In 1951 while
McCarthyism goes unchecked, Peter Appleton is a
Hollywood screenwriter. His agent Leo Kubelsky and his attorney Kevin Bannerman relay he was labeled a
communist for attending a "Bread Instead of Bullets"
antiwar club meeting during college to impress a girl he was wooing. Peter's new film
Ashes to Ashes is delayed for months, his movie star girlfriend Sandra Sinclair dumps him, and the studio drops his contract. Peter gets drunk and drives up the California coast, accidentally crashing off a bridge to avoid an
opossum. After striking his head, he regains consciousness on the beach, experiencing
amnesia. Stan Keller finds and helps Peter to the nearby town of Lawson. Doc Stanton tends his wounds as Sheriff Cecil Coleman is called. Harry Trimble arrives, believing Peter is his son Luke who went
missing in action during
World War II, sometime after
D-Day. Coleman tells Doc to "break it to her gently," referring to Doc's daughter, Adele. Hesitantly, Peter accepts being treated as Luke by the townspeople, led by Mayor Ernie Cole, and gets to know Adele, who had been engaged to Luke the night before going to war nine and a half years earlier. Peter helps renovate the derelict
Majestic movie theater. Veteran Bob Leffert is skeptical that Peter is Luke, fearing he will disappoint the town further, after having lost sixty young men to the war. Nevertheless, Peter's theater restoration invigorates the townspeople, and encourages Mayor Cole to display a memorial commissioned by President
Franklin D. Roosevelt, which Lawson did not previously have the heart to display. Peter's disappearance reinforces
House Un-American Activities Committee member Elvin Clyde's belief that Peter is a communist, sending federal agents Ellerby and Saunders to apprehend him. They pick up the trail when Joey finds Peter's car on the beach. Peter's amnesia ends while
The Majestic shows his first movie
Sand Pirates of the Sahara, and he discovers his name on the poster. Harry suffers a heart attack, which Stanton says will be fatal. Peter decides to allow Harry to die believing he really is his son Luke. After the funeral, Peter tells Adele the truth, which she already suspected. Federal agents and state police officers arrive with Leo, Ellery and Saunders, who reveal Peter's identity to the whole town. Frank is summoned to the congressional hearing in Los Angeles. Leo advises Peter to name other communists to "purge" his own "indiscretions." The Majestic's usher Emmett reveals, he knew Peter wasn't Luke after hearing Peter play "that fine roadhouse boogie" at the "welcome-home dance" because Luke played classical music, not jazz. But Emmett remained silent because "the town needed Luke" to recover from post-war grief. Peter goes to the cemetery to return Luke's
Medal of Honor to his memorial case. He and Adele argue. He decides to submit to the committee to be removed from the
Hollywood blacklist, but she wants him to fight as Luke would have done. At the train station, Doc gives Peter a package from Adele. It is a copy of the
Constitution and Luke's WWII letter telling Adele his readiness to die to honor their cause, to beat down bullies who rise up. In Los Angeles, Peter changes his mind and testimony to the committee, which is broadcast by radio to Lawson citizens. He confronts Clyde and Congressman Doyle, giving an impassioned speech about American ideals, reading from the
First Amendment to the United States Constitution concerning
freedom of speech, while holding Luke's Medal of Honor. Peter sways the crowd and newsreporters, compelling the committee to release him. Kevin tells Peter, it was Lucille Angstrom, for whom he attended the "Bread Instead of Bullets" meeting, who named him to the committee. Peter resumes his screenwriting career, but he rejects the studio executives' ridiculous ideas and leaves Hollywood. After sending Adele a telegram, Peter returns to Lawson, fearing Adele will not be there to greet him. Instead, he receives a hero's welcome from the town's citizens, who have come to respect him as an individual. Peter resumes management of
The Majestic, marries Adele, and they have a son together, as revealed by photos in their apartment above the theater. ==Cast==