, who played Baron Scampia Scarpia, in the 1890
parody,
Tra-La-La Tosca The most famous adaptation of
La Tosca was
Giacomo Puccini's Italian opera
Tosca which premiered in Rome on 14 January 1900 with
Hariclea Darclée in the title role and went on to successful premieres in London, New York, and Paris. The Paris premiere at the
Opéra-Comique in 1903 was performed in a French translation by
Paul Ferrier with Sardou himself taking charge of the rehearsals. Unlike Sardou's play, Puccini's opera has achieved an enduring popularity. More than 100 years after its premiere,
Tosca ranks sixth in the list of most frequently performed operas worldwide, and has over 100 commercial recordings as well as several film versions (see
Tosca discography). Puccini had seen
La Tosca in Italy when Bernhardt toured the play there and asked his publisher,
Giulio Ricordi, to negotiate with Sardou for the adaptation rights. Before Puccini obtained the rights, the composers
Alberto Franchetti and
Giuseppe Verdi had both expressed interest in turning
La Tosca into an opera, although Verdi thought the ending had to be changed. Puccini's
librettists,
Luigi Illica and
Giuseppe Giacosa, likewise tried (unsuccessfully) to convince Sardou to accept a new ending, with Tosca going mad rather than committing suicide. The Sardou ending stayed, but Illica and Giacosa did make several significant changes to the play, primarily to tighten the action. Earlier,
La Tosca had been adapted into an English novel by Arthur D. Hall in 1888, and had two adaptations for traditional
Japanese theatre, both performed in 1891. In the Japanese adaptations, the famed story-teller,
San'yūtei Enchō, set the work during the period of the 1837 rebellion by
Ōshio Heihachirō, while
Fukuchi Gen'ichirō adapted the play for
Kabuki theatre. There were at least four
silent film adaptations. A hand-coloured version starring Sarah Bernhardt was made in 1906 by Le Film d'Art, a French film company run by
André Calmettes and
Charles le Bargy. Bernhardt was so displeased with her performance that she refused to allow its release and tried to buy up and destroy all the negatives. Le Bargy and Calmettes then re-filmed the work, this time with
Cécile Sorel as Tosca, and released it in 1908. The Bernhardt version re-surfaced and was released in 1912 by
Universal Pictures. There was also a 1918 version by
Paramount Pictures with
Pauline Frederick as Tosca. Only fragments remain of the Italian film made the same year starring
Francesca Bertini. Later films tended to be adaptations of Puccini's opera rather than Sardou's play with the notable exception of
Carl Koch's 1941 Italian film
Tosca starring
Imperio Argentina as Tosca and
Rossano Brazzi as Cavaradossi.
Jean Renoir originally worked with Koch on the adaptation, but had to leave Italy at the outbreak of World War II. The film was released in the US in 1947 as
The Story of Tosca. Shortly after the first London performances of
La Tosca,
Francis Burnand and the composer Florian Pascal wrote a musical parody of the play entitled
Tra-la-la Tosca or The High-Toned Soprano and the Villain Bass. In their
burlesque version, Tosca murders Scarpia in the "Cafe Romano allo Strando", stabbing him with a huge rolled-up restaurant bill and then places one of the dish covers over his face. Cavaradossi, instead, is executed by a phalanx of photographers. The show premiered at London's
Royalty Theatre in January 1890 and ran for 45 performances, with the critic Cecil Howard pronouncing it one of Burnand's finest efforts. Burnand had previously parodied Sardou's
Féodora as
Stage-Doora (1883) and
Théodora as ''The O'Dora'' (1885), both of which ran at
Toole's Theatre in London. In 2004,
Lucio Dalla composed an Italian
musical,
Tosca, Amore Disperato (
Tosca, Desperate Love), based largely on the structure of Puccini's opera, but with elements from Sardou's play. The setting was updated to modern times with costumes by
Giorgio Armani.
Tosca, Amore Disperato continues to be performed in Italy and was broadcast on
RAI television in June 2010.
Differences between Sardou's play and Puccini's opera The number of characters is sharply reduced in the opera, and the work shortened to three acts, leaving out much of the political motivations of the protagonists. In the opera, Angelotti and Cavaradossi already know each other. In the play, they had never met before, thus allowing considerable scope to explain their histories and backgrounds to each other. The roles of Tosca's maid and Cavaradossi's two servants were eliminated as were most of the characters in Act 2, although some of them such as the Marquis Attavanti and
Queen Maria Carolina are alluded to in the opera. The gathering at the
Farnese Palace in the presence of Queen Maria Carolina, Act 2 of the play, was eliminated. The setting of Act 2 and the events of Acts 3 and 4 in the play were then combined into the second act of the opera, which involved several significant changes. 's set design for the
Farnese Palace in the premiere production of Puccini's
Tosca Unlike the play, Scarpia shows Tosca the Marquise Attavanti's fan in Act 1, where Puccini's librettists contrive to have her return to the church following the departure of Angelotti and Cavaradossi. In the opera, both Cavaradossi's interrogation and torture and Scarpia's subsequent murder take place in the Farnese Palace. In the play, Cavaradossi's interrogation is set at his country house, where he was captured, while Scarpia's murder takes place at his apartment in the Castel Sant'Angelo. The news of the Austrian defeat at Marengo which formed the climax of Act 2 in
La Tosca does not emerge in the opera until after Cavaradossi has been captured and tortured. Thus Scarpia is able to listen to Tosca's uninterrupted performance of the cantata (heard in a distant room of the palace). Early audiences (especially in the United States and Britain) sometimes balked at the realism in Sardou's play, especially Cavaradossi's screams while he is being tortured off-stage. In Puccini's version, his screams are likewise heard by the audience. However his death by firing squad is even more explicit, occurring on stage in full view of the audience, rather than off stage as in the play. Tosca's final words before committing suicide in the play are addressed to Spoletta and his men. When he vows to send her to join her lover, she cries ("I am going, scoundrels!"). In the opera, her final words are addressed to Scarpia: ("O Scarpia, [we meet] before God!"). The opera also gives Cavaradossi a
soliloquy in the final act, "
E lucevan le stelle" ("And the stars were shining"), in which he reflects on his past happiness with Tosca and his impending death. Other relatively minor changes include Puccini's addition of a singing shepherd boy as Cavaradossi awaits his execution and a change of the church in Act 1 from Sardou's
Sant'Andrea al Quirinale to Puccini's
Sant'Andrea della Valle. The latter actually has a potential hiding place for Angelotti. Its
Barberini chapel incorporates a shallow chamber separated from the main part of the chapel by a grille. ==References==