As of 2023, many celebrities, organizations, and former contestants have publicly spoken out against the show such as
Beth Ditto,
Eva Padberg,
Julia Stegner,
Carolin Kebekus,
Cordula Stratmann,
Désirée Nick,
Wolfgang Joop,
Roger Willemsen,
Sara Nuru,
Simone Kowalski,
Femen and even the German
Federal Ministry of Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth. Since
Cycle 5, the show's ratings have decreased. To improve ratings, showrunners shifted their focus to inciting conflict between contestants. The show has faced criticism from within the modeling industry for its minimal relevance and focus on shock value. In 2009, German model
Julia Stegner said that ''Germany's Next Topmodel'' has "little to do with the reality of
modeling." In 2012, former judge Rolf Scheider criticized the program, saying "the show has never produced a new
Nadja Auermann or
Claudia Schiffer" and that contestants who "lack modeling talent" are selected purely for ratings. In April 2022, the head of MGM Models, Marco Sinervo, expressed that the format has nothing to do with models or fashion, but with the abuse of contestants. Former judge
Wolfgang Joop criticized the show, stating he left because of the program's focus on scenes like "contestants collapsing, getting homesick, crying and falling on their heels." In 2019,
Cycle 4 contestant Tessa Bergmeier criticized the show and production team, stating they "often put words and phrases in the contestants' mouths that they would never have said." Former contestant Jana Heinisch said that disputes are deliberately provoked by the production. A physical fight in
Cycle 14 between contestants Jasmin Cadete and Lena Lischewski led to Cadete's disqualification. Lischewski's lawyer sued ProSieben and the cameramen, calling it "unacceptable that a television station films a minor beaten by another participant and the present camera crew does not intervene." After Vanessa Stanat quit Cycle 14, ProSieben took over her official
Instagram account and her personal account shortly after, possibly due to anger from her quitting weeks before the finale. In 2020,
Cycle 14 winner
Simone Kowalski said that "it is not right that it is perceived as entertainment, how young people put each other down." In March 2020,
Cycle 13 contestant Abigail Odoom revealed that she had a car accident during a challenge that involved a high speed car. She claimed that not only was she not allowed to talk about the car accident, but also that she was not taken care of in a timely and appropriate manner. In May 2022, Chiara "Kiki" Hölzl from
Cycle 10 also revealed that she broke her arm during a photo shoot that the production team buried. Contestant Lijana Kaggwa received death threats after participating in
Cycle 15 of ''Germany's Next Topmodel'', leading her to seek police protection. Mareike Fangmann from
Stern wrote that "[ProSieben] also has complicity because the broadcaster knows exactly how to cut scenes together in order to identify a clear bitch. Good for the ratings, good for the show." In December 2020, Kaggwa also stated, "The broadcast of GNTM 2020 completely ruined me mentally. I've become a different person." Cycle 9 contestant Nathalie Volk agreed with Kaggwa, saying "I have scars on my body because of Heidi." In February 2021,
Cycle 16 contestants had to walk nude in front of Heidi Klum, which was criticized by the audience and
Ministry of Family Affairs, Senior Citizens, Women and Youth. They also did a photoshoot from 122 meters in the air, leading to contestant Linda Braunberger's panic attack and subsequent elimination. Six contestants quit this cycle, most of them citing the decline of their mental health. In September 2022, the winner of the Cycle 4,
Sara Nuru, joined the criticism of the show, confessing she was "not aware of how blatantly young women were treated there." She added: "With the knowledge I have today, I would not take part in ''Germany's Next Topmodel
again." The former contestant Tamara Hitz of Cycle 15 revealed that the contestants always had an inkling of who would soon be eliminated because leading up to the elimination, that contestant would be filmed more frequently, proving the fake scripted background of the show and the cruel treatment of the entire production with the contestants. In August 2022 Marie Nasemann (contestant from Cycle 4) revealed that she has scoliosis. Back in 2009, during Cycle 4, her scoliosis was discussed at a casting for Samsung. The editors of GNTM'' tried to make her cry because of her illness and she also reveals: "I found out years later that Samsung would have liked to book me, but from the production side it wasn't allowed". The show has also faced criticism for the danger it poses to its young impressionable female audience. In May 2015, psychiatrist Manfred Lütz said the program promotes
anorexia.
