Critical response , who played
Lorelai Gilmore, received critical acclaim for her performance.
Gilmore Girls premiered to critical acclaim. Upon debut,
Gilmore Girls was lauded for the distinct, dialogue-infused style created by Amy Sherman-Palladino, the strength of the dynamic familial themes, and the performances of its cast, particularly leading star Lauren Graham. On
Metacritic, the first season has an average rating of 81 out of 100 from 26 reviews, indicating "universal praise". In the
San Francisco Chronicle, John Carman wrote "It's cross-generational, warm-the-cockles viewing, and it's a terrific show. Can this really be the WB, niche broadcaster to horny mall rats?"
Caryn James of
The New York Times called it a "witty, charming show" that "is redefining family in a realistic, entertaining way for today's audience, all the while avoiding the sappiness that makes sophisticated viewers run from anything labeled a 'family show.
Ray Richmond of
The Hollywood Reporter declared it "a genuine gem in the making, a family-friendly hour unburdened by trite cliche or precocious pablum," while Jonathan Storm of
The Philadelphia Inquirer dubbed it "a touching, funny, lively show that really does appeal to all ages".
David Zurawik of
The Baltimore Sun called
Gilmore Girls "One of the most pleasant surprises of the new season". Emily Yahr of
The Washington Post retrospectively called the second installment "Pretty much a perfect season of television". Viewers were concerned that the show would suffer when Rory left for college after season 3, and Yahr commented that the show was not "the same" from this point but gave seasons four and five a positive 7/10. The introduction of Luke's daughter has been described as "pretty much the most hated plot device in
Gilmore Girls history". portrayed
Emily Gilmore.
Gilmore Girls was listed as one of
Time magazine's "All-Time 100 TV Shows". and was ranked the 87th greatest American television series in
TV (The Book), authored by critics
Alan Sepinwall and
Matt Zoller Seitz in 2016.
Entertainment Weekly placed
Gilmore Girls 32nd on its "New TV Classics" list, and included the show on its end-of-the-2000s "best-of" list, and
The A.V. Club named "They Shoot Gilmores, Don't They?" as one of the best TV episodes of the decade. Alan Sepinwall included the show in his "Best of the 00s in Comedies" list, saying: "
Gilmore offered up an unconventional but enormously appealing family ... As the quippy, pop culture-quoting younger Gilmores were forced to reconnect with their repressed elders, creator Amy Sherman-Palladino got plenty of laughs and tears out of the generational divide, and out of showing the family Lorelai created for herself and her daughter in the idealized,
Norman Rockwell-esque town of Stars Hollow. At its best,
Gilmore Girls was pure, concentrated happiness." In 2016, Amy Plitt of
Rolling Stone reflected on the enduring appeal of
Gilmore Girls, and noted that it stood out from other family shows like
7th Heaven,
The O.C. and
Everwood by being "far richer, deeper ... The characters were funny and relatable, the banter was zinger-heavy, the familial drama was poignant and the romantic chemistry ... was off the charts." For its first season the show aired in the tough Thursday 8pm/7pm
Central time slot dominated by
Friends on
NBC and
Survivor on
CBS. During season 2, ratings for
Gilmore Girls surpassed
Buffy and it became The WB's third-highest-rated show, with viewer numbers that grew by double digits in all major
demographics. but with Season 5 it became The WB's second-most-watched prime time show. According to data from
Nielsen,
Gilmore Girls was one of the top ten most watched television programs on all platforms in 2021, 2022, and 2023.
