Up until the twelfth century, Jews and Christians in Latin
Christendom lived in relative peace with one another thanks to Augustine's theological justification. The situation started changing with the begin of the First Crusade, when the call for the European kingdoms to unite under the cross raised anew the question of the status of the Jews, combined with popular resentment of the practice of moneylending by Jews and religious fervour stoked by stories of illtreatment of Christians in the Holy Land by Muslims and Jews. In response to the persecutions, the papacy started reissuing pope Gregory's letter Sicut Judaeis as protection. "Officially, the medieval Catholic church never advocated the expulsion of all the Jews from Christendom, or repudiated Augustine's doctrine of Jewish witness... Still, late medieval Christendom frequently ignored its mandates..."
The Crusades during the First Crusade, by the 19th-century painter
Auguste Migette The trials the Jews periodically endured in the various Christian West kingdoms echoed the catastrophes that occurred during
Crusades. In the
First Crusade (1096) flourishing communities on the Rhine and the Danube were
utterly destroyed. Furthermore, there were also attacks on the Jews that lived in cities along the Rhine. Prior to these attacks, many Jews were seen as integral members of society despite religious differences. Many Jews worked in the money lending trade. Their services allowed for societies to function financially. In one case Jewish moneylenders were responsible for financially maintaining a monastery. Without these loans the monastery would have been unable to survive. However, this fiscal responsibility that the Jews carried might have caused tensions amongst the middle and upper class. These sects of society would not have approved of the power that the Jewish communities held. At this point there were no strictly Jewish communities. Jews were not concentrated in one area, rather their presence was spread over a larger geographical region. Oftentimes a few families lived immersed in a predominantly Christian settlement. The Jewish families were comfortable in this setting and functioned successfully. In some circumstances, Christians both accepted and welcomed the Jews. When violence against the Jewish people began to occur some Christians attempted to protect their fellow neighbors. In the town of Cologne, Jews fled to the homes of their Christian neighbors where they were given shelter. Although the archbishop at first accepted the bribe, community leaders persuaded him to protect the Jews' money instead of taking it, while still offering them refuge in his quarters. In another instance, the bishop of Trier offered to keep Jews safe from Crusaders in his palace; however, local intimidation eventually forced him to abandon those whom he had previously aided. Because the bishop had no ancestry or allies in Trier, he felt that he could not muster the political power needed to carry out a successful resistance without the support of the townspeople. Instead, he offered the Jews an ultimatum: convert to Christianity or leave the palace. When doing so, he remarked, “You cannot be saved—Your God does not wish to save you now as he did in earlier days.” In Cologne, Jews were protected by local gentiles after violence had broken out at the beginning of Shavuot, a Jewish holiday. During the two days of Shavuot, one Jewish woman was killed by Crusaders while venturing to the safety of a Christian neighbor's home, where her husband was waiting for her. However, the vast majority of Jews in Cologne survived Shavuot because local Christians had reached out and offered their homes as a means of asylum from the Crusaders.
Sicut Judaeis Sicut Judaeis (the "Constitution for the Jews") was the official position of the papacy regarding Jews throughout the Middle Ages and later. The first
bull was issued in about 1120 by
Calixtus II, intended to protect Jews who were suffering during the
First Crusade, and was reaffirmed by many popes, even until the 15th century. The bull forbade, besides other things, Christians from forcing Jews to convert, or to harm them, or to take their property, or to disturb the celebration of their festivals, or to interfere with their cemeteries, on pain of excommunication. Although the Jews and Christians of Rome were organized into distinct communities, the boundaries of which were not only reinforced on a daily basis but were regularly performed on ceremonial occasions such as the papal
adventus, Jews and Christians experienced unusually robust cultural and social interactions, especially as the Jews increasingly aligned themselves with the protective power of the papacy. With the increase of the prestige of the papacy and of its power in the twelfth and thirteenth century, the popes also sought to regulate more Jewish-Christian interactions. Pope Innocent III, who was particularly concerned with protecting Christian society from both external enemies such as the Muslims and internal enemies such as heretics, viewed the Jews as not very trustworthy. The
Fourth Lateran Council, convened by him in 1215, exceeded previous church councils in its regulations on Jews. Similar to existing Muslim regulation, it decreed that
Jews be differentiated from others by their type of clothing or marking to avoid intercourse between Jews and Christians. Innocent nevertheless held the Augustinian position that Jews should be protected and thus stipulated that the distintinctive clothing should not result in harm for them. However, the rule likely resulted in discrimination of all kind. Jews were sometimes required to wear a
yellow badge or a
pointed hat.
