In 1905,
Heinrich Conried, manager of the
Irving Place Theatre and the Metropolitan Opera House, brought Abarbanell to New York. Her American debut came that October at Irving Place in
Frühlingsluft (
Spring Breezes) followed a month later playing Lt. Von Vogel in
Jung Heidelberg (
Young Heidelberg), a comic opera with music from
Carl Millöcker and book by Leopold Krenn and
Karl Lindau. Her debut at the Metropolitan Opera House as Hänsel to
Bella Alten's Gretel came on November 25, 1905. After honing her language skills Abarbarbanell made her English-speaking debut at the
Garden Theatre on Christmas Day, 1906, as Lisa in the musical comedy
The Student King. In March 1907 she began a tour in
The White Chrysanthemum, but left by the end of the month following a dust-up over a dressing room issue with co-star
Edna Wallace Hopper. That October she played the lead character Sonia in
Franz Lehár's
The Merry Widow at the Colonial Theatre, Chicago.
The Merry Widow, which ran simultaneously at Chicago and New York, was a huge success, netting an estimated one million dollars over its first year. The New York production was performed initially at the
New Amsterdam Theatre and starred
Ethel Jackson until she fell ill in March 1908 and was replaced by Abarbanell. After a successful national tour in
The Merry Widow, Abarbanell replaced Elgie Bowen as Nellie Vaughan in the romantic musical
The Love Cure at the New Amsterdam in October 1909. At the same venue the following August, Abarbanell played the title role in the musical comedy
Madame Sherry, which had a run of 231 performances and was later taken on tour. Abarbanell remained active on Broadway and in road productions for over two decades. Her most popular endeavor during this time was probably as Mademoiselle Martinet in
The Grand Duke, a comedy by
Sacha Guitry that was produced by
David Belasco at the
Lyceum Theatre.
The Grand Duke had a respectable run between November 1921 and March 1922 and a later road tour. Abarbanell last appeared on the Broadway stage at the end of January 1934 in the very short-lived play
Theodora, the Quean. ==Eduard Goldbeck==