or
anti-war movie:
Lewis Milestone's
All Quiet on the Western Front, 1930|336x336px Because genres are easier to recognize than to define, academics agree they cannot be identified in a rigid way. Furthermore, different countries and cultures define genres in different ways. A typical example are war movies. In
United States, they are mostly related to ones with large U.S. involvement such as World wars and Vietnam, whereas in other countries, movies related to wars in other historical periods are considered
war movies. Film genres may appear to be readily categorizable from the setting of the film. Nevertheless, films with the same settings can be very different, due to the use of different themes or moods. For example, while both
The Battle of Midway and
All Quiet on the Western Front are set in a
wartime context and might be classified as belonging to the
war film genre, the first examines the themes of honor, sacrifice, and valour, and the second is an
anti-war film which emphasizes the pain and horror of war. While there is an argument that
film noir movies could be deemed to be set in an urban setting, in cheap hotels and underworld bars, many classic noirs take place mainly in small towns, suburbia, rural areas, or on the open road. The editors of filmsite.org argue that animation,
pornographic film,
documentary film,
silent film and so on are non-genre-based film categories.
Linda Williams argues that horror, melodrama, and pornography all fall into the category of "body genres" since they are each designed to elicit physical reactions on the part of viewers. Horror is designed to elicit spine-chilling, white-knuckled, eye-bulging terror; melodramas are designed to make viewers cry after seeing the misfortunes of the onscreen characters; and pornography is designed to elicit sexual arousal. This approach can be extended: comedies make people laugh, tear-jerkers make people cry, feel-good films lift people's spirits and inspiration films provide hope for viewers.
Eric R. Williams (no relation to Linda Williams) argues that all narrative feature-length films can be categorized as one of eleven "super genres" (
action,
crime,
fantasy,
horror,
romance,
science fiction,
slice of life,
sports,
thriller,
war and
Western). For example, according to Williams, a film like
Blazing Saddles could be categorized as a
comedy (type)
Western (super-genre)
musical (voice), while
Anomalisa is a
drama (type) Slice of Life (super-genre)
animation (voice). Williams has created a seven-tiered categorization for narrative feature films called the
Screenwriters Taxonomy. ==Film in the context of history==