Early years Sullavan succeeded in getting a chorus part in the Harvard Dramatic Society 1929 spring production
Close Up, a musical written by Harvard senior
Bernard Hanighen, who was later a composer for
Broadway and Hollywood. The President of the Harvard Dramatic Society, Charles Leatherbee, along with the President of Princeton's
Theatre Intime,
Bretaigne Windust, who together had established the University Players on Cape Cod the summer before, persuaded Sullavan to join them for their second summer season. Another member of the University Players was
Henry Fonda, who had the comic lead in
Close Up. In the summer of 1929, Sullavan appeared opposite Fonda in
The Devil in the Cheese, her debut on the professional stage. She returned for most of the University Players' 1930 season. In 1931, she squeezed in one production with the University Players between the closing of the Broadway production of
A Modern Virgin in July and its tour in September. She rejoined the University Players for most of their 18-week 1930–31 winter season in Baltimore. Sullavan's parents did not approve of her choice of career. She played the lead in
Strictly Dishonorable (1930) by
Preston Sturges, which her parents attended. Confronted with her evident talent, they ceased their objections. "To my deep relief," Sullavan later recalled, "I thought I'd have to put up with their yappings on the subject forever." A Shubert scout saw her in that play as well and eventually she met
Lee Shubert himself. At the time, Sullavan was suffering from a bad case of
laryngitis and her voice was huskier than usual. Shubert loved it. In subsequent years Sullavan would joke that she cultivated that "laryngitis" into a permanent hoarseness by standing in every available draft. In March 1933, Sullavan replaced another actor in
Dinner at Eight in New York. Movie director
John M. Stahl happened to be watching the play and was intrigued by Sullavan. He decided she would be perfect for a picture he was planning,
Only Yesterday. At that time Sullavan had already turned down offers for five-year contracts from
Paramount and
Columbia.
Universal Pictures offered Sullavan a three-year, two-pictures-per-year contract at $1,200 per week. She accepted it and had a clause put in her contract that allowed her to return to the stage on occasion. Later in her career, Sullavan signed only short-term contracts because she did not want to be "owned" by any studio.
Hollywood Sullavan arrived in Hollywood on May 16, 1933, her 24th birthday. Her film debut came that same year in
Only Yesterday. When she saw herself in the film's early
rushes, she was so appalled that she tried to purchase her contract for $2,500, but Universal refused. In his November 10, 1933, review in
The New York Herald Tribune,
Richard Watts, Jr. wrote that Sullavan "plays the tragic and lovelorn heroine of this shrewdly sentimental orgy with such forthright sympathy, wise reticence and honest feeling that she establishes herself with some definiteness as one of the cinema people to be watched." Sullavan's next role came in
Little Man, What Now? (1934), a film about a couple struggling to survive in impoverished post–World War I Germany. Universal was reluctant to produce a film about unemployment, starvation and homelessness, but
Little Man was an important project to Sullavan. She would list the film appearance among the few Hollywood roles that afforded her a great measure of satisfaction. In
The Good Fairy (1935), Sullavan was able to illustrate her versatility. During the production, she married its director,
William Wyler. King Vidor's
So Red the Rose (1935) dealt with people in the postbellum South and preceded the publication of
Margaret Mitchell's bestselling novel
Gone With the Wind by one year and the blockbuster
film adaptation by four years. Sullavan played a childish Southern belle who matures into a responsible woman. In
Next Time We Love (1936), Sullavan played opposite the then-unknown
James Stewart. She had been campaigning for Stewart to be her leading man, and the studio complied for fear that she would stage a threatened strike. The film dealt with a married couple who had grown apart over the years. This was the first of four films made by Sullavan and Stewart together. '' (1938) In the comedy ''
The Moon's Our Home'' (1936), Sullavan played opposite her ex-husband Henry Fonda as a newly married couple.
