According to the second version, Muhammad gathered his relatives for a meal. Then he invited them to Islam, as reported by the Sunni historian
al-Tabari () in his on the authority of Ali, via Ibn Abbas. In this tradition, Abu Lahab foiled Muhammad's first attempt by dispersing the crowd. On the second attempt, Muhammad announced, Possibly the youngest there at the age of about fourteen, Ali was the only relative who offered his assistance to Muhammad, according to al-Tabari. In response, Muhammad brought him close and declared, Muhammad's announcement was nonetheless met with ridicule from Abu Lahab and the guests dispersed, al-Tabari concludes. The account of the Shia-leaning
Ibn Ishaq () is similar to that of al-Tabari. The Sunni historian
Ibn Hisham (), however, omitted this tradition from his recension of Ibn Ishaq's , possibly because of its Shia implications. Muhammad's response to Ali in this particular tradition is also not included in , a Sunni collection of hadiths. In contrast, the response above appears in Shia exegeses under the verse of the , including those by
al-Qumi () and
al-Tabarsi (). Among Sunnis, traditions similar to that of al-Tabari are also reported by
Abu al-Fida () in his and by
Ibn Kathir () in his universal history .
Miracle , located in
Medina, present-day
Saudi Arabia Some traditions attribute a miraculous aspect to this event. For instance, the Sunni historian
Ibn Sa'd () narrates that Muhammad fed his guests with a single plate of food, which Abu Lahab dismissed as a sorcery. In this tradition, however, Muhammad rejects Ali's offer to help because of his youth. This negative response to Ali is similar to that in a separate tradition in .
Views Rubin writes that Ali's response to the invitation of Muhammad contrasts the response of his tribe, the
Quraysh. He and
Moojan Momen, another expert, suggest that the early appointment of Ali as Muhammad's heir in this version supports his right to
succeed Muhammad, a central tenet of Shia Islam. Indeed, it is in this vein that the Shia exegete
Muhammad H. Tabatabai () invokes this tradition. Rubin also notes that the association of this tradition with the verse of the lends it divine authorization. At any rate, the linguist
Richard F. Burton () comments that this banquet "won for [Muhammad] a proselyte worth a thousand sabers in the person of Ali, son of
Abu Talib." ==See also==