GNTM is subject to regular checks by the German
Commission for Youth Media Protection.
Süddeutsche Zeitung argued it does not matter who wins the show, because it is only about promotion, the showmanship of Heidi Klum, and promoting a deadly body image. German influencer Kayla Shyx saw three effects of the show: "Suicidal thoughts, anxiety, and depression." According to a study by the "International Central Institute for Youth and Educational Television" a third of all girls surveyed with eating disorders named
GNTM as a trigger for it. German comedian
Carolin Kebekus said "''Germany's Next Topmodel'' made many greats: eating disorders, self-loathing, cyberbullying" and "this year they went crazy for diversity because every woman has the right to be humiliated by Heidi Klum." In May 2013, during the live finale of Cycle 8, Klum was attacked by two topless
Femen activists,
Zana Ramadani and Hellen Langhorst, who flashed her. This was the first time a winner of the show sued her way out of a prize contract. Ailabouni was not invited to
Cycle 6's live finale, while several
ProSieben-related magazines referred to
Cycle 4 winner
Sara Nuru as "last year's winner", given she was working as a backstage host. Since then, a number of other contestants have withdrawn from their contracts with ONEeins, including Viktoria Lantratova Luise Will (Cycle 8) and Aminata Sanogo (Cycle 9). In May 2017 the German radio and television broadcaster
Philipp Walulis criticized the show and its practices within his
YouTube show "
Walulis". His main criticism is that the contestants get gagging contracts and that the show is only concerned about advertising campaigns instead of the contestants, with some former contestants providing testimony. In December 2020,
Cycle 14 winner
Simone Kowalski met Günther in court, reaching a verdict that her contract with Günther Klum will be terminated and Kowalski will receive her full salary. In February 2023
Der Spiegel covered the notorious gag contracts that contestants sign to compete. According to Jörg Nabert, these are "illegal gag contracts" that bind models to the agency for two years, which is not customary in the modeling industry. Heidi Klum herself is criticized for her treatment of the contestants and her self-centeredness. Puls24 considered her behavior
gaslighting. German comedian
Cordula Stratmann referred to Klum as "the face and soul of a cold-hearted, disgusting production" and "the trainer in malice and condescension." Charlotte Koep via
T-Online referred to the program and Klum as "the ego show of the GNTM deadbeat mom". In August 2022, media personality
Désirée Nick interviewed Nathalie Volk on her podcast. Volk stated "What could be easier than to play your power over little girls who trust you? That is morally very questionable, like everything Heidi Klum has ever done".
Cycle 4 contestant Tessa Bergmeier described Klum as a "super-mega psycho".
Papis Loveday, who also worked on GNTM, added about Klum: "She only thinks of herself. Nobody can shine more than she does." In February 2023, the former judge Peyman Armin criticized the show and Klum, saying "It has become a pure self-portrayal by Heidi. Heidi comes first. Then Heidi and Heidi again. When Heidi Klum is in the foreground and takes care of the slapstick, for sensational shootings and catfights." In April 2023, Heidi Klum said about everything that happens at
GNTM: "At the end of the day I'm the boss and I make the rules!" In June 2023, the German TV broadcaster
ZDF released a 70-minute investigative documentary about the machinations of the makers of
GNTM called "Pressure, hatred, manipulation: how sick does ''Germany's Next Topmodel'' make you?" For this documentary, around 50 former contestants, judges and members of the show's crew were interviewed, some anonymously. The makers of the documentary admitted that they are familiar with difficult investigations, but they have never experienced it before that so many people were afraid to talk about what happened as these former participants and employees of
GNTM. A crew member of the show who wished to remain anonymous is quoted as saying: "If you film a young woman from morning to night, you'll get every sectional image you want. So you can cut and tell what you want. A lot of things are cut together wildly. The jobs depend on it. It's about ratings." In addition, former contestants report how the show's editors deliberately foment manipulation, lies and discord among the contestants behind the scenes. The contestants are shielded from the outside world so they lose their nerve and argue. So 20 candidates have to sleep together in one room without contact to the outside world. The statements by
Heidi Klum, the broadcasting TV station
ProSieben and the production company are presented as hypocrisy. ProSieben is said to have earned 87 million euros with the
Cycle 18, and Heidi Klum 10 million euros. The contestants receive no money.
GNTM has driven some contestants into depression and suicidal thoughts. ==References==