On February 1, 1782, Huddy was given command of the blockhouse, a small fort at the village of
Toms River that was built to protect the local salt works. The salt was needed to cure meat destined for American troops, and the Toms River was an important launch point for Patriot privateers. On March 24, a large, irregular force of approximately 80
Loyalists overwhelmed Huddy's small band of defenders and took the fort. Huddy was transferred to a military prison ship in New York harbor. He was then taken from British custody by a band of Loyalists headed by Captain
Richard Lippincott, ostensibly to make a prisoner exchange. It was reported in a letter to Washington that Huddy maintained his innocence in the death of Phillip White, and that he "should Dye Innocent, and in a good Cause, and with uncommon Composure of Mind and fortitude prepared Himself for his End", and that "Capt. Huddy dyed with the firmness of a Lyon." The next morning, Patriots found Huddy's body hanging from the gallows, cut it down, and took it to
Freehold, where they buried him at
Old Tennent Church. Over 400 people gathered to protest his execution and sent a petition to General
George Washington, demanding retribution by execution of a British officer of similar rank if Lippincott was not surrendered. Both Washington and General
Henry Clinton condemned the hanging, and the British forbade the Board of Loyalists from removing any additional prisoners. Clinton's successor
Guy Carleton later abolished the organization. ==Asgill Affair==