England In Anglo-Saxon Britain, there had been few, if any, Jews, who mostly came with other Flemish migrants in the wake of the Norman conquest. They reached a population of estimated 5,000, around half the population lived in London while the rest moved to York, Winchester, Lincoln, Canterbury, Northampton and Oxford. In 1144, the first instance of the charge of ritual murder occurred in Norwich, with at least more incidents happening in the rest of the twelfth century. The launch of the Third Crusade was also accompanied by the charges of ritual murder and pogroms. In 1229,
King Henry III of England forced Jews to pay half the value of their property in taxes, following burning of the
Talmud in Paris and the
Tartars' capture of Jerusalem. King Henry III of England ordered Jewish worship in synagogue to be held quietly so that Christians passing by would not have to hear it, giving an order that Jews may not employ Christian nurses or maids, nor may any Jew prevent another from converting to Christianity. A few years later, French King
Louis IX expelled the Jews from France, ending the Tosaphists period. Most Jews went to Germany and further east. At the end of the thirteenth century, the Jews were no longer profitable to English
King Edward I. In 1275, he passed a law making ursury illegal and later linking it to blasphemy. In the 1280s, in order to pay the ransom for his cousin Charles of Salerno, Edward confiscated the property of the Jews in his lands in Gascony before expelling them in 1289. The next year, claiming widespread evasion of his law against ursury, Edward I also grabbed all assets of the English Jews and
expelled them from England. By that time, only 2,500 Jews were left who produced a total of £9,100.
Later immigration to Germany In 1267, the
Vienna city council forced Jews to wear the
Jewish hat, in addition to the yellow badge. Later in the century, a blood libel in
Munich resulted in the deaths of 68 Jews, and an additional 180 Jews were burned alive at the synagogue, following another mob in
Oberwesel, Germany. In 1348, hundreds of Jews were burned and many were baptized in
Basel. The city's Christian residents converted the synagogue into a church and destroyed the Jewish cemetery there. Pope Clement VI issued an edict repudiating the libel against Jews, saying that they too were suffering from the Plague. In 1385,
German Emperor Wenceslaus arrested Jews living in the
Swabian League, a group of free cities in Germany, and confiscated their books. Later, he expelled the Jews of Strassburg after a community debate.
Benedict XIII banned the study of the Talmud in any form, as institutions forced Christian sermons and tried to restrict Jewish life completely, and a few years later Pope Martin V favorably reinstated old privileges of the Jews. After more Jews were expelled from France, some remained in
Provence until 1500. In 1422, Pope Martin V issued a bull reminding Christians that Christianity was derived from
Judaism and warned the Friars not to incite against the Jews, but the Bull was withdrawn the following year. By the end of the 15th century, the
Inquisition was established in Spain. Around 1500 Jews found relative security and a renewal of prosperity in present-day
Poland.
France Philip IV of France ordered all Jews expelled from France, with their property to be sold at public auction, and some 125,000 Jews were forced to leave. Similar to accusations made during the
Black Plague, Jews were accused of encouraging
lepers to poison Christian wells in France. An estimated five thousand Jews were killed before the king,
Philip the Tall, admitted the Jews were innocent. Then,
Charles IV expelled all French Jews without the one-year period he had promised them, as much of Europe blamed the Black Plague on the Jews and tortured them so they would confess that they poisoned the wells. Despite the pleas of innocence of
Pope Clement VI, the accusations resulted in the destruction of over 60 large and 150 small Jewish communities. Under the Almoravids, though Jewish religious scholarship and poetry continued, Jews became increasingly marginalised and were pushed out of civil services. From that time onward, Jews were often safer in northern Spain under Christian rulers. The situation worsened under the
Almohad Caliphate, who brought most of Muslim Spain under their control by 1172. They were intolerant towards both Christians and Jews and, similar to the Visigothic kings, forced Christians and Jews to choose between conversion or death. Many Jews fled the Muslim controlled portion of Iberia either to more tolerant Muslim countries such as
Ayyubid Egypt and Syria or fled over the frontier into Christian Spain. Questioning the sincerity of those Jews that converted to Islam, the Caliph
Yaqub al-Mansur still treated them as if they were dhimmis, not only limiting their civil rights but also having them wear distinguishing clothing consisting of blue-black garments, ludicrous caps and the
shikla. By the end of the twelfth century, the Almohad persecutions had ended the flourishing Jewish settlements in Muslim Spain. Through some of the Christian world, Jews enjoyed privileges at the hands of nobles and even kings that were almost equal to the local Christians. For example, in the
Crown of Aragon, in 1241,
King James of Aragon issued a decree that the Jewish community of Barcelona would be given the right to elect members of the Jewish community to police itself and investigate Jewish criminals and crimes within the Jewish community. Once the elected police force caught a criminal, they were given the right to impose fines (paid to the crown, not the Jewish community), banish them from the Jewish quarter, or even banish them entirely from the city of Barcelona. Further, these elected members were given the authority to judge cases between Jews in a court of law. In 1271, King James issued a similar decree with a sense of increased urgency which suggests that things had become volatile among the Jewish community, or that the perception of the Jewish community was overwhelmingly one of a state of chaos. This second decree also increased the rights of the council to whatever punishments they deem to be "convenient to the community," including any punishments that they deemed fit.
