
Raw, DIY defeated The New Day and the Creed Brothers to face
Awesome Truth (
The Miz and
R-Truth) for the renamed
World Tag Team Championship. On the April 22 episode of
RAW, DIY was unsuccessful at winning the World Tag Team Championship from Awesome Truth. On night 2 of the
2024 WWE Draft, both Gargano and Ciampa were drafted to SmackDown. On the July 5 episode of
SmackDown, he and Ciampa became the new
WWE Tag Team Champions by defeating
A-Town Down Under (
Austin Theory and
Grayson Waller), having started a feud weeks prior to the title match. On the August 2 episode of
SmackDown, DIY lost the titles to
The Bloodline's
Jacob Fatu and
Tama Tonga after interference from
Solo Sikoa and
Tonga Loa, ending their reign at 28 days. Over the next few months, DIY vowed to win back the titles, but there were signs of dissension between Ciampa and Gargano as the former took on a more aggressive character. On the November 15 episode of
SmackDown, Ciampa interrupted a title match between The
Street Profits (
Angelo Dawkins and
Montez Ford) and defending champions
Motor City Machine Guns (
Alex Shelley and
Chris Sabin), attacking both teams, but Gargano restrained him. On the December 6 episode of
SmackDown, DIY defeated Motor City Machine Guns to win the titles for the second time after Gargano hit Sabin with a low blow, and later revealing the recent arguments to all be a ruse, turning Gargano
heel. At the
Royal Rumble on February 1, DIY successfully defended the titles against Motor City Machine Guns in a 2 out of 3 falls match with interference from The Street Profits who attacked them after the match. On the February 21 episode of Smackdown, DIY's tag title match against Pretty Deadly ended in disqualification after The Street Profits got involved. On the March 14 episode of
SmackDown, #DIY lost the titles to the Street Profits, ending their second reign at 98 days. On the April 25 episode of
SmackDown, they would attempt to regain the titles against the Street Profits in a critically acclaimed
tables, ladders, and chairs match also involving the Motor City Machine Guns, where the Street Profits retained.
Singles competition (2026–present) On January 21, 2026, Ciampa announced he would not be renewing his contract when it expires, thus disbanding #DIY and leaving Gargano as a singles wrestler. After Ciampa's departure, Gargano began a gimmick of being depressed and was often seen lying face down in various areas backstage. Gargano returned to the NXT brand on the March 24 episode of
NXT, winning a
Gauntlet Eliminator match to earn an
NXT North American Championship opportunity against
Myles Borne at
Stand & Deliver, incidentally after
Candice LeRae pushed Gargano to lie on
Shiloh Hill and pin him for the victory. ==Personal life==