Introducing Joss Stone received generally positive reviews from music critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a
normalised rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, the album received an
average score of 64, based on 22 reviews.
Rolling Stones Christian Hoard felt that "[t]here are a couple of moments on Stone's third album when she clobbers a melody with enough showy vocal oomph to make even
Christina Aguilera fans squirm. But for the most part, Stone employs her remarkable instrument with focus and nuance on
Introducing, and the result is an album full of solid
pop-wise
R&B." Mike Joseph of
PopMatters commented that "[i]t's certainly the first great R&B album I've heard this year. While there's still the occasional affectation that I wish she would get rid of, Stone has grown into her music quite a bit." Tim Perlich of Canadian newspaper
Now noted, "With the fast-maturing Stone gaining greater control of her powerful pipes and a recent breakup adding to the underlying sexual tension while stoking the creative fire, the craftily reconstituted 70s R&B concept works exceptionally well."
Blender critic
David Browne wrote, "Nearly every song is a souped-up retro-
funk tornado, pushed along by
blaxploitation-soundtrack guitars, scenery-chewing backup singers and, of course, Stone's husky pipes." Both
Billboard and
Entertainment Weekly praised Saadiq's production; the former called it "brimming with horns and seriously in-the-pocket rhythm sections, but there are also enough
hip-hop touches and contemporary arrangements to keep the tracks in the now", while the latter opined that "[h]e brings a strong focus to
Introducing Joss Stone, blending the digital crispness of modern R&B with Stone's preferred flavors of retro: swooping Motown-style strings, girl-group background vocals, gutbucket
soul guitar." In a review for
AllMusic,
Stephen Thomas Erlewine found that "
Introducing does sound brighter, fresher than her other two albums, pitched partway between
Amy Winehouse and
Back to Basics Christina yet sounding very much like
Texas at their prime, but it's all surface change." ==Commercial performance==