Hail to the Thief has a score of 85 out of 100 on review aggregate site
Metacritic, indicating "universal acclaim".
Neil McCormick, writing for
The Daily Telegraph, called it "Radiohead firing on all cylinders, a major work by major artists at the height of their powers". Chris Ott of
Pitchfork wrote that Radiohead had "largely succeeded in their efforts to shape pop music into as boundless and possible a medium as it should be" and named it the week's "Best New Music". Andy Kellman of
AllMusic wrote that "despite the fact that it seems more like a bunch of songs on a disc rather than a singular body, its impact is substantial", concluding that Radiohead had "entered a second decade of record-making with a surplus of momentum". In
Mojo,
Peter Paphides wrote that
Hail to the Thief "coheres as well as anything else in their canon". The
Q writer
John Harris felt that it "comes dangerously close to being all experimentalism and precious little substance".
Robert Christgau of
The Village Voice wrote that while the album's melodies and guitar work are "never as elegiac and lyrical" or "articulate and demented" as those of Radiohead's 1997 album
OK Computer, it flowed better. He later awarded it an "honourable mention".
Hail to the Thief was the fifth consecutive Radiohead album nominated for a
Grammy Award for Best Alternative Music Album, and earned Godrich and the engineer Darrell Thorp the 2004
Grammy Award for Best Engineered Non-Classical Album.
Legacy In 2010,
Rolling Stone ranked
Hail to the Thief the 89th-best album of the 2000s, writing that "the dazzling overabundance of ideas makes
Hail to the Thief a triumph". In 2025,
GQ named
Hail to the Thief the eighth-best Radiohead album, saying it was "stranded between their band's avant-garde run of
OK Computer,
Kid A and
Amnesiac, and the late-career brilliance that started with
In Rainbows ... The uncharitable caricature that's sometimes fixed to their music – Thom Yorke warbling vaguely political sentiments over fiddly drum patterns and melodies – probably was born here, given the lyrical focus on the war on terror."
Rolling Stone said
Hail to the Thief was one of Radiohead's most divisive albums, which was "part of the fun". In 2008, Yorke posted an alternative track listing on Radiohead's website, omitting "Backdrifts", "We Suck Young Blood", "I Will" and "A Punchup at a Wedding". Jonny agreed that it was too long, and said: "We were trying to do what people said we were good at ... But it was good for our heads. It was good for us to be doing a record that came out of playing live." In 2023, approaching its 20th anniversary, Selway described
Hail to the Thief as a bridge between
Kid A,
Amnesiac and Radiohead's subsequent album,
In Rainbows. In 2025, the
Pitchfork critic Molly Mary O'Brien wrote that "as a timepiece, its foreboding sense of unease is quite suited for the present", citing the improved public image of George W. Bush, the presidency of
Donald Trump and that year's
US strikes on Iranian nuclear sites. ==
Hamlet Hail to the Thief ==