Buffalo Bills Tuel was not invited to the
NFL Scouting Combine or selected in the
2013 NFL draft. Tuel signed with the
Buffalo Bills. On August 26, 2013, Tuel was tentatively named the starting quarterback for Week 1 of the
2013 season. Whether Tuel would start depended on the status of current first-string quarterback
EJ Manuel (drafted in the first round of the 2013 draft), who was recovering from an operation on his knee. On September 4, the Bills determined Manuel was healthy enough to return to play and named him starting quarterback, relegating Tuel to the second string position. Had Tuel started that game, he would have been the first undrafted rookie quarterback to start a season opener without any prior professional football experience since at least the 1950s. He received some notoriety for being a relatively unknown player when he was named as the Bills' starting quarterback—in fact, this Wikipedia page did not exist when the announcement happened. Tuel played his first NFL game on October 3, 2013, against the
Cleveland Browns shortly after Manuel hurt his knee halfway into the 3rd quarter. Tuel's first pass was incomplete, due to a defensive interference. Late in the 4th quarter, Tuel threw an interception that was returned 44 yards for a touchdown, effectively ending any chance of a Bills comeback. Following Tuel's performance, the Bills called up
Thad Lewis from the
practice squad and named him starter, again demoting Tuel to second-string. Coincidentally, the Bills also brought back punter
Brian Moorman, who wore Tuel's original number 8 in the twelve seasons before Tuel's arrival; Tuel gave Moorman his number 8 and changed to number 7. Tuel made his first NFL start on November 3, 2013, a 23–13 loss to the
Kansas City Chiefs. Tuel and Lewis competed for the second string position during the 2014 preseason and training camp; Tuel won the competition, and Lewis was released on August 26. The move was short-lived; the team released all of its backup quarterbacks, including Tuel, in final preseason cuts on August 30, leaving only Manuel on the roster (the team then signed
Kyle Orton, who came out of a brief retirement, to serve as Manuel's only backup). Tuel was signed to the Bills' practice squad shortly afterward. Tuel was waived by the Bills on May 29, 2015.
Jacksonville Jaguars Tuel was claimed off waivers by the
Jacksonville Jaguars on June 1, 2015. He was waived on August 29, 2015. On October 13, Tuel was re-signed to Jacksonville's practice squad. On December 9, 2015, Tuel was released from the Jaguars' practice squad. ==Career statistics==