Awards and nominations Gilmore Girls earned several accolades, but did not receive much attention from the major awarding bodies. Its only
Emmy nomination was for
Outstanding Makeup for a Series, for the episode "The Festival of Living Art", which it won at the
56th Primetime Emmy Awards in 2004. Michael Ausiello has attributed this to "a notorious bias against the WB". Recognition did come from the
American Film Institute, who named
Gilmore Girls one of the ten best shows at the
American Film Institute Awards of 2002, and the
Television Critics Association (TCA) who named it
Outstanding New Program of the Year at the
17th TCA Awards in 2001. The
TCA Awards also nominated the show for
Outstanding Drama in 2001 and at the
18th TCA Awards in 2002, and
Outstanding Comedy at the
21st TCA Awards in 2005. The
Satellite Awards nominated it for
Best Series – Musical or Comedy at the
7th Golden Satellite Awards in 2002 and the
9th Golden Satellite Awards in 2004, while it was nominated for Favorite Television Drama at the
31st People's Choice Awards in 2005. The series also achieved considerable attention from the
Teen Choice Awards, where it received multiple nominations and wins including the award for
Choice Comedy Series at the
2005 Teen Choice Awards. and she won the Teen Choice Award for Parental Unit three times. Alexis Bledel won a
Young Artist Award for Best Performance in a TV Drama Series: Leading Young Actress at the
22nd Young Artist Awards, two
Teen Choice Awards for Choice TV Actress Comedy, and a Family Television Award. She was also nominated by the Satellite Awards in 2002. Kelly Bishop was twice nominated for the
Satellite Award for Best Supporting Actress – Television Series in 2002 and 2004. During the run of the show this was mostly a small but dedicated group, predominantly of females, but its audience has grown steadily since it came off the air. The series experienced a resurgence when it became available on Netflix in October 2014, introducing it to a new generation of viewers. When the revival was announced in 2015, star Lauren Graham credited it to the campaigning and persistence of the fans. At this point, according to
The Washington Post, the show became "a quirky pop culture obsession". The enduring popularity of
Gilmore Girls is considered to come from its comforting quality and cross-generational appeal. For the 16th anniversary of the show, 200 coffee houses around the US and Canada were transformed into "Luke's Diners". For two weeks in winter 2018–19, Warner Bros. added a special feature to their studio tour that recreated the Stars Hollow set and displayed props and costumes from the series. The show has an active fandom, posting in
internet forums and creating work such as
fan fiction. Special
Gilmore Girls trivia nights have been held at venues in multiple different cities. Actor from the show, Scott Patterson, who played Luke started his coffee brand which features blends themed after the show. His brand, ''Scotty P's Big Mug Coffee,
sells blends themed after places in the show, such as Luke's'' blend, named after Patterson's character's diner. The
Irish Independent has commented that "Even though it preceded social media,
Gilmore Girls has been internet gold for the past few years. Thanks to its snappy one-liners, it's spawned thousands of
memes that have introduced the
BuzzFeed generation to its coffee-swilling, cheeseburger-loving, critically thinking characters." and
Family Guy, and featured in an episode of
Six Feet Under. A cocktail bar in
Brooklyn devised a menu inspired by the show. Warner Bros. has produced a range of
Gilmore Girls merchandise, including T-shirts, mugs, and dolls. Three collections of academic essays that analyze the show have been published:
Gilmore Girls and the Politics of Identity (2008);
Screwball Television: Critical Perspectives on Gilmore Girls (2010); and
Gilmore Girls: A Cultural History (2019). In 2002, four
young adult novels were published that adapted scripts from the first and second seasons into novel form, told from Rory's
first-person point of view. There have also been several unofficial, fan-based guides to the series, including ''Coffee At Luke's: An Unauthorized Gilmore Girls Gab Fest
(2007), The Gilmore Girls Companion
(2010), You've Been Gilmored!: The Unofficial Encyclopedia and Complete Guide to Gilmore Girls
(2020), and But I'm a Gilmore!: Stories and Experiences of Honorary Gilmore Girls: Cast, Crew, and Fans
. The program is also the source of a book club, in which followers aim to read all 339 books referenced on the show, and the inspiration for a cookbook called Eat Like a Gilmore
. It follows the hosts, Kevin T. Porter and Demi Adejuyigbe, as they watch every episode of the series. Sadaf Ahsan of the National Post commented that it "helped reignite – and, for some, initiate – fan fervour" towards Gilmore Girls''. More example of how annual streaming has become a part of the new fandom, with articles highlighting how during autumn there's an increase in views of Gilmore Girls and related content online through posts and meme posted on social media platforms related to the show. Based on several years of streaming data, the show has gotten a significant boost in viewership every autumn since 2021, when Nielsen began issuing weekly top 10 lists of original and acquired streaming shows in the United States. ==Notes==