Jewish-Christian relations The relations of Jews and Christians were fraught with tensions about the death of Jesus and the Christian perception of Jewish obstinacy in refusing to accept the only faith the Christians knew in the world. The pressure on Jews to accept Christianity was intense. Recent years have seen a debate among historians on the nature of Jewish-Christian relations in medieval Europe. Traditionally, historians focused on the trials Jews had to endure in this period. Christian violence towards Jews was rife, as were ritual murder accusations, expulsions, and extortion. However, recently historians have begun to show evidence of other relationships between Jews and Christians, suggesting Jews were more embedded into Christian society than was previously thought. Since the time of the
Middle Ages, the
Catholic Church upheld the
Constitutio pro Judæis (Formal Statement on the Jews), which stated: Jonathan Elukin is one historian who thinks in this vein, as elucidated in his book
Living Together, Living Apart. He shows that during the Crusades, some Jews were hidden and protected from being attacked by Christians. Some Jews worked in Christian villages. There were also several cases of conversion to Judaism as well as interfaith marriages. One such case was Jacob ben Sullam, a Christian looking to become a part of Jewish society. He chose to "slaughter [himself]" of his Christian identity in the hope of being accepted as a Jew in the Jewish community. As Christians sought conversion to Judaism, a number of Jews similarly wanted to convert to Christianity. For example, Herman, a Jew who adopted Christianity to the degree that his family worried that he would reject his Jewish heritage completely. Herman's conversion startled the rabbis and made them fear losing other Jews to Christianity. The close bonds between Jewish and Christian neighbors led to Jewish communities thriving in some Christian cities. Though strict constraints were placed on Jews in the thirteenth century by the French monarchy, Jews continued to experience a stable living situation. Although the French monarchy prohibited the creation of Jewish religious centers, friendly relations with Christians enabled them to build a synagogue in Béziers in 1278. For Marcus times of persecution were rarities and few and far between. Historians interpret this as Jews feeling comfortable living and working in places surrounded by Christians. Another example some historians use to show Jewish attachment to their place in Western Christendom is the Jewish expulsion in France. After they were expelled in 1182, they returned in 1198. However, some historians do not agree with this view of history. Historian
Daniel J. Lasker does not see the relationship of Christians and Jews in the same light. He contends that the expulsions Jews in Spain faced in 1492 were the product of the revolts seen a century earlier in 1391. Even though the relationship might have been positive, it ended on a negative note. The expulsions of the Jews in various regions is that ending, with a wide range of reasons behind them not just religion. The reason for the Jews returning to regions they were expelled from was not acceptance as to what happened, but a sense of comfort and familiarity. In the
High Middle Ages, many European Jews were specialized as merchants, money-lenders or artisans, as they were largely excluded from
craft guilds and barred from owning land. In contrast, Julie L. Mell insists on the fact that much of the Jewish population was left at the lower end of the urban economic scale. The first instance of ritual murder accusation in France occurred in 1171 in the town of
Blois. The story follows a Jewish man and a Christian servant watering their horses at the same bend in a river. The Jewish man accidentally scared the Christian's horse with the white corner of his undershirt and the servant rode away, upset about the frightened beast, and told his master he saw the Jew throw a child in the river. The Christian master, who hated Jews, took this opportunity and had the Jew unlawfully accused of murder. The Christians took the man, along with the Jews who had tried to free him, beating and torturing them in the effort that they would abandon their religion. To no avail, the Jews were burned alive. In some cases, the authorities spoke against the accusations, for example
Pope Innocent III wrote in 1199: No Christian shall do the Jews any personal injury, except in executing the judgments of a judge, or deprive them of their possessions, or change the rights and privileges which they have been accustomed to have. During the celebration of their festivals, no one shall disturb them by beating them with clubs or by throwing stones at them. No one shall compel them to render any services except those which they have been accustomed to render. And to prevent the baseness and avarice of wicked men we forbid anyone to deface or damage their cemeteries or to extort money from them by threatening to exhume the bodies of their dead. The charge was circulated that they wished to dishonor the Host, which Roman Catholics believe is the body of
Jesus Christ. ==Later Middle Ages (1350–1550)==