In a 2014 affidavit, Giuffre alleged that in the early 2000s, as an 18-year-old, she had sex with Epstein and then-
Prince Andrew in an orgy, with eight other girls who "appeared to be under the age of 18" and did not speak English.
Buckingham Palace denied the allegation. A lawyer for Epstein called Giuffre's allegations of orgies "old and discredited". Giuffre also made controversial allegations that
Bill Clinton and
Al Gore had visited the island. In 2011, she told
Daily Mail reporter Sharon Churcher that
Ghislaine Maxwell "went to pick up Bill in a huge black helicopter that Jeffrey had bought her" and "I used to get frightened flying with her but Bill had the Secret Service with him and I remember him talking about what a good job she did". In a declassified 2011 email, Epstein wrote: "[T]hese stories are complete an[d] utter fantasy, I don't know and have never met Al gore, Clinton was never on the island".
Alan Dershowitz argued Giuffre's story was improbable, as the Secret Service would not allow Maxwell, "then a novice helicopter pilot", to fly a former president. A 2017
Freedom of Information Act request for Secret Service records found no evidence that Clinton had visited Little St. James. A spokesperson for Clinton has denied he ever visited the island. In a 2016 deposition,
Sarah Ransome said she visited Little Saint James with Epstein in 2007, Ransome said she had an argument with Epstein and Maxwell about her weight, causing her to attempt to swim off the island, before Epstein assembled a search party to bring her back. In a 2021 interview with
NPR, she said her attempt to swim off the island was "after I'd been raped three times and after Ghislaine had taken my food away". In her 2021 book, Ransome writes that she attempted to swim off the island after Ghislaine "snatched away" her dinner and replaced it with cucumbers and tomatoes. Little Saint James has been given numerous nicknames in the media, such as "Isle of Babes", "Island of Sin", and "Epstein Island". According to a 2019
Vanity Fair article, two unidentified locals on
St. Thomas said they saw Epstein board his plane in 2019 with girls "who appeared to be under the age of consent". == Aftermath and new ownership ==