"It must be admitted that few men in this country have been a candidate for high office so many times and polled so few votes." Birney, but not Smith, is recorded in the commemorative painting of the event. In 1848, Smith was nominated for the
Presidency by the remnant of this organization that had not been absorbed by the
Free Soil Party. An "Industrial Congress" at
Philadelphia also nominated him for the presidency in 1848, and the "Land Reformers" in 1856. In
1840 and again in
1858, he ran for
Governor of New York on an anti-slavery platform. a plank in the
Liberty Party platform on June 14–15, 1848. On June 2, 1848, in
Rochester, New York, Smith was nominated as the
Liberty Party's presidential candidate. At the
1848 Liberty National Convention, held June 14–15 in
Buffalo, New York, Smith gave a major address, including in his speech a demand for "universal suffrage in its broadest sense, females as well as males being entitled to vote." At the request of friends, Smith had 3,000 copies printed of an 1851 speech in Troy in which he set forth his views of government. Smith laments the people's universal dependence on government. As a consequence of that dependence, government occupies itself "for the most part, in doing that it belongs to the people to do". He opposed tariffs, internal improvements, such as the
Erie Canal, at public expense, and publicly-supported schools, which could not teach religion, which Smith thought the main function of schools. The remedy was less government, and the less, the better. The only political office to which Smith was ever elected, and that by a very large majority, Smith was nominated as the presidential candidate of the new party in
1856. The Radical Abolitionists ran electors in New York and Ohio, where Smith polled 321 votes, finishing far behind the Republican candidate
John C. Fremont and the successful Democratic nominee,
James Buchanan. Smith was again the presidential candidate of the Radical Abolitionists in
1860. A convention of one hundred delegates was held in Convention Hall, Syracuse, New York, on August 29, 1860. Delegates were in attendance from New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Michigan, Illinois, Ohio, Kentucky, and Massachusetts. Several of the delegates were women. Smith, despite his poor health, fought
William Goodell in regard to the nomination for the presidency. In the end, Smith was nominated for president and
Samuel McFarland from Pennsylvania was nominated for vice president. Radical Abolitionist electors polled 176 votes in Illinois, Indiana, and Ohio. Smith, along with his friend and ally
Lysander Spooner, was a leading advocate of the
United States Constitution as an antislavery document, as opposed to abolitionist
William Lloyd Garrison, who believed it was to be condemned as a pro-slavery document, and was in favor of
secession by the North. In 1852, Smith was elected to the
United States House of Representatives as a
Free-Soiler. In his address, he declared that all men have an equal right to the soil; that wars are brutal and unnecessary; that slavery could be sanctioned by no constitution, state or federal; that free trade is essential to human brotherhood; that women should have full political rights; that the Federal government and the states should prohibit the liquor traffic within their respective jurisdictions; and that government officers, so far as practicable, should be elected by direct vote of the people.
Horace Greeley attributed to Smith the view that the state "has no other legitimate business than to keep one man's fingers off another man's throat and out of any pocket but his own." Unhappy with his separation from his home and business, Smith resigned his seat at the end of the first session, ostensibly to allow voters sufficient time to select his successor. In 1869, Smith served as a delegate to the founding convention of the
Prohibition Party. During the
1872 presidential election Smith was considered for the Prohibition Party's presidential nomination. ==Support for Black people==