While in Florida, García guest starred in
seaQuest DSV,
Second Noah, and
Superboy and several films of the week. While attending high school, she was re-discovered by
Nickelodeon and starred for three seasons as Samantha on
Are You Afraid of the Dark?. She commuted from Florida to Montreal, Canada, where the show was filmed. She was cast at the age of fifteen on the 1994 television drama
Party of Five, playing the recurring character Hallie. She had a recurring role on
Freaks and Geeks (1999–2000) portraying the character of
Vicki Appleby, the popular freshman
cheerleader who spent
seven minutes in heaven with the ultimate geek,
Bill Haverchuck (
Martin Starr). but later quit school to pursue acting full-time, moving to Los Angeles, California. García went on to portray the character of
Cheyenne Hart-Montgomery, Reba's (
Reba McEntire) oldest daughter on
The WB/
CW sitcom
Reba (2001–07). She was featured on the short-lived
CBS comedy
Welcome to the Captain. Beginning in the fall of 2008, she starred as Megan Smith in the CW series
Privileged (originally known as
How to Survive the Filthy Rich). On the big screen, García was seen in the comedy spoof
Not Another Teen Movie. In December 2009, she guest starred as Maggie,
Ted Mosby's college buddy on
How I Met Your Mother. García starred in the ABC sitcom
Better with You. The show centers on two sisters who were at different points in their romantic relationships: one was unmarried and in a long-term relationship, and the other (García) got married after getting pregnant from a
one-night stand. It was canceled on May 13, 2011. Garcia guest-starred on
The Penguins of Madagascar in the episode "The Officer X Factor/Love Hurts", which aired on February 12, 2011. In 2012, Garcia appeared in four episodes of the
USA Network dramedy Royal Pains as a
nephrologist treating Jack O'Malley (
Tom Cavanagh). In 2013, during season three of the series
Once Upon a Time she began playing the recurring role of Ariel from
The Little Mermaid. == Business ventures ==