Dorothy Parker and
Alan Campbell were recruited to improve the script's dialogue, reportedly at Sullavan's insistence. Her seventh film,
Three Comrades (1938), is a drama set in post–World War I Germany. She gained an Oscar nomination for her role and was named the year's best actress by the
New York Film Critics Circle. Sullavan reunited with Stewart in
The Shopworn Angel (1938). Stewart played a sweet, naive Texan soldier on his way to fight in World War I who first marries Sullavan. Sullavan's ninth film was
The Shining Hour (1938), in which she played the suicidal sister-in-law of
Joan Crawford's character. Crawford insisted on the casting of Sullavan even though Louis B. Mayer warned Crawford that Sullavan could steal the picture from her. In
The Shop Around the Corner (1940), Sullavan and Stewart worked together again, playing colleagues who unknowingly exchange letters with each other. In 1940, Sullavan also appeared in
The Mortal Storm, a film about the lives of ordinary Germans during the rise of Adolf Hitler; it was her last film with Stewart.
Back Street (1941) was lauded as among the best performances of Sullavan's Hollywood career, a film for which she ceded top billing to
Charles Boyer to ensure that he would take the male lead part.
So Ends Our Night (1941) was a wartime drama in which Sullavan, on loan to
United Artists for a one-picture deal from Universal, played a Jewish exile fleeing the Nazis. '' (1938) A 1940 court decision obliged Sullavan to fulfill her original 1933 agreement with Universal, requiring her to appear in two more films for the studio. These films would be
Back Street (1941) and the light comedy
Appointment for Love (1941). ''
Cry 'Havoc''' (1943) was Sullavan's last film with
M-G-M. After its completion, she was free of all film commitments. She had often referred to MGM and Universal as "jails."
Films with James Stewart Sullavan's co-starring roles with James Stewart are among the highlights of their early careers. In 1935, Sullavan had decided on doing
Next Time We Love. She had strong reservations about the story, but had to "work-off the damned contract." The script contained a role that she thought might be ideal for Stewart, who was the best friend of Sullavan's first husband, actor Henry Fonda. Years earlier, during a casual conversation with some fellow actors on Broadway, Sullavan predicted that Stewart would become a major Hollywood star. By 1936, Stewart was a contract player at MGM but securing only small parts in B-movies. Sullavan, under contract with Universal, suggested that the studio test Stewart as her leading man. He was borrowed from MGM to star with Sullavan in
Next Time We Love. The inexperienced Stewart had been nervous and unsure of himself during the early stages of production, and director
Edward H. Griffith, began bullying him. However, Sullavan believed in Stewart and spent evenings coaching him and helping him scale down his awkward mannerisms and hesitant speech that were soon to be famous. "It was Margaret Sullavan who made James Stewart a star," Griffith later said. Bill Grady of MGM said: "That boy came back from Universal so changed I hardly recognized him." Gossip in
Hollywood held that Sullavan's husband
William Wyler was suspicious about her rehearsing with Stewart privately. When Sullavan divorced Wyler in 1936 and married
Leland Hayward that same year, they moved into a colonial house just a block away from that of Stewart. Stewart's frequent visits to the Sullavan/Hayward home soon restoked the rumors of his romantic feelings for Sullavan. Sullavan and Stewart's second film together was
The Shopworn Angel (1938).
Walter Pidgeon, who also starred in the film, later recalled: "I really felt like the odd-man-out in that one. It was really all Jimmy and Maggie ... It was so obvious he was in love with her. He came absolutely alive in his scenes with her, playing with a conviction and a sincerity I never knew him to summon away from her." Sullavan and Stewart appeared in four films together between 1936 and 1940 (
Next Time We Love,
The Shopworn Angel,
The Shop Around the Corner and
The Mortal Storm).
Later years in New York City, November 1944 Sullavan took a break from films from 1943 to 1950. Throughout her career, Sullavan seemed to prefer the stage to the movies. She felt that only on the stage could she improve her skills as an actor. "When I really learn to act, I may take what I have learned back to Hollywood and display it on the screen," she said in an interview in October 1936 (when she was doing
Stage Door on Broadway between movies). "But as long as the flesh-and-blood theatre will have me, it is to the flesh-and-blood theatre I'll belong. I really am stage-struck. And if that be treason, Hollywood will have to make the most of it." Another reason for her early retirement from the screen (1943) was that she wanted to spend more time with her children, Brooke, Bridget and Bill (then 6, 4 and 2 years old). She felt that she had been neglecting them and felt guilty about it. ==